Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Analysis - Mario Osava
- The massacre of 19 landless peasants by Brazilian police last month has set the flags flying over the political left again and forced President Fernando Cardoso to bring the issue of land reform onto the front burner.
Cardoso has made a curious division between the Ministry of Agriculture and the Agrarian Reform portfolio – keeping the former under right-wing control while handing the latter to the left.
The new minister, who will attempt to settle 240,000 families on the land within three years, is Raul Jungman a former member of the Popular Socialist party (PPS), who previously worked in the institute dealing with government environmental policy.
For years politicians and analysts had been saying it was impossible for the Ministry of Agriculture, which mainly answered to the interests of landowners and large agricultural producers, to promote agrarian reform for the dispossessed.
With the new division of responsibilities, this contradiction has not disappeared, for while the issue has left the ministry it is still a bone of contention between the two ministers, and will have to be arbitrated at a higher level nearer to the president.
This experience had a historical precedent under former president Jose Sarney, who between 1985 and 1990, also created a specific ministry to bring in a National Agrarian Reform Plan. In those years, however, only 98,000 of the 1.4 million people awaiting settlement were actually provided with land.
The government of the time was a coalition representing a wide range of political opinion which had contributed to the return of democracy after 21 years of military rule. This mosaic finally contributed to the failure of the agrarian plan, along with other things, like the fight against inflation.
The Cardoso government appears to be more like Sarney’s regime every day because, although it was elected as an alliance of social democrats and liberals, now it is made up of seven important parties, the bulk of which are right-wingers. This broadening was carried out in order to reach the three-fifths majority needed to approve constitutional reform for the deregulation of the economy and to reduce the size and budget of State infrastructure.
The Movement of Landless Workers (MST), leading the peasant action, had a partial triumph with the national commotion caused by the April massacre and resultant ministerial changes. This meant the issue was now out of the hands of a Conservative agriculture minister, but the move was really a side-step as the president refused to take on direct personal management of the issue.
“Ambiguity is not resolved by the State” but by pressure from society, said the sociologist Herbert de Souza, champion of the social struggle in Brazil. He was the motivating force behind the campaign against hunger with its millions of volunteers, and another for “democratisation of the land.”
The battle for agrarian reform is a movement which “grew slowly, gradually and securely,” changing from the “small ripples to the current large waves” moving out of the economic field into the social and political, said De Souza.
This is a conflictive issue. In the early 1960’s the sociologist was at the centre of the disputes and political agitation which ended up with the military coup of 1964, one of the pretexts for which was the defence of the property threatened by communism.
Now the situation is different. The ‘unforeseen’ Landless Movement had religious roots, linked to the church, and was born more than a decade ago in an area of family farming in the south, from whence it spread throughout the nation, said Herbert de Souza.
The movement is made up of families who want a piece of land to set up a small farm. Women and children are obligatory in their demonstrations and in the land occupations, said de Souza. “They are the face of the Brazilian people.”
At the same time, these people are the part of the Brazilian population which “rejected begging in the cities, kept their dignity and are ready to die for that and for the land” he said.
The MST, frequently criticised for its radicalism, appears to have won the battle with public opinion, even in the cities. A series of recent surveys have shown that a majority support agrarian reform. The Catholic Episcopal Conference declared on Apr. 24 that “the agrarian reform, accmpanied by an agricultural policy aimed at the production of food for the people to eat is a (founding) demand of democracy itself,” and must be “taken on with courage and determination by the government.”
This current has, however, come up against opposition in Congress, which has not approved no laws to facilitate land distribution, in the legal system, which supports the “acquired rights” of the landowners, and with the police who cut down the landless people.