Development & Aid, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean

LATAM-HABITAT: Women Build Cities, Report

Humberto Marquez

CARACAS, Feb 23 1996 (IPS) - Women who were behind the explosion of shantytown housing in urban areas can be credited with the upsurge of city growth throughout Latin America, according to a new book published in Venezuala.

Entitled “City Builders” the book is a collection of personal narratives by mainly poor immigrants, fighting for a better life

“We had to build our small house of wood and pieces of cardboard secretly at night to avoid the police,” recalled 53- year-old Bolivian Alcira Cardenas in her account of city life near Buenos Aires. “One night, the police raided the neighbourhood and took my husband, my brother-in-law and some neighbours on charges of using land that did not belong to them,”

Cardenas, a mother of six children has spent more than 40 years n Argentina after struggling in 1957 to hang on to land she occupied in the “General San Martin “neighborhood of Buenos Aires.

She provided one of 33 testimonies collected in 11 Latin American cities by Venezuelan architecture professor Teolinda Bolivar and published under the auspices of the central University here.

Bolivar told IPS that the book was intended to provide a sampling of the initiatives poor people have taken to build “the informal city, that is, the one that departs from optimal practices as defined by official planners.”

“At the same time, we show that women are the principal city builders and they testify as voices that are never heard. Maybe women (build neighborhoods) because are usually the ones who stay at home in the Third World,” the architect said.

“City Builders” will be sent to the second World Habitat Conference to be held this June in Istanbul “to try to contribute to designing more humane and dignified cities by drawing on the initiatives people have developed to resolve their urban problems,” Bolivar noted.

The Istanbul conference is dedicated to the problems of urban habitat and responds to projections that two-thirds of the world’s population, or eight billion people, will live in cities in just 30 years.

Cardenas’ experience “reflects the fact that there is not enough land to accommodate housing for the poor” in Latin America, Bolivar said, “and this is the context for the initiatives that they take to deal with the problem and describe in the book.”

In Quito, Bertha and Yolanda Gordillo made a pioneering move to the old La Ronda neighborhood, where they hope to start a tourist hostel while Havana resident Graciela Gonzalez is working to expand her small apartment.

Along with individual and family initiatives, the book documents some successful collective approaches to urban problems, including joint land purchases and neighborhood-level improvements, such as those described by the “Committees for Communal Action” in Bogota’s Nueva Argentina, Tanque and Laguna neighborhoods.

Some of the urban poor have modified existing community organizations to address their new needs. For example, residents of the Lomas Bajas neighbourhood in southeast Caracas, most of whom migrated from the countryside in the 1960s, turned their former Agrarian League into a Neighbourhood Association.

In Mexico City, Yola, Luis Carlos, Lupe and Manuela reported that “people are organizing a Neighbourhood Assembly to get housing, first and foremost, and then to fight for better wages, schooling for their children, and voting rights.”

“Even though I already have my house, I don’t think the struggle is over because it will take many years to get decent housing for all the families here. It would be very comfortable to go home and watch television, but I would rather join the demonstrations,” Lupe remarked.

In Managua, Ines Rugama and other families occupied land in the Pablo Ubeda neighbourhood in 1978 “under harassment from the National Guard.” We suffered from cold, hunger, the sun and the wind” until “our defense committees” organized community services that they still use, Rugama said.

Her countrywoman Virginia Villalobos began organizing “pro- land committees” in 1986 and four years later led 50 groups to occupy the Francisco Salazar neighborhood. Some 850 families now receive water and electrical services in the area but have yet to legalize their holdings.

Bolivar noted that “a common problem in Latin America, which shows up constantly in these testimonies, is that governments refuse to improve existing neighborhoods because they judge the shantytowns a blight and always want to build better-quality housing instead.”

But the upshot, she says, is that “there are never enough resources to build this kind of housing and in the meantime millions of people are left with no help at all and build settlements with many problems that then become very costly to rehabilitate.”

At the root of this neglect “is an ideological nostalgia for the small cities of the past, which are held up as archetypes, and this means that the problems go unresolved,” Bolivar mused.

As an example, she cited Venezuela, a nation of 21 million inhabitants, “86 percent of whom live in cities and 41 percent in shanties, including half the residents of Caracas, some of whom live in sprawling shantytown mini-cities of up to 800 hectares.

“We have to realize that our problems are those of big cities. Let’s get real. This is an urban world inhabited by a very low- income population,” she concluded.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags