Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Dipankar De Sarkar
- Britain is in the throes of a debate on the future of the welfare state — a British invention — after the opposition Labour Party unveiled its “new deal” on welfare envisioning a role for the private sector.
Though the party insists talk of “an end to the welfare state” is a distortion of the reforms proposed by spokesperson on social security Chris Smith, commentators say the ideas are sufficiently far-reaching to warrant such a conclusion.
The concept of a welfare state, providing a cushion for citizens in times of great need, was laid down by the British economist and social reformer William Beveridge in his landmark ‘Report on Social Insurance and Allied Services’ in 1942.
In his treatise, Beveridge stipulated three “indispensable conditions of a good life” in post-War Britain — “lasting peace, a job while one can work (and) an income when one cannot work.” He called them “fundamental freedoms.”
One of the main features of the much-emulated report was social security. This was described by Beveridge as “a scheme of social insurance against interruption and destruction of earning power and for special expenditure arising at marriage, birth and death.”
Since its implementation by the post-War Labour government of Clement Attlee, Britain’s welfare state has solidly laid on services such as income support, unemployment benefit, universal pension and a national health service.
And support for the system came not only from Labour: it was Tory prime minister Winston Churchill who coined the phrase ‘cradle to the grave’ to describe the enduring, comprehensive and caring nature of welfare in Britain.
The intellectual and ideological underpinning is now in danger of being discarded.
On May 7, Smith, a rising star of party chief Tony Blair’s new- look shadow cabinet, outlined his vision of what the welfare state in Britain would have to offer under a Labour government.
Smith, charged with the task of thinking the unthinkable on welfare by a Labour leadership keen to discard its working class, cloth-cap image, explained that though a Labour government would subscribe to the underlying principles of Beveridge, it would advance those ideas.
“Surely it is time to get away from the sterile battle lines of public and private and, instead, to look at how the two can best work together in the interests of the citizen,” he said in an address to the Institute for Public Policy Research, a left- wing think-tank in London.
Responding to Labour’s critics on the left, Smith said, “….the principle must surely be that the state acts as the guarantor of all provision, the regulator of all provision, and the administrator of some. The welfare state is after all a framework which the government sets in order to enable citizens to achieve security; it is not a particular mechanism per se for delivering that security.”
Labour’s new deal on welfare seeks to created a new relationship between the welfare state and those who turn to it for help, ensuring they are treated as “citizens, not supplicants”. Further, it calls for a national assessment of poverty to guage the scale of the task facing a Labour government.
Finally, it provides for a change in the emphasis of social security from dealing with the consequences of poverty to tackling its causes by helping people back to work instead of keeping them dependant on state handouts.
Smith unfurled his plans on the very day the ruling Conservative Party set out its own controversial proposals for people to buy private insurance policies for old-age nursing care and social support.
Coming on top of recent reported plans by the Labour leadership to scrap child benefit for 16-18 year olds, it prompted The Guardian newspaper to declare “the end of the welfare state” in front-paged banner headlines the next day. Smith’s new deal, it reported, involved a growing role for private insurance.
“The coincidence of the Labour and Tory pronouncements marks a decisive and irreversible shift in the role of the welfare state,” the newspaper said. The moves marked a “bipartisan rejection of the comprehensive, state-run social insurance model of William Beveridge.”
Labour dismissed the newspaper’s criticism as a “gross distortion” of the Smith plan. A spokesman said: “It was the Labour Party that established the welfare state and it remains fully committed to maintaining and improving it. We are not talking about any end to the welfare state.”
Sally Witcher, director of the Child Poverty Action group said: “Chris Smith says the state cannot be regarded as a secure option, but then neither can the private sector be.”
Crucially, Smith won a semblence of support from from old age pensioners. The largest group of social security benefitiaries, they account for a huge 45 percent of welfare provisions.
Britain’s population of the aged has grown phenomenally in recent years. In 1942, the country had three million people who were retired. Today, the figure has risen to 10.5 million. Sometime between 2035 and 2040, the number is expected to reach its zenith of 13.5 million.
People are living longer — life expectancy is increasing at an average rate of three months every year. Rising living standards have meant heightened expectations of old age care.
Mervyn Kohler of the charity Help the Aged said Britain’s demographic pattern was changing so dramatically and changes in the welfare system were necessary.
“We live in a constantly changing welfare state. Its changing once again as far as older people are concered and we have to find new ways forward. The old arrangements were not adequate.”
“Society as a whole should make corporate arrangements for the old, rather than leave it to the individual,” Kohler said. “It is a risk that ought to be shared by society corporately.
But he added: “We are not getting a real sense of fundamental thinking that will take us into the next century. We are disappointed that neither party is being more imaginative. We need to re-invent the welfare state,” he added.