Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Angeline Oyog
- On the day five North Africans were acquitted of terrorism charges after a painstaking investigation and trial in Belgium, experts over the border in France asked why alleged Algerian bomber Khaled Kelkal never lived to appear in court.
Kelkal, 24, was killed Friday by paratroopers called in after a major manhunt by police around the south-eastern city of Lyons. His dying moments as he was shot to death as he lay wounded but still armed on the street, were filmed and broadcast worldwide.
But the scale of the operation staged to find him has led several experts to ask why Kelkal could not have been taken alive and brought to trial.
“We remain extremely cautious, but we also have reason to ask what exactly the mission of the gendarmes was,” said Jean-Claude Bouvier, secretary-general of the Union of Magistrates. “It was as though they were searching for a confrontation that could have only ended in the death of an essential witness.”
Kelkal, whose fingerprints were found on an unexploded railway bomb in August, was linked to six bombings attributed to Algeria’s Armed Islamic Group (GIA) that have killed seven and injured over 100 since July 25. The GIA is fighting to overthrow the military- backed government in Algeria, a former French colony.
He was also implicated in the murder of moderate imam Abdelbaki Sahraoui, a co-founder of the Algerian Islamic Salvation Front (FIS), in Paris in July. Some 170,000 copies of his portrait had been ciruclated in an effort to track him down. At one point over 700 police were hunting him on the hills surrounding Lyons.
“People are wondering whether the real mission of the authorities was to kill,” said Lahaj Thami Breze, president of the Union of Islamic Organisations in France, “so as to muddy the path of the real people behind the bombings.”
“We, of course, condemn all acts of terrorism, but we do wonder whether the police did not have the means to simply arrest the suspect and make him talk.”
“His death has left unanswered several questions,” added Mouloud Aounit, secretary general of the Movement against Racism and for Friendship among Peoples, “who Kelkal worked for; were all the bombings the work of the GIA or were they manipulated by the Algerian secret service; or was there only one team of bombers?”
Fears that troops simply shot-to-kill an enemy of the state echo protests at the killing of three unarmed Irish Republican Army members in Gibraltar by British troops in 1988 — condemned by the European Court as a violation of human rights last week.
The three IRA members were known to be planning a bomb attack on the British colony, but were allegedly allowed onto British territory so they could be more easily cornered and assassinated.
The killing of Kelkal also contrasts with the Belgian handling of a case involving Algerian radicals that ended Tuesday.
Thirteen North Africans were accused of membership of the GIA and various terrorist activities, as was Kelkal. The 13 — eight Algerians, three Moroccans, a Libyan and a Tunisian — arrested in March, included former Algerian university professor Ahmed Zaoui.
Zaoui, 34, said by Belgian state security to be a GIA leader, was sentenced to death in absentia by an Algerian court in 1992, admits contacts with the GIA, but denounces terrorism. A Belgian court Tuesday acquitted five of the 13 including Zaoui, saying there was not enough evidence linking him to the GIA. He will now be deported when a country can be found to accept him.
Police raids on the group’s hideout in March netted weapons, munitions, false ID papers and radio equipment and propaganda literature.
Kelkal was shot dead in Lyons while waiting at a bus stop. He fired on the approaching paratroopers who shot back, wounding him. Lying on the ground, Kelkal fired his revolver once more only to be shot to death by the troops, who later invoked ‘self-defence’.
The killing was followed by three nights of rioting in the Lyons working class suburb of Vaulx-en-Velin, Kelkal’s home.
Bouvier found it “curious” that despite deploying large numbers of troops and specially equipped helicopters, the suspect could not be taken alive. “How was it possible,” he asked. “That from the moment the fugitive was identified, localised and cornered, several gendarmes could not take alive a man who was already wounded and fallen to the ground?”
Aounit noted that Interior Minister Jean-Louis Debre immediatly closed the case by attributing all the bombings to Kelkal, including the first and most deadly one at the Paris St Michel subway. Earlier reports had suggested that other bombers were to blame for the subway outrage, which killed seven.
“It would seem that Debre has been a little imprudent in attributing all the bombings to Kelkal,” said Thami Breze. “We would have liked have heard the conclusions of the justice department as well.”
“Instead of the testimony of Kelkal, the French have only the declarations of Debre to hear (as evidence)” complained the French daily Le Monde. It suggested that France had violated the principle of presumption of innocence until proof of guilt in this case.
“This manner of action has left many people bitter and deeply perturbed,” added Aounit. “Surely could have been other ways of going about it. We are under the rule of law and people have the right to justice. This is the minimum.”