Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Nadire Mater
- Turkish prime minister Nemcettin Erbakan called it a “victory for Turkish democracy,” but the new Islamist premier’s narrow scrape through a hair-raising parliamentary session this week leaves the whole nation facing uncertainty.
Erbakan’s Welfare Party (RP) and its True Path Party (DYP) allies in coalition steered a wild path through a sometimes embarrassing session Monday, in which members of coalition and opposition parties crossed floors to vote with other sides.
“This is the victory of Turkish democracy,” said Erbakan in his address to the deputies after winning the ensuing vote of confidence 278 in support and 264 against with one abstention. Seven deputies went absent from the chamber.
“The government owes most to (former prime minister and DYP leader) Tansu Ciller who has displayed the courage to coalesce with the Welfare Party,” he added.
Ciller’s earlier alliance with Motherland Party (ANAP) leader Mesut Yilmaz failed to pass a confidence test in parliament after — following an appeal by Erbakan himself — the Constitutional Court ruled an absolute majority of 276 out of a possible 550 votes was needed to win a vote of confidence.
So Ciller, under pressure from corruption allegations and desperate to avoid a parliamentary inquiry, did a deal with Erbakan. Up to then she had fought hard against the RP, claiming that it would turn Turkey into a fundamentalist state; now she sits alongside its leader as foreign minister in its new cabinet.
But in spite of Erbakan’s boasts that the vote brings a spell of prolonged political crisis to an end, most analysts here believe that it only heralds a new period of instability and uncertainty.
Still unresolved are the basic contradictions between Erbakan’s election pledges of a new foreign policy line towards Islamic countries and the coalition’s pledge to maintain its present alliances with the West.
“I am sure there will be no essential change in Turkey’s general foreign policy lines,” noted professor Sule Kut of Marmara University. “Turkey’s diplomacy is in such disarray that under Erbakan it cannot be worse.” But she thought that Erbakan was not unknown in the West. “His potential is well known and his positions thoroughly studied.”
She doubted that he would make his entrance on the diplomatic stage with a trip to Damascus. Syria is complaining about Turkey abuse of regional water supplies and Turkey condemns Syrian tolerance of Kurdish guerrillas in areas under its control.
“He will probably start with Germany, but if it appears that it will not be too embarrassing for him, he go first to Washington,” she told IPS.
Similarly, although the coalition says it will comply with Turkey’s secular traditions, analysts doubt that Erbakan and his party will be able to long resist the call of their long-held ambition to bring Islamic doctrine back to Turkish civil affairs.
Like the classical Chinese strategist Sun Tsu “he is a master of deception and fooling,” says veteran diplomat Sukru Elekdag, former Turkish ambassador to Washington DC. “Erbakan seems to have planned his basic strategies and actual tactics masterfully so that he would finally establish an Islamic state,” he claims.
“The major aim of his strategy is establishing a single RP government, therefore his appraisal of Kemal Ataturk, the founder of secular republic and his lip service to Turkey’s alliances with the west are all part of his strategy.
Elekdag posited a complex plot in which Erbakan planned to fill the state bureaucracy with RP ‘cadres’ and push a populist economic policy under cover of his alliance with Ciller’s DYP, the final aim of which would be new elections and a overall victory for his party.
“Tansu Ciller knows all this but formed this government anyway, thereby betraying her supporters who voted for her as a defender of secularism.” Following the establishment of the coalition the RP deputies withdrew their support from parliamentary inquiry commissions formed to investigate Ciller’s ‘business activity’.
“I am concerned about a prospective Islamist takeover in the state bureaucracy, though I am not totally amazed at the RP’s rise,” conceded Kut. She felt that Erbakan would follow a careful domestic policy line and would put the brakes on his cadres’ calls for rapid changes towards Islamic rule.
However secular Turkish women remain deeply concerned by the prospects of living under an Islamist led government. “I am living in my own personal depression,” says Feryal Gurpinar, a sociologist from Ankara. “This is the beginning of darker days.
“It is normal that the government should be formed by the largest party in the parliament,” says Ayse Duzkan, a women’s rights activist from Istanbul. “Yet, political Islam is a major threat against women, and I am most worried about prospective measures against women’s rights.”
But Gurpinar did not anticipate a repeat of the furious public protests that greeted the RP’s victories in municipal elections last year. “The public is weary of fears and worries, and generally exhausted,” she said.
On the other hand Islamist woman intellectual Nezahat Bulac, while welcoming an Islamic presence in government for the first time since the 1970s, suspected that the Erbakan government will be short lived.
“Two opposite poles have coalesced in government. It is uncertain how long it will last,” she said. “Basic questions such as economic restructuring and the Kurdish question are unlikely to be solved even under this government,” she told IPS.
She hoped for small gains like the right of Islamist girl students to wear head cover in state schools and for religious seminary graduates to continue studies in national universities.
Erdal Kara, deputy chair of the socialist Freedom and Solidarity Party (ODP) also suspected the present coalition would not last.
“Such an unstable government will not be able to cope up with such burning issues as grave economic problems, the prolonged Kurdish war and corruption,” he told IPS. The effective collapse of the political centre in Turkey, he claimed, left the elites and the military in the wings plotting their own solution.
“The business community is pressing for a transition to a ‘national government’ in order to increase the pressure on organised labour, and the Army has no intention of stopping the war against the Kurds,” he said.
The Turkish armed forces are locked in bitter conflict against the guerrillas of the Kurdistan Workers Party in the country’s disputed south-east. At least 20,000 have died since 1984 and an estimated two million people have been forced from their homes.
“The military and president Sulyman Demirel are simply marking time to see out the last parliamentary alternative, in order to justify the ‘extraordinary measures’ that would follow,” he claimed.
He said new elections under new laws allowing smaller parties into parliament would allow broader party representation and a “genuinely democratic way out” of the crisis.