Headlines, North America

DISARMAMENT-US: Clinton Pressured to Ban Land Mines

Jim Lobe

WASHINGTON, Sep 11 1997 (IPS) - A group of U.S. politicians put pressure on President Bill Clinton Thursday to back a treaty banning anti-personnel landmines and introduced legislation that would stop the United States using the weapon after 1999.

The 134 sponsors of a bill in the House of Representatives, including more than 30 Republicans, said they hoped it would persuade Clinton to stop insisting on exemptions to a ban – currently being negotiated by more than 100 nations in Oslo.

“As the one nation calling for exceptions to the treaty, the United States remains an outsider in this effort,” said Democratic Rep. Lane Evans. “Our nation must make a choice: we can become part of a historic movement or make a monumental mistake in becoming an obstacle,” he said.

Anti-personnel mines are estimated to kill or maim about 26,000 people a year – one third of whom are children, and nearly all victims are civilians.

Washington has asked the Oslo conferees to exempt U.S. forces in Korea from the proposed ban. Landmines were still needed to protect South Korea and the 37,000 U.S. troops stationed there from a possible land invasion by North Korea across the 1953 armistice line, according to Pentagon officials.

Proponents of the ban included highly-decorated retired army officers and six U.S. senators who saw combat during the Vietnam War. They delcared anti-personnel mines are not needed to defend South Korea.

“Korea is a fig leaf,” Sen. Patrick Leahy, leader of the mine-ban movement in Congress, told reporters after his return from the oslo negotiations. “The Pentagon can solve that problem.”

The bill introduced Thursday would bar the use of government money to fund the deployment of landmines anywhere beginning January. 1, 2000 and thus would make permanent the one-year moratorium on deployment approved by Congress in 1995 and scheduled to take effect in 1999.

The sponsors said they would hold off moving the bill through Congress, at least until the Oslo negotiations conclude at the end of next week. Sixty of the Senate’s 100 members are already on record in support of the ban, which could be attached to pending legislation at almost any time.

Time, however, is running out. Congress hopes to adjourn for the year by mid-October, and the current negotiation process, of which the current Oslo round is a part, is designed to conclude with a final treaty that will open for signature December 4.

Supporters of a ban on ouitlawing the use of land mines believe that the key to getting Washington to go along with such a ban is to put pressure on Clinton. The president, who has deferred to senior Pentagon officials on military matters since he came out in support of admitting homosexuals into the armed forces during his 1992 election campaign, is reluctant to alienate the military brass if he can possibly avoid it, according to political observes.

“The military has historically reacted protectively toward their weapons,” said Bobby Muller, president of the Vietnam Veterans of America Foundation, which has been a leader in the mine ban effort. “But the president, as commander-in-chief of our military, has the ability to decide that a weapon is unacceptable,” he added.

“The President should stop hiding behind the Pentagon and declare antipersonnel landmines off limits.”

Public and Congressional pressure has moved the administration in the direction of a ban over the past three years as such high- profile personalities as the Gulf War commander Gen. Norman Schwarzkopf, Pope John Paul II, and the late Princess Diana enlisted in the movement.

In 1994, Clinton committed the United States to the goal of the “eventual elimination” of anti-personnel landmines while insisting that hi-tech, self-destroying “smart” mines should be exempted. In May, 1996, he called for the negotiation under U.N. auspices of a ban “as soon as possible” provided that Washington would still be able to use landmines in Korea and “smart” mines anywhere. At the same time, he said Washington would destroy its most of its own stockpile of “dumb” anti-personnel mines by 1999.

Critics charged that UN-sponsored talks in Geneva were unlikely to get anywhere because all decisions taken by that body would have to be reached by consensus. Under such rules, one or more countries could block agreement by all the others.

Ban supporters instead favoured a Canadian proposal that all countries favouring a ban negotiate a final treaty by December, 1997, and then use moral and public pressure to shame recalcitrants into signing on.

Clinton initially rejected U.S. participation in what has become known as the “Ottawa Process,” of which the Oslo round is a part. But, faced with growing pressure from Congress, the president announced last month that he would send a delegation to Oslo and, in a key concession, said Washington would not press its demand to exempt smart mines – except in Korea.

In Oslo, however, U.S. negotiators have refused to bend on the Korea exemption, a position which has frustrated both the other conferees and lawmakers here. Canadian Foreign Minister Lloyd Axworthy, who launched the Ottawa Process in October 1996, complained this week that any exemption would “undermine the treaty” by creating a precedent for other nations.

The U.S. position has become increasingly untenable, according to Caleb Rossiter, director of Demilitarisation for Democracy, an independent disarmament research group here.

He notes that the draft treaty already provides for a ten-year grace period for countries to clear existing mines. That gives Washington until 2007 to come up with ways to come up with ways to neutralise a North Korean invasion without using landmines.

A recent Pentagon study found that U.S. and South Korean forces could repel a North Korean invasion within just a few kiolometres of the current armistice line without using anti-personnel mines. But the cost in friendly casualties could run into the tens of thousands.

In a reply endorsed by ret. Lieut. Gen. James Hollingsworth, who commanded U.S. troops in Korea during the 1970s, Rossiter’s group found those estimates to be based on highly questionable assumptions which greatly exaggerated North Korean military capabilities and discounted the U.S. intelligence resources.

The Pentagon was supposed to release a new report on how it could defend the existing armistice line without using anti- personnel mines August 31 but, as yet, it has not appeared.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags