Europe, Headlines, Human Rights

TURKEY-HUMAN RIGHTS: Concern Over Trial of Alleged Killers

Nadire Mater

ISTANBUL, Jul 16 1996 (IPS) - International observers, in Turkey for the trial of 48 police officers accused of killing a young leftwing journalist, have expressed concern over the sudden change in the venue for the trial and postponement of its starting date.

Authorities shifted the trial of the men charged with killing Metin Goktepe to Aydin, 600 kilometres outside Istanbul, ostensibly because of security concerns. Observers are worried it could have an impact on the outcome.

Late last week, judges of Istanbul’s Penal Court accepted the request of the Ministry of Justice for the transfer, a hearing was told here Monday. At Monday’s hearing the court decided that the date for a second hearing should be decided by the local court. It suspended the trial until then.

“We originally saw the trial of the police officers as a positive sign and that is why we came here. But what we saw here arouses deep worries,” said Robert Menard, chair of Paris-based international journalists organization, Reporteres Sans Frontiers.

Menard said the development was “alarming”. He also expressed concern over the kidnapping of a key witness, who will now be unable to testify. “This is a negative sign for Turkey has been witness to deaths of 20 journalists since 1986,” he said.

And Kamil Tekin Surek, the lawyer of daily Evrensel, said: “The transfer of the trial of the accused police officers to Aydin is discouraging. We are suspicious of the outcome of the trial.”

Domestic analysts and international press freedom activists fear the court will be unable to remain free from pressure — official and unofficial given the nature of the case.

Goktepe, a reporter for the left-wing Istanbul daily Evrensel, was found dead outside Eyup district Sports Hall in January. He had been taken into police custody the previous day, detained as he followed a funeral procession for two political activists killed during a prison disturbance.

Local police authorities initially denied Goktepe had been detained. But media pressure forced the Ministry of Interior to launch an inquiry into the affair. Investigators discovered that the 28 year-old-journalist had been detained and beaten to death by local police officers and then dumped outside the Sports Hall.

Already delayed for six months, the startof the case has been delayed by lengthy legal procedures designed to protect security officials.

“The progreess of the case through natural and normal means will be a test for both Turkey and the Council of Europe and the EU,” said Menard. “It is a test for Turkish democracy. A test for commitment to universal democratic principles and to international agreements.”

It will also test the European Parliament and the European Union, said Menard. The European Parliament had predicated Turkey’s inclusion in a Customs Union with Europe on improvements in basic liberties, said Menard. “We will be following how the EU is following Turkey,” he declared.

However, there were claims Monday that some of the witnesses had been threatened.

Deniz Ozcan, one of the witnesses who during investigation testified that Goktepe was beaten to death in police custody claimed that last weekn he was kidnapped by plainclothes police agents and tortured in order to withdraw his testimony.

“I was struck by a car on the way to metro in Istanbul’s sagmalcilar district,” Ozcan told IPS. “Then I was taken in the car where they covered my mouth with a piece of cloth. I fainted.”

“I opened my eyes in a mysterious house where I was continuously beaten for two days. They forced my head into a bucket full of water and threatened with death if I did not resign from testimony,” he claimed.

Ozcan joins 20 other witnesses, including police officers who pleaded guilty.

Nail Gureli, chair of Journalists Association of Turkey, who had run a vigorous campaign for Goktepe case is of the opinion that if media workers had not displayed utmost solidarity at the time Goktpe would have been added to a long list of “mysterious killings”.

“Goktepe too would have been believed to be ‘killed mysteriously’ just as 2,000 others who lost their lives during the last five years,” Gureli told IPS.

“Thanks to journalists’ solidarity and great pressure exerted on the parliament and officials, initial claims that he had died accidentally were withdrawn,” he said.

“The 2,400 members of the association for the first time in the organization’s history united around a common cause what affected a substantial change in the police’s attitude towards journalists,” says Gureli.

“It is the 189th day since Metin Goktepe’s death, but the actual hearing is yet to start,” he told IPS. “For the future of press freedom the conclusion of this trial is fatal. If these officers, whose crime is evidenced by the ministry of interior, are acquitted, the risk journalists will face in the future will certainly grow.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags