Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Europe, Headlines

SLOVAKIA: Privatisation At Speed – But Lacking Transparency

Peter Fridner

BRATISLAVA, Mar 12 1996 (IPS) - The publication of a list of companies allowed to buy the Slovak state’s shareholdings in 54 key industries has triggered new criticism of Bratislava’s radically revised privatisation programme, now racing to its final stages.

A number of hitherto unknown private companies, many of them newly founded, edged out higher-bidding and longer established competitors in the race to buy up the state’s remaining stock in the 54 firms — conservatively valued at some 2.5 billion crowns (83.3 million dollars).

Earlier privatisations made most sales to management and workers at the enterprises involved, but some staff applicants have been disappointed this time round as the stock has gone to companies often unknown even to experienced workers in the industry.

In one case, an alliance of staff and management from the Biotika Slovenska Lupca plant in central Slovakia were beaten to the shares by a hitherto unknown company called GV Pharma of Presov — despite placing a bid three times higher.

The staff of Biotika, one of the largest penicillin producers in central Europe are still waiting for an explanation why their bid was rejected. They accuse the privatisation chiefs at the National Assets Fund (FNM) of Slovakia of fixing the tender to please political friends of the ruling coalition.

All they know about ‘GV Pharma’ is that it was recently created by managers at another large company, Slovakofarma Hlohovec. And in an angry letter to the trade union daily Praca, the Biotika team suggested theirs was not the only bid to be unfairly rejected.

“It would be of very great interest to us to learn who are these firms who have bought up the Medicaments Research Institute at Modra or Medika in Kosice — the biggest distributor of pharmaceutical products in Slovakia,” they wrote.

More controversy is expected when the government keeps its promise to privatise the country’s three leading banks and top insurance house — due by mid-February, postponed to the end of the month but still not implemented.

Critics of the process say the revised rules favour coalition friends, cover takeovers from potential rivals and betray the spirit of the original privatisation programme by denying employees the right to own and run their own firms. Most of all the critics condemn the lack of transparency in the FNM tendering process.

Some assets have been sold far below their realistic book value, while certain buyers have been given ten years to pay. Others have allegedly received preferential treatment on a rule requiring the payment of 17 percent of the total share purchase price up front.

And several critics say assets are being sold only to those deemed loyal to prime minister Vladimir Meciar’s Movement for a Democratic Slovakia (HZDS) or its coalition allies. Dozens of state company managers were allegedly replaced last year by allies of the government — just before the sales.

The HZDS coalition links the left-wing Alliance of Slovak Workers, hostile to privatisation, and the hardline nationalist Slovak National Party, which is hostile to foreign investment. The coalition may shortly also add the Party of the Democratic Left after its upcoming congress.

The FNM was originally founded in 1991 as a non-partisan executor agency in the manner of the civil servants of Germany’s Treuhandanstalt, founded to sell off former East German state property. Actual policy and terms were defined by the government under parliamentary scrutiny.

But Meciar changed all that turning over total responsibility for the programme to the FNM — including the exclusive right to decide what and how much industry should be sold and at what cost and to whom.

This left the programme, in the words of Stefan Balejik, president of the Supreme Supervisory Office, able to operate without public checks. The government opposition claimed the change excluded the ordinary worker from buying shares and hide from the public eye the ways in which the state property is being sold off.

In 1994 about 3.5 million Slovaks bought coupons for later exchange for shares in some 60 billion crowns (about two billion dollars) worth of state industries. But the scheme was cancelled by Meciar after he took office in late 1994.

The changes have speeded up the process dramatically. The dropping of the coupon plan in favour of an open market saw an estimated one billion dollars worth of sell-offs in the second half of 1995 alone, mostly to employees.

The reward for Slovakia, population just 5.3 million, where about 65 percent of gross domestic product is now generated by the private sector, has been a boost in growth to six percent in 1995, second only in east and central Europe to Albania.

The furious criticism of the cancellation plan was eased by a compensation offer offering each coupon holder a 10,000 crown (about 330 dollars) bond backed by FNM assets — also theoretically redeemable against apartment purchases or pension funds.

The bonds are due to mature in 2001, requiring the FNM to have up to 35 billion crowns to hand to pay out, aside from payments on interest floating at around 9.75 percent. This suggests that pressure will be on manager-owners to divert funds to pay off the FNM as the deadline approaches.

The diversion of cash flow to pay the FNM will only further weaken the newly privatised firms’ ability to invest in new technology, training and staff.

Meciar’s coalition has a strongly nationalist bent and its key justification for the scrapping of coupon privatisation in 1994 was to prevent supposed ‘foreign takeovers’. But foreign investment may become essential to allow Slovak growth to continue.

Starvation of capital to domestic industry and a shortfall of sale income in the FNM coffers could even force a devaluation of the 10,000 crown bonds before they mature.

The political furore that would follow — especially if those favourites allowed to buy up stock in undervalued companies later sell their shares for big profits — would be massive. But then it will be too late.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags