Tuesday, November 17, 2026
John Roberts
- It’s an irony that a British aristocrat divorced out of the country’s royal family should have become known as the people’s princess — and that her death should spark national soul-searching about the monarchy’s future here.
It was the prime minister, Tony Blair, who dubbed Diana Princess of Wales the ‘People’s Princess’. Divorce had firmly tipped her out of the Royal Family; no longer part of the ‘Firm’, she had long stopped carrying out official duties on behalf of her ex- husband, Prince Charles, or her former mother in law, Queen Elizabeth II.
But she was a 36-year-old woman of great, if controversial, character, and had managed to insinuate herself into the hearts of millions of Britons.
What’s more, the vast crowds of mourners who turned up to sign the condolence books at various royal palaces, town halls and even supermarkets, scarcely typified the old style ‘stiff-upper-lip’ British establishment.
These crowds embraced the displaced, the disadvantaged and the disabled: HIV sufferers who knew of Diana’s work for AIDS victims; children who knew she had brought comfort to the chronically sick; Britons of Caribbean, African or Asian origin who found in Diana someone who transcended their fear of racism in British society — and who didn’t keep them at arms’ length.
But as the crowds swelled during the week, and as plans for her funeral procession grew longer to accommodate the expected masses, the silence from the official Royal Family was deafening.
There were occasional statements conveyed by a royal employee or via the Prime Minister but no direct proof that the Queen or Prince Charles shared the grief of their subjects. Neither, it appeared to many, were they properly comforting the bereaved children of Charles and Diana’s failed marriage, the Princes William and Harry.
Only at noon on Thursday, four full days after the princess’s death, did the Royal Family appear to react positively. The Queen, her press secretary announced, would make a personal broadcast Friday night to the nation to record her feelings on Diana’s death.
And on Friday morning, the Queen braved the street outside Buckingham Place, to meet some of the tens of thousands of mourners who have congregated there daily since Diana’s death. “You could have come earlier,” one mourner was reported to have told her, “but thanks for coming anyway.”
It is a serious issue for both the Monarch, the British government and the people. Ordinarily, the Queen has no power. She reigns, but does not rule, in the classic constitutional formulation.
Yet she is commonly presumed to be the ultimate defining symbol of national unity in times of crisis.
The problem is that Diana’s death has now prompted the greatest spontaneous outpouring of national emotion since the end of the Second World War — and the Queen appears redundant if she cannot be seen to be sharing with her subjects their sense of loss.
Indeed, on Thursday morning, some hours before the Palace announcements, the London Times warned the Royal family that their “failure to respond to the expectations of the public could turn a melancholy mood into an ugly one”.
The dilemma for the monarchy is precisely that for the last two generations it has sought to isolate itself from all taint of scandal in the wake of the abdication forced on the Queen’s uncle, King Edward VIII, when he desired to marry a divorced woman in 1936.
Yet such isolation has in practice proved impossible in an era in which divorce is now commonplace and in which not only Prince Charles, but also his sister Princess Anne, his brother Prince Andrew and his aunt, Princess Margaret, have all been divorced.
The Queen has attempted to modernise the image of the monarchy, not least by inviting the cameras into the various palaces to portray both her public and private mode.
As a result of her conscientious reading of cabinet papers every week for the last 45 years she personally knows more about the workings of British government than anyone else. But she is more likely to be judged in Britain by one chilling image from one of these televised documentaries: her grand-daughter Beatrice, then a toddler, was shown struggling to climb a palatial staircase while the queen walked past her without extending a helping hand.
Queen Elizabeth was, of course, brought up in an era in which it seemed wrong to display emotion, and that is exactly how she and her husband, Prince Philip, the Duke of Edinburgh, have brought up Prince Charles.
But Diana showed that emotion was what many Britons wished to see. Diana herself used to say that she acted “from the heart, not the head,” adding: “always have done, always will do.”
It was an attitude that got results, not least in terms of publicising the devastation caused to whole countries — and especially to women and children — by landmines.
“She would send shivers down the spine of professional diplomats because, in a sense, she was uncontrollable,” noted former U.S. secretary of state Henry Kissinger, in a totally admiring tone of voice to a BBC interviewer.
Diana’s death leaves a void in Britain, and particularly in the royal family. The Queen, Prince Charles and other senior members of the royal family, notably Princess Anne, Prince Andrew and Prince Edward, may yet recoup some of the family’s lost prestige if they are considered to have behaved appropriately at the funeral on Saturday.
But it seems more likely that the British people, having lost the People’s Princess, will for some time continue to lose faith in the royal family’s ability to serve as any kind of emotional core for the nation.
The current generation of royals are in grave danger of appearing redundant. But Prince Charles is still only forty-nine and almost inevitably, regardless of the public’s thoughts or his seemingly cold and aloof manner, will, in due course, become King.
Britain looks likely to have to wait another generation or so for Diana’s son to assume the throne. And by then, who knows whether there will still be a throne to inherit?