Headlines, Human Rights, Middle East & North Africa

PALESTINE: Hebron – Clock Counts Down To Chaos

Deborah Horan

HEBRON, West Bank, Nov 7 1996 (IPS) - Omar Abu Mata is used to living next door to hostile neighbours.

Three houses away from heavily-armed Israeli Jewish settler compounds in the heart of the city, he says he sees settlers run through the market overturning vegetable carts, spitting and throwing garbage on passers-by.

One year ago, he says, his ten-year-old daughter Reem came home from school crying after settlers stormed the elementary school near their compound, beat the headmistress and tore down a Palestinian flag.

When Israeli soldiers finally redeploy from Hebron, the last of eight cities slated for Palestinian self-rule, his wife predicts violence: “I’ll keep my children indoors,” she says. “We’ll lock the door and hide under the bed.”

Though Egyptian president Hosni Mubarak, quoted in Cairo’s government press on Thursday, has denied reports that an Israeli- Palestinian accord on withdrawal from Hebron could be signed next week in Cairo, Israeli troops are still expected to move this month.

They will be replaced by 400 armed Palestinian police. The Israeli’s anticipated departure has cast an oppressive air of foreboding over the town, on both sides. Most Jewish settlers and their unwilling Palestinian hosts are bracing for war.

“Palestinians do not want peace with the settlers in the city,” explained a Palestinian taxi driver. “They did not come in peace and they are not welcome.”

Down the street from the taxi stand, settler Noam Federman agrees that there will not be peace: “They’ll shoot us, we’ll shoot them,” predicted the 27-year-old ex-spokesman of the outlawed militant Kach movement.

The troop pullout is complicated because of the presence of the settlers. Israeli soldiers are heavily deployed in the city to ensure their security, which Palestinians say takes precedence over the economic and social needs of the Arab inhabitants.

The desolate street on which Taha’s barber shop is located is an example. The street was closed after U.S. born Jewish settler Baruch Goldstein gunned down 29 Palestinians praying at a mosque here two years ago. Israeli soldiers stationed at both ends of the kilometre-long main street behind barbed wire and concrete blocks allow only settler vehicles to pass. Palestinian cars are not allowed through.

Most of the once-thriving shops along the road are now boarded up. The adjacent vegetable market is also closed. Palestinians want both opened when Israeli soldiers pull out of the 80 percent of the city that was agreed upon in the Oslo accord so that life can return to normal.

Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu wants both to remain closed to better ensure the ‘safety’ of the settlers lodged in between. The dispute is one of the main sticking points holding up an agreement and has soured relations between settlers and their reluctant neighbours.

Settlers predicting bloodshed have called on the Israeli government not to leave the city. Surrounded by 100,000 Palestinians, settlers accuse the government of creating a climate of desperation. Settler leader Rabbi Moshe Lebinger, known for his extremist views, alluded to Goldstein and to Yigal Amir, slain Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin’s assassin, as examples of what can happen if settlers feel pushed to the wall.

“We have exercised restraint over the years but I cannot guarantee we will show the same restraint if they go ahead with this suicidal redeployment,” Levinger told Israeli officials on a tour of the city two weeks ago.

But Netanyahu’s choices are limited. He entered office last May after unseating Oslo architect Shimon Peres by promising Israelis ‘peace with security’. He also obligated his right-wing government to fulfill a peace agreement it despises.

As the first aspect of the Oslo accords to be implemented by Netanyahu since his upset victory in May, the Hebron redeployment is seen as a litmus test of his commitment to the accords.

It is also a barometer for stability in a region where stagnation on the political front can quickly deteriorate into violence.

Without movement on the Hebron deal the future of the already faltering peace agreement with the Palestinians remains bleak; Israel’s prospective relations with its Arab neighbours hangs in the balance.

Under pressure from U.S. and Arab allies, and from his own nervous business community, Netanyahu has pledged to carry out the troop pullout with modest security improvement for the settlers.

Along with the market and main street remaining closed, Netanyahu is demanding that Palestinian police patrol their streets, leaving their weapons behind at their base, and that Israeli soldiers be allowed into Palestinian-controlled areas of the city if the security need arises.

Palestinians call these demands “humiliating” and refuse to agree to make changes to the agreement on the city that was signed with Israel’s previous government. “We have an agreement,” said Palestinian negotiator Saeb Erekat. “We’re waiting for them to implement it.”

In a town that has become a focus of both Jewish and Arab anger, the impending redeployment could ultimately shatter the fragile peace being sought by pragmatic voices on both sides.

Hebron’s Palestinians are known to support the militant Hamas and Islamic Jihad organisations more than in other West Bank towns. A recent poll conducted by the Palestinian Centre for Public Opinion found that 44 percent of Hebron’s residents would not heed a call by Palestinian President Yasser Arafat to stop military operations and suicide attacks against Israel.

The same poll found one in four was “not enthusiastic” about the long-awaited arrival of the Palestinian Authority — a number that roughly corresponds to the estimated support in the city for Islamic opposition groups.

Hebron’s Jewish settlers are characterised as ultra-nationalist and religious ‘fanatics’, even by Israelis on the right of the political spectrum. A recent pamphlet they issued was signed, ‘The Friends of Baruch Goldstein’, and indicates their collective attitude.

“There is no question they are extremists,” said Ehud Sprinzak, an Israeli political analyst who specialises in the politics of the Israeli right-wing. “Most Israelis would agree that they are dangerous troublemakers.”

“The problem is that the settlers have a mindset that all the Palestinians are out to get them,” said Sprinzak. “This is the danger because if you think like that about the other side, then you want to be the first to strike.”

Palestinians say the presence of a tiny community of well-armed and anxious settlers is courting disaster. More than 80 percent say they cannot coexist peacefully with the settlers in the city, according to polls. “The settlers must leave our city,” said Hebron’s Palestinian mayor Mustafa Natshe. “This is the only solution.”

Some Palestinians speak of stockpiling arms to counter the settlers. Though it is unlikely with Israeli security measures that many have succeeded, they say there are weapons around. “Anything can be bought with enough money,” said one man in the market.

But most say they have no choice but to trust their incoming police force and the scaled-down Israeli army presence to keep order once 80 percent of the city comes under Palestinian control.

“We will leave it to our policemen to protect us if there is any violence,” said Abed Qawasmeh, a Palestinian construction worker. “If the settlers make trouble, we hope the Israeli soldiers will stop them. Otherwise, our soldiers will have to step in.”

There has already been violence. Ten days ago, unnamed settlers threw petrol bombs at a Palestinian home, injuring five residents. In another incident, they shot at a Palestinian home, without causing injury.

Once redeployment does take place, some settlers say they hope to scuttle the agreement by stirring up trouble. Federman, who has been operating what he calls “civilian patrols” in Arab areas of the city, says he plans to continue them after Israel leaves with the hope of enticing the soldiers back.

In the strained atmosphere of Hebron, that kind of provocation could set off an explosion. “The likelihood of violence between settlers and Palestinians is very high,” said Sprinzak. “Both sides anticipate it. There is a good chance it will be a self- fulfilling prophecy.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags