Environment, Europe, Headlines

ENVIRONMENT: Tar-Based Fuel Shipment Plan Hit By Welsh Oil Spill

Darius Bazargan

LONDON, Feb 28 1996 (IPS) - The anger and frustration left by this month’s oil disaster off the Welsh harbour of Milford Haven is deepening suspicion about plans to build a new port jetty to unload shipments of the Venezuelan tar-based fuel orimulsion.

“Orimulsion is particularly heavy and particularly sour,” says Adam Seymour, a researcher at the Oxford Energy Institute. “It is certainly a very nasty kind of crude oil — if there is such a thing — it’s very, very heavy,” he said.

“In a spillage it would ultimately cover the sea bed and probably kill all life at that level.”

The 50,000 tonnes of light crude or more spilled by the crippled Sea Empress after it ran aground earlier this month already threatens some of the most precious bird and sea life reserves in Britain with a ten kilometre long oil slick. As a result the thought of a possible orimulsion spill is concentrating opposition against the jetty scheme.

Gordon James of the environmentalist organisation Friends of the Earth (FoE) said their research shows that orimulsion behaved differently to oil in water. “It becomes suspended in water so you can’t scoop it up and clean it in the way that they claim they can do with oil,” he said.

FoE researchers claim orimulsion contains APEO, a chemical ‘surfactant’ that carry alkyl-phenol compounds that are very slow to biodegrade and accumulate in organisms through the food chain.

The compounds are said to mimic the female hormone oestrogen, damaging the reproductive organs of birds, fish and potentially humans.

“The impact of big orimulsion spills are unstudied, particularly large spills from a tanker accident,” said Tim Deere-Jones, a marine consultant to FoE. He says that even a ‘small’ 100 tonne spillage of orimulsion would have a strong effect.

“The 200 kilogrammes of alkyl-phenols this would involve is equivalent to about 100 years of discharge of similar chemicals in sewage effluents in the area.

The use of orimulsion is increasing worldwide, despite the fact that it has always attracted bitter criticism from environmental groups. The FoE and others say that burning the fuel merely spreads its poisonous matter further afield.

Venezuela enthusiastically defends the fuel, extracted from the oil soaked earth under the country. State run Petroleos De Venezuela plans to expand production with a new 320 million dollar plant, allowing it to hike output to 7.06 million tonnes in 1998 from 5.2 million tonnes in 1995.

The firm has won supply contracts for the Orimulsion fuel with power generators in Japan, Norway, Denmark, Lithuania, Italy, Canada, lately the U.S. and now Britain. The orimulsion delivered to Milford Haven will go to the nearby 2,000 MW Pembrokeshire oil- fired power station.

National Power, the recently privatised electricity generating company which owns the plant and plans to import the orimulsion to fuel it, argue that there were some 7,000 oil tanker deliveries made to Milford Haven annually and that their orimulsion project would account for only 35 shiploads a year.

“That is less than half of one percent of the fuel already being delivered to Milford Haven,” said a spokesman. He added that their orimulsion would be delivered in ‘double skin’ tankers, ships with a secondary hull to limit oil leaks in event of an accident.

“National Power said they would use double skinned tankers at the beginning,” replied FoE expert Max Wallis, “but the reason was this stuff has to be kept warm across the sea coming from Venezuela,”

“But because of the limited number and cost of these double- hulled ships, they told the Countryside Council for Wales they were now looking at super-heating the orimulsion in Venezuela, so they can ship it in single-skinned tankers.”

National Power claims that any spillage of orimulsion would actually be easier to recover than regular crude oil as, they say. it sinks to an initial level of about two metres below the surface and cannot be blown about by the wind. Any leaked orimulsion could then be sucked up using specialised pumping equipment.

“There are very strong currents under the water in this part of the Severn Estuary (on which Milford Haven sits),” Wallis said. “They cannot predict how this would spread.

“Orimulsion is not like oil, which separates from water, Orimulsion is 30 percent water, it immediately dilutes several times over. There is no technology for separating it from sea water on a large scale — and they haven’t proposed any.”

National Power also argue that any lessons from the recent Sea Empress disaster would have been acted upon by the time the jetty came on stream in 1999. “Any conditions with regards to navigation improvements, the delivery and control of these ships, will of course be taken on board and fully accepted as far as our transporters are concerned,” he said.

National Power claims it is also spending the equivalent of 750 million dollars on filters and clean-burning technology that will make the burnt orimulsion smoke less environment-hostile. This entails a process known as flue gas de-Sulphurisation, special burners to reduce oxides of nitrogen and specially designed electrostatic precipitators to remove dust particles.

“Noone could say orimulsion is that dangerous, as it’s dug out of the ground. it’s effectively a natural substance with some man- made additives.”

“National Power’s ‘few man-made additives’ involves one of the most toxic materials to reproductive systems that man makes,” said Wallis.

“Alkyl-phenols are being phased out of household detergents in Britain,” he said. “Under the Paris Convention they’re supposed to be phased out altogether in Europe. Britain makes about 2,000 tonnes a year at present. But National Power’s imports alone would be 10,000 tonnes.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags