Thursday, November 19, 2026
Deborah Horan
- Skirting an Israeli checkpoint where soldiers were stopping Palestinian cars, a taxi darted down a small side street into Ramallah and delivered Said Shaheen to his father’s car dealership.
Only a few days before, two Palestinian suicide bombers had blown themselves up in a central Jerusalem market, killing 13 and prompting Israel to confine Palestinians in the West Bank to their home towns. Shaheen, 21, from a nearby village, would have been arrested if caught sneaking into the city.
But with a family to support, it’s a risk he says he and his father have to take. Though they can’t get to Israeli ports to bring in new cars just now, they have customers waiting on repairs. “Sure, there is a danger,” Shaheen shrugs. “But what can we do? We have to work.”
In porous Ramallah, where dozens of back roads lead into the city, getting in and out is not as much of a problem as it is in isolated towns or far-flung villages and refugee camps. And Palestinians know the measure is temporary. Last year, following a series of bus bombs that killed 59 people, it lasted three weeks.
But the measure still saps popular support for the peace process. When president Yasser Arafat made peace with Israel in 1993, it was young men like Shaheen, those who had battled Israeli soldiers in the street during the seven-year uprising, who most supported the Palestinian leader. Thousands of them joined the different branches of the Palestinian police.
Today their leaders say they are struggling to maintain that same level of support. There has been little progress on implementing agreements that promised but failed to deliver a Palestinian airport, harbour and control of more West Bank territory than the 27 percent they have now.
“How can we when we have an Israeli army siege around every town every village every refugee camp?” complained top Palestinian negotiator Saeb Erekat. “Palestinians are not talking about peace now. They are too busy trying to keep the situation from deteriorating further.”
In the wake of last week’s bombing, Israel took unprecedented measures to pressure Arafat to reign in his militant opposition after a leaflet found signed by the Islamic Hamas organisation claimed responsibility for the attack.
The bombers have not been definitively identified, but Hamas and the smaller Islamic Jihad have been responsible for dozens of bombings in Israel.
The tough measures include stopping the flow of taxes to the Palestinian government, jamming its radio and television broadcasts, and demanding extradition of suspects on a wanted list who are thought to be hiding in Palestinian-controlled areas.
But of all of them, it is the inability to move from town to town or to jobs within Israel that Palestinians complain of most.
By the weekend, Israel had deployed hundreds of soldiers to man makeshift checkpoints that lock Palestinians inside the eight West Bank cities under their control. They also surrounded villages and refugee camps.
Israel says by making it more difficult for everyone to move from place to place, it can better prevent Hamas operatives from carrying out further attacks. And Israeli security advisors have said in the past that the measure is the surest way to make would- be suicide bombers and their backers think twice about carrying out attacks by letting them know that Palestinians too will pay a high price.
But Palestinians view the measure as punishing the innocent. Tens of thousands of them cannot get to jobs in Israel. Hundreds more who were trying to enter Palestinian areas from Jordan and Egypt are stuck at the border.
“Why are they punishing us?” asked Walid Abu Hammad, 22, who sneaked into the city from Jenin to work at the ministry of industry. “We didn’t do anything and we don’t support these attacks, why should we suffer and be locked in the city?
“They know that we can get in by other ways,” insisted Mohammed Hammed, 16, who moved last year to a village outside Ramallah from California. “They just want to harass us.”
Even if back roads can sometimes be used, Palestinian businessmen complain that repeated border closures have devastated their fledgling economy as would-be investors thought twice about sinking money into an area where the flow of goods could not be guaranteed.
Six months before the agreement, Israel put permanent checkpoints on roads leading to the West Bank and Gaza and institutionalised a permit system. The system meant that all Palestinians had to get permission from Israel’s military government before they could enter Israel. Each time a bomb exploded, the borders were sealed and all permits cancelled for varying lengths of time.
So instead of the prosperity they were promised after making peace with Israel, Palestinians witness unprecedented unemployment and divestment. A year before the peace agreement, for instance, private investment in Palestinian areas hovered around a billion dollars. A year later, it dropped by almost half, to 586 million, according to a report compiled by a United Nations office in Gaza.
Similarly, before the agreement, 120,000 Palestinians were employed in Israel. Today, more than 70,000 of them have been permanently replaced by Romanian and Thai workers. The rest work sporadically, depending on the security situation.
“Before the peace, we could feed our children,” said Adnan Ajudani, a shoe salesman in Ramallah. “Now, people are just angry. They want to fight not to make peace.”
Some Israeli opposition politicians as well as some of prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s security advisors have warned against measures that risk stripping Arafat of his popular support. But they admit that the cycle of violence is hard to break.
“Every act of terror results in Israeli reprisals against the Palestinian population, which in turn makes it difficult for Arafat to maintain his position that the Palestinians are getting something out of the peace process,” explained Shlomo Avineri, an Israeli political analyst at Hebrew University.
“That, in turn, makes it more likely that more of them will opt for violence,” he said. “It’s a circular argument.”
For Israel, the challenge is to convince a public scarred by more than a dozen bus bombs since the Palestinian Authority was set up in 1994 that ceding more territory to their control is a wise security move.
Yet to maintain his support, Arafat needs to show that he is getting tangible assets out of negotiations. For if the Israeli definition of peace is personal security, the Palestinian definition is an end to Israeli army presence in the West Bank and Gaza, economic prosperity and eventual statehood.
Four years ago, only nine percent of the Palestinian public said they were unaffiliated with any political party. Today, about 40 percent describe themselves as independents. Much of that has to do with growing disenchantment with the peace process, says Khalil Shkaki, director of the Center for Palestine Research and Studies, a Palestinian think-tank.
Without signs that tangible gains are on the way, Arafat’s popular support is likely to continue to fall, Shkaki predicts.
“The public supported the peace process not out of a sudden love for Israelis, but because they thought it would fulfill basic objectives,” explained Khalil Shkaki, director of the Center for Palestine Research and Studies, a Palestinian think-tank. “It hasn’t fulfilled those objectives so we see less support.”