Tuesday, November 17, 2026
MAHESH UNIYAL
- HUMAN RIGHTS ACTIVISTS, LEGISLATORS AND A GROUND SWELL OF PUBLIC OPINION HAVE FORCED THE INDIAN GOVERNMENT TO REVISE A DECADE-OLD INTERNAL SECURITY LAW WHICH IS WIDELY SAID TO HAVE TURNED ENFORCERS INTO INSTRUMENTS OF TERROR.
PRESSED BY POLITICAL OPPONENTS AND WITH AN EYE ON IMMINENT POLLS, PRIME MINISTER P.V. NARASIMHA RAO’S ADMINISTRATION IS PREPARING A MILDER VERSION OF THE LAW TO BE TABLED IN PARLIAMENT NEXT MONTH, NEWSPAPERS HERE REPORT.
LAST WEEK, MORE THAN 100 MEMBERS OF PARLIAMENT, INCLUDING LEADING RULING PARTY LAWMAKERS, URGED THE PREMIER TO MAKE BASIC CHANGES IN THE 1985 TERRORIST AND DISRUPTIVE ACTIVITIES (PREVENTION) ACT (TADA).
“IT IS TIME TO PUT AN END TO THE ABUSE OF HUMAN RIGHTS AND THE ASSAULT ON HUMAN DIGNITY PERPETRATED IN THE NAME OF TADA,” THEY SAID IN A SIGNED MEMORANDUM TO RAO.
TADA, INTRODUCED AS A TEMPORARY MEASURE IN THE THEN TROUBLED NORTHERN BORDER STATE OF PUNJAB AND ITS SURROUNDING PROVINCES TO KEEP MILITANT SIKH SEPARATISM FROM SPILLING OVER, WAS LATER EXTENDED TO THE REST OF INDIA. THE LAW EXPIRES IN MAY.
PRIME MINISTER RAO TOLD A PUBLIC MEETING LAST MONTH THAT TADA WOULD BE REPEALED IF STATE GOVERNMENTS CONTINUED MISUSING IT. HE ALSO ADMITTED IN A MEDIA INTERVIEW THAT THE LAW WAS ABUSED AT TIMES, BUT WAS CONSIDERED NECESSARY WHEN IT WAS ENACTED.
ACCORDING TO UNNAMED SENIOR OFFICIALS QUOTED BY NEWSPAPERS, THE CENTRAL LAW MINISTRY HAS ADVISED SCRAPPING THE TADA PROVISION OF PICKING UP A SUSPECT WITHOUT GIVING HIM OR HER THE CHANCE TO BE HEARD.
THE CHANGED LAW WILL ALSO EXEMPT WOMEN, CHILDREN AND THE AGED AND MAKE IT NECESSARY FOR ENFORCERS TO PROVE ACTUAL INVOLVEMENT OF SUSPECTS IN TERRORISM OR RELATED ACTS. IN ITS PRESENT FORM, TADA CAN REQUIRE THE ACCUSED TO PROVE INNOCENCE.
TADA IS CRITICISED FOR ITS SWEEPING DEFINITION OF TERRORIST AND DISRUPTIVE ACTS TO INCLUDE A RANGE OF VIOLENT AND NON-VIOLENT PUBLIC AND PRIVATE ACTIVITIES AND EVEN THE ACT OF SPEAKING.
THE ACCUSED HAS TO BE PRODUCED BEFORE AN EXECUTIVE AND NOT A JUDICIAL MAGISTRATE, CAN BE DETAINED FOR 180 DAYS, EXTENDIBLE TO A YEAR. CHARGESHEETS NEED NOT BE FILED FOR A YEAR, WHILE CONFESSIONS TO THE POLICE CAN BE ADMITTED AS EVIDENCE.
NEW DELHI, WHICH HAS LONG FACED FLAK FROM DOMESTIC AND FOREIGN RIGHTS WATCHDOGS OVER TADA, WAS RECENTLY ASKED BY TWO U.N. REPORTS TO URGENTLY REVIEW THE LAW.
INDIAN CIVIL RIGHTS GROUPS ALLEGE THE LAW IS USED MORE OFTEN TO INTIMIDATE INNOCENT CITIZENS, OFTEN, THE RULING PARTY’S OPPONENTS AND EVEN GREEN ACTIVISTS.
“IT IS A BAD LAW WHICH NEEDS TO BE REPEALED AND HAS NO PLACE IN A DEMOCRACY. THE STATE HAS A RIGHT TO FIGHT TERRORISM, BUT THROUGH THE PROCESS OF JUDICIAL ACCOUNTABILITY,” SAYS RAVI NAIR OF THE NEW DELHI-BASED SOUTH ASIA HUMAN RIGHTS DOCUMENTATION CENTRE.
NAIR SAYS THAT POLITICIANS WOKE UP TO TADA MISUSE AFTER THEY “FELT A PUBLIC GROUND SWELL” AGAINST IT, BUT THINKS THEY ARE USING REVISION BID AS JUST ANOTHER VOTE-CAPTURING PLOY.
INVESTIGATIONS BY LOCAL RIGHTS ACTIVISTS FOUND THAT EVEN 12- YEAR-OLD CHILDREN AND OLD WOMEN WERE BOOKED UNDER TADA. ACCORDING TO OFFICIAL STATISTICS, MORE THAN 75,000 PEOPLE HAVE BEEN CHARGED SINCE TADA’S ENACTMENT IN 1985.
THE GOVERNMENT CLAIMS THAT MOST TADA DETAINEES HAVE BEEN FREED OVER THE PAST YEAR AFTER THEIR CASES WERE REVIEWED.
BUT RIGHTS GROUPS QUESTION THIS. THE LIST OF TADA DETAINEES IS STILL A STATE SECRET, WITH EVEN PARLIAMENT KEPT IN THE DARK, RIGHTS ACTIVIST NAIR TOLD IPS.
HIS GROUP VISITED TADA JAILS IN JODHPUR IN THE WESTERN STATE OF RAJASTHAN AND SRINAGAR IN NORTHERN KASHMIR TWICE OVER A ONE YEAR PERIOD, BUT THE SAME PRISONERS LANGUISHED THERE. NONE OF THE 240 TADA ACCUSED IN THE INDIAN CAPITAL’S TIHAR JAIL HAS BEEN FREED.
THE GOVERNMENT IS UNDER PRESSURE TO MODIFY TADA SINCE 1993, WHEN THERE WAS A POLITICAL OUTCRY TRIGGERED BY THE HEAVY USE OF THE LAW, SPECIALLY AGAINST THE MINORITY MUSLIMS IN THE WAKE OF COUNTRYWIDE COMMUNAL VIOLENCE AND THE SERIAL BOMB BLASTS IN THE WESTERN METROPOLIS OF BOMBAY IN MARCH 1993.
TADA CAUGHT THE PUBLIC IMAGINATION AFTER THE ARREST OF THE POPULAR, YOUNG FILM STAR SANJAY DUTT, SON OF A RULING PARTY MEMBER OF PARLIAMENT AND FORMER FILM ACTOR SUNIL DUTT.
THE YOUNGER DUTT WAS BOOKED UNDER TADA FOR HAVING AUTOMATIC GUNS WHICH WERE ALLEGEDLY USED IN HINDU-MUSLIM CLASHES IN BOMBAY IN EARLY 1993 AND FOR HIS LINKS WITH THOSE BEHIND THE BOMB BLASTS.
IN A SUBMISSION TO THE COUNTRY’S APEX COURT LAST YEAR WHEN IT WAS HEARING A SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION BY DUTT’S LAWYERS, INDIA’S HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION SAID: “THE IMPLEMENTATION OF TADA SEVERELY AFFECTS THE HUMAN RIGHTS OF NUMEROUS CITIZENS AND THIS IS A MATTER OF LEGITIMATE CONCERN TO THE COMMISSION WHICH HAS BEEN CONSTITUTED FOR BETTER PROTECTION OF HUMAN RIGHTS.”
THE SUPREME COURT HAS RULED THAT TADA IS VALID, BUT SAID CHANGES MUST BE MADE IN THE LAW.