Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Nadire Mater
- To the surprise of supporters of traditional Turkish secularism, the country’s new Islamist led coalition government has received a calm response both at home and abroad.
Warnings of Turkish secular backlashes and international isolation dogged Islamist leader and new prime minister Necmettin Erbakan’s efforts to transform his Welfare Party’s lead position in parliament into a controlling role in a coalition government.
When the mainstream parties failed to unite themselves Erbakan got his chance, but since winning power and the prime minister’s seat on Jun. 28, Erbakan has only further downplayed his previous well-documented anti-EU, anti-NATO and anti-Western views.
Analysts have struggled to interpret his ever-changing positions on a range of issues and divine his real objectives.
“The Islamist Welfare Party (RP), in a single day shifts from programmes of autarchic ‘just order’ to endorsing liberal economics, from outright rejection of the military agreement with Israel to settling for its simple revision,” complained professor Nulifer Narli of Marmara University.
“Erbakan’s search for a compromise is more by-the-minute pragmatism than a philosophical transformation.”
“Everything in the Turkish political scene is out of order,” said Kurdish analyst Ahmet Zeki Okcuoglu. “Even myself, a political analyst, am fed up with these people. There are no rules any more!”
Okcuoglu is not alone in his frustration. “After all these series of widespread corruption and fraud cases among politicians Turkish public have turned their back to politics,” Narli observed. “As a reaction to the decay of the political centre they first turned towards radical parties, but now they have been demoralised and alienated by all Turkish politics.”
The low key public response to Erbakan’s accession last month contrasted dramatically with the furious secularist reaction that followed the party’s victory in 1994 local authority elections. Women’s groups in particular, in Istanbul and elsewhere, launched fierce anti-RP campaigns.
Hundreds of ‘Citizens’ Initiatives’ were started, aimed at countering Islamist threats to their secular life styles. However the newly-elected RP mayors took care to avoid policies likely to draw confrontation with the 80 percent of eligible voters who had not voted for them.
“The 1994 local elections were a shock,” said Narli, “but the election results also ripened Turkish public and generated a ‘wait- and-see’ mentality instead of one of outright confrontation.”
The response from the West was sanguine. “Turkey is not expected to withdraw from its commitments under international treaties,” said Washington Institute analyst Alan Makovsky, a prominent specialist on Turkey.
The Turkish business community was equally pragmatic. “The RP government guarantees the secularist character of Turkish democracy,” says Ishak Alaton, a business magnate of Jewish origin. “If the RP does not divert from the path of democracy fundamentalism will not constitute a threat for Turkey.”
Omer Laciner, a left wing political analyst from Istanbul, read the rise of the RP and the cool reaction to its assumption of power as more evidence of the collapse of the Turkish political centre.
“Tansu Ciller’s DYP and Deniz Baykal’s CHP, the twin pillars of the Turkish political centre are in decay and it has collapsed as a result. Now the establishment is seeking to restore the system by adopting the RP in the establishment.”
Okcuoglu also dismissed the widespread talk of a confrontation between the RP and the Turkish military establishment, which still exerts a baleful influence over the country’s politics. He saw the Turkish political parties as no more than extensions of the military establishment.
“The RP is the Islamist arm of the Turkish Army Staff, just there are leftist or nationalist political extensions within the Army high command,” he claimed. “Its assumption of power is endorsed by the Army. The Welfare Party are no fundamentalists.”
Turkish Chief of Staff General Ismail Hakki Karadayi’s comment on the RP government Tuesday was simple: that his army stayed out of politics.
But Okcuoglu warned: “The army is not just manipulating politics but also playing with society and history. When the rise of Islam in the region is considered I wonder what will they do if this play becomes real.”
And there is no clue how the two will work together to resolve the savage conflict in the country’s disputed south eastern territories where the army has battled the guerrillas of the Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK) for over a decade without resolution but with the loss of more than 20,000 lives.
The Islamist human rights organisation Mazlum-Der doubted that an improvement in the human rights situation would be likely in the near future under a RP government. “We will not lose our memory: We will be following the progress of the party in keeping its pledges,” said Mazlum-Der chairman Ahmet Mercan.
The one person to really feel the lash of public opinion in the wake of the RP’s accession is Ciller, who led her party into a pact with the Islamists in the face of rank and file opposition — apparently as a means of avoiding her alleged involvement in a corruption case from being subjected to parliamentary scrutiny.
Her party has suffered a massive drop in public support, down to below the parliamentary representation benchmark of ten percent.
Since the pact was announced the RP’s hardline supporters appear to have lost a little faith as well. Their polled support has fallen three percent from their election day peak of 22 percent in December.
“I was shocked by the RP victory in 1994’s local elections. But this Islamist sealed government based on lies and corruption simply disgusts me,” said Lale Argul, an office worker from Istanbul.
“I am not worried about Islamic radicalism. They are not radicals, just thieves like their predecessors. They will not last long together; not because they have political quarrels but because they will fight over the spoils of corruption.”