Monday, November 16, 2026
Niccolo Sarno
- After a month’s worth of sales in Belgium, importers of ‘fair trade’ bananas believe that if farmers in the developing world get a fairer share of the profits, European shoppers will go out of their way to buy their fruit.
‘Fair trade’ labels go to goods from developing countries produced in line with global accords, such as the International Labour Organisation (ILO) conventions and the U.N. Agenda 21 environment action plan.
Max Havelaar, a NGO that has imported and sold fairly traded coffee in Belgium since 1991, began distributing fairly traded bananas in mid-November, imported from Ghana, Costa Rica, Dominican Republic and Ecuador. They say their banana suppliers are paid twice what the multinationals pay for crops.
Two thirds of the world banana trade is run by three multinationals: Del Monte, Dole and Chiquita. Chiquita cut the price of its bananas in Belgium by five percent last week, partly in response to the new ‘fair trade’ competition.
“The launch of Max Havelaar’s bananas is at least one of the causes which brought this decrease in price,” says Luc De Weerdt, responsible for product development at Max Havelaar. He says the NGO sold around 2,500 banana boxes a week in the first month of trading, the equivalent of 2,500 tonnes a year, and they expect to shift 3,000 and 3,500 boxes a week in the months to come.
The Max Havelaar bananas are of competitive quality and sold here by both major supermarket chains and small alternative retailers and natural food shops.
The fair trade fruit’s prospects have been boosted by the partial results of a survey by the European Union’s executive Commission, which found that 74 percent of EU shoppers would buy ‘fair trade bananas’ if made available in the shops alongside ‘standard’ bananas. Some 37 percent would be willing to pay up to 10 percent more for bananas of quality produced to fair trade standards.
The figures are higher for people who already buy fair trade goods; 93 percent of them would be prepared to buy fair trade bananas, and 70 percent of would be willing to pay a premium of at least 10 percent over the price of standard bananas.
“We feel vindicated by the results of the survey,” Alistair Smith of the NGO Banana Link told IPS. “I’m impressed by the fact that the Commission took (the banana fair trade issue) seriously enough to carry out a survey.”
Banana Link is the outgoing holder of the rotating presidency of EUROBAN, a network of 35 fair trade and environment NGOs, trade unions and church groups from 14 European countries and all concerned with banana producers in developing countries.
The Commission says that it is investigating ways of providing support for fair trade initiatives for bananas, “with the provision that any actions taken must be fully compatible with WTO (World Trade Organisation) rules.
The WTO recently ruled that an EU development programme under the Lome trade and aid convention allowing African and Caribbean bananas preferential access to the EU market, violates free trade rules.
A conservative interpretation by Commission experts of the results of the survey indicates that the EU market potential for fair trade bananas could be around 300,000 to 400,000 tonnes per year.
This estimate takes into consideration only those consumers who already bought fair trade products, and is based on the total EU market for bananas, some four million tonnes per year.
Smith estimates the current amount of fair trade bananas sold in Europe between 30,000 and 35,000 tonnes per year. The African, Caribbean and Pacific (ACP) group of countries, and in particular 12 ‘traditional suppliers’ supply around 17 percent of all bananas consumed within the EU.
The 12 countries are: Surinam, Dominica, Grenada, St Lucia, St Vincent and the Grenadines, Jamaica, Belize, Cameroon, Cape Verde, Cote d’Ivoire, Madagascar and Somalia.
EU Commissioner for development Joao de Deus Pinheiro says that “(the outcome of the survey) is good news for ACP banana producers some of whom are already producing bananas that are eligible for the fair trade label.
“This survey shows the sentiment of solidarity of European consumers with regard to less developed countries.”
In the view of the Commission, the main problem facing fair trade bananas in the EU is distribution. “The success (of marketing fair trade bananas) would depend,” it says, “to a large extent on fruit of equivalent quality to standard bananas being widely available through consumers’ preferred outlets, principally supermarkets, so that buyers would have the option of choosing.”
But, in the view of De Weerdt, the main problem facing fair trade bananas is in their visibility: “EU (market potential) figures give for granted that fair trade bananas are known to the public, but it is not always the case.”
Awareness of fair trade and its products in Europe differs widely from country to country: it is much higher in the North (Denmark, United Kingdom, the Netherlands, and Germany) than in the South (Greece, France, Spain, Portugal).
Eleven percent of the surveyed have bought fair trade goods, mainly coffee, tea, and craft products, but the percentage varies from only three percent in Portugal and Greece to 49 percent in the Netherlands.
“By putting (Max Havelaar) bananas on the market, we hope to prove that consumers here are increasingly aware of farmers’ conditions,” said De Weerdt.
The fair trade concept has developed in western countries over the past 30 years, mainly thanks to NGOs in response to a growing recognition of the inequalities in trade relationships between developed and developing countries.