Active Citizens, Civil Society, Economy & Trade, Environment, Headlines

ENVIRONMENT-UKRAINE: Group of Seven Talks on Chernobyl Closure

Judith Perera

CHERNOBYL, Ukraine, Nov 2 1995 (IPS) - Thursday’s round of talks in Kiev on funding the closure of the Chernobyl nuclear power plant marked the first real progress in a long running row between Ukrainian leaders and the Group of Seven (G-7) world’s richest nations.

Previous discussions have stalled — ostensibly over Ukraine’s insistence that closure of the plant would cost at least four billion dollars, far more than the G-7 is prepared to offer.

Mikhail Umanets, head of the State Committee for Nuclear power (Goskomatom) says, “The figure of four billion which Ukraine is requesting for closure of Chernobyl is peanuts”. It is not invented, he insists, and can be justified even using Western estimates of cost.

He points out that according to a joint Ukrainian-U.S. study 1.4 billion is needed just to decommission the plant and a further 400 million to build a high-voltage electricity generating substation for the Ukrainian capital Kiev.

In addition, according to another foreign-led group, the European Alliance consortium, 1.6 billion is needed to build a new sarcophagus to protect the crippled fourth reactor.

An explosion and fire at the fourth reactor in 1986 triggered the world’s most serious nuclear accident to date, spreading radioactive dust across central and northern Europe. The west has sought its closure ever since.

Closing Chernobyl would cause serious problems for Ukraine’s power system, says Umanets, since it is currently producing over five percent of the country’s total electricity output. Chernobyl remains one of Ukraine’s most efficient and economic power plants at a time when the whole power generation industry is in crisis.

The power plants are owed a total of 31,500 billion karbovantsi (1.8 billion dollars) in unpaid bills for provided power and themselves owe another 32,500 billion karbovantsi in fees for supporting services and fuel. Power shortages and power cuts are commonplace in Ukraine and the national grid is operating at a frequency of 49.3 kilohertz instead of the normal 50kHz.

Ukraine is totally dependent on Russia for supplies of oil and gas and its coal industry is antiquated and in need of modernisation. “In this situation the West is asking us to close our cheapest source of power,” says Umanets in exasperation.

However the real difficulty delaying agreement with the G-7 is rooted in the deep differences of opinion which divide both sides to the talks.

The G-7 countries — Britain, Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan and the United States — hold a range of different opinions on the need for immediate closure of Chernobyl with the most intense pressure reportedly coming from Germany and Canada.

On the Ukrainian side, President Leonid Kuchma agreed earlier this year to close Chernobyl by the year 2000. In this he has the backing of Environment Minister Yuri Kostenko who is also responsible for nuclear safety.

However Goskomatom and the management of the Chernobyl plant led by its powerful director Sergei Parashin, want to keep the plant operating up to the end of its design life. Parashin has assumed personal responsibility for the 5,000 plant operators and their families who live in the new town of Slavutich some 50 kilometres from the station.

But prior to this week’s meeting agreement for closure appeared to have moved closer with prime minister Yevhen Marchuk backing away from the four billion dollar demand.

He said there was no point in naming a figure. “Perhaps it will be more, perhaps less. The figure of four billion dollars frightens people,” he told local reporters.

This enabled the talks to consider the practicalities of closure with Ukraine putting forward a four-stage decommissioning plan. Stage One, to be completed by the year 2000, includes construction of a new waste storage plant and waste disposal facility.

Stage Two, up to 2003, will see the power units closed down and their fuel removed. In the third stage, up to 2004, equipment would be decontaminated and in the final stage, up to 2006, the power units would be mothballed.

Talks also covered ways of compensating Ukraine for the loss of the power units. The G-7 rejected earlier Ukrainian proposals for the construction of a gas-fired plant to replace Chernobyl, they suggested instead a more comprehensive plan to include completing Ukraine’s half built nuclear power units at other plants, renovating thermal plants and increasing productivity at existing hydroelectric plants.

The G-7 team were pleased with the previous round of talks, in October. “This was the first time we really talked turkey on the issue” of shutting down Chernobyl, a G-7 envoy told IPS in Kiev. “We still have a lot of problems to solve yet, but it was very constructive.”

But the Ukrainians came away very frustrated. “We went into these talks ready to take decisions, even hard ones for us, but the G-7 sent only technicians who had no power to decide anything,” one official commented. Parashin expressed his “disappointment” with the G-7 team.

According to Goskomatom Deputy Director Nur Nigmatullin, Ukraine is now asking the West for 3.2 billion dollars to help with the Chernobyl closure rather than four billion. Western sources say the most that is on offer is 2.2 billion dollars.

But whatever the outcome it is clear that Chernobyl will be closed sooner or later. The clean-up and decommissioning problem is not going to go away and Ukraine’s need for electricity will increase in coming years. the solution will clearly have to take all these factors into account.

Chernobyl’s Unit 1 was closed last week as a result of a fault in the refuelling mechanism which has since been repaired. The incident has been rated at zero on the International Nuclear Events ‘accident scale’ and the reactor will be restarted shortly. It came back on line only on Oct. 18 after extensive repair and maintenance work.

Despite having only one unit operating in September, the Chernobyl plant exceeded its power output targets by 4.9 percent generating 708.1 million Kwh of electricity during that month.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Active Citizens, Civil Society, Economy & Trade, Environment, Headlines

ENVIRONMENT-UKRAINE: Group of Seven Talks on Chernobyl Closure

Judith Perera

CHERNOBYL, Ukraine, Nov 2 1995 (IPS) - Thursday’s round of talks in Kiev on funding the closure of the Chernobyl nuclear power plant marked the first real progress in a long running row between Ukrainian leaders and the Group of Seven (G-7) world’s richest nations.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags