Economy & Trade, Europe, Headlines, Labour

TURKEY-HABITAT: May Day Protests Show up Rich-Poor Divide

Nadire Mater

ISTANBUL, May 8 1996 (IPS) - A week after bloody riots erupted in the streets of this sprawling city, the toll — three dead, 100 injured — is as haunting a residue as the socio-political sores which were exposed.

While the government moved to strengthen security measures and prevent a recurrence, labour unions and independent analysts focussed on the social inequality some critics see as an underlying cause of the incidents.

Demonstrators, police and bystanders were among victims of the May 1 confrontations. In addition to the deaths and injuries, more than 300 people were detained. The incidents happened after some 50,000 men, women and children gathered in and around Kadikoy square to mark May day.

The Contemporary Lawyers Association, 40 labour unions, Human Rights Association, some political parties (ODP: Liberty and Solidarity Party and EP: Labour Party) all demanded an official investigation into the way the May Day protests were handled.

“What happened during May Day was a police provocation,” said Mustafa Ucdere, chair of the Contemporary Lawyers Association after handing their appeal to the Istanbul Court. “The media and the government are ignoring the fact that three people were killed in Kadikoy.”

“The incidents took place because of the vacuum in government authority. Cabinet members are busy slinging mud at each other instead of discussing how try should serve the people”, commented Necmettin Erbakan, leader of the Islamic Welfare Party (RP).

On Tuesday, some groups urged the prosecutors office to take a look at possible failures in actions of the Minister of the Interior, the Governor and the Chief of Istanbul police.

The groups accused the police of intent to kill and of abuse of powers. Organised by four labour union confederations, the protests had attracted workers, civil servants, radical leftist groups, left wing parties such as pro-Kurdish HADEP (People’s Democracy Party), ODP and EP.

Included among the May Day protestors were supporters of the outlawed Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) openly carrying flags and pictures of their leader, Abdullah Ocalan and shouting “we are the PKK”.

Many PKK supporters and other radical leftist groups wore uniform- style costumes. Some covered their faces with bright, red scarfs. At the start, youngsters danced to guitar music. Workers performed folk dances with wives and children dressed in their best Sunday clothes.

The shootings of the two young persons by police reportedly happened after people entering the square refused to be searched by police.

In the afternoon, when the square filled up with people, the platform from which leaders of various labour organizations addressed the crowd was taken over by representatives of radical groups who wanted to announce the deaths that had occurred in the morning.

Events spun out of control. Crowds of mostly 16-17 year old boys and girls attacked shops with sticks. Several cars were burned. Cost of the damaged is estimated to be more than three million U.S. dollars.

“The power of the state will not show tolerance from now on,” said Primer Mesut Yilmaz after the riots. “The law will be applied to the letter.”

Trade union leaders blamed radical leftist groups for acting in an irresponsible way. But they also criticized the police, saying the security forces over-reacted by opening fire on the crowd.

“May 1, 1996 will go down in history as a day on which the union movement gave up it’s principles, and the radical leftist groups had an opportunity to make a show of force,” Sukran Soner, a columnist in the daily Cumhuriyet, told IPS.

“This could happen because of the political, social and union rights’ vacuum, the gap between the incomes of various groups and other injustices in the country,” Soner added.

Istanbul has 12 million residents. Nearly half the number live in poor housing conditions. At least 400,000 people come here every year, to seek a better life than what is available elsewhere in Turkey.

In reality, not much is on offer. Luxury villas sitting in an idyllic setting by the famous Boshporos cast shadows on nearby shantytowns but their inhabitants are worlds apart in terms of incomes and lifestyles.

Turkey’s per capita income is around 2,500 USD dollars. In Istanbul, the figure is 6,000 USD. But these figures tell only a part of the story. Economist Mustafa Sonmez, who recently wrote a book about Istanbul, notes that those who define Istanbul as a world city do not take account of the poverty.

“Five percent of Istanbul inhabitants’ per capita income is 11,000 USD. On the other hand 20 percent is 1,000 USD,” he told IPS.

“Shanty town youth has a real problem of integration to the modern city life,” said Sonmez. “They don’t want to be like their mothers and fathers, they want to be the like the others, the rich ones. But economically and socially it’s impossible.”

Normal municipal searvices are unavailable. There is no piped water. Sewage networks and transportation are inadequate. Often education and health services are missing as well. Cultural facilities are inadequate.

For example, 45 percent of young people of high school age work rather than attend school.

“Somehow those living in shanty towns are not accepted by those who consider themselves the real owners of Istanbul,” says Sonmez. “This isolation creates strong hatred anger, and in a way they burst.”

Events of May 1 have been very widely discussed in the columns of the daily newspapers and very often interpreted as proof of the frustration of the youth in the poor shantytowns of Istanbul.

“What we saw was children marching on the streets with very strong hatred as if they were demanding revanch,” says Oral Calislar, in his column in Cumhuriyet newspaper.

“But the state has to look at it’s own wrong doings first. How can you wait anything positive from the shanty-town youth in the country which is suffering from extra juridical executions, torture and undissolved murders.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags