Headlines, Human Rights, Middle East & North Africa

IRAN: Voting For A Fairer Rather Than A Different System

Nevval Sevindi and Darius Bazargan

TEHERAN, May 26 1997 (IPS) - Iran’s new president-elect Hojjat ol-Eslam Hajj Seyyed Mohammad Khatame, a moderate former culture minister and middle-ranking clergyman, has hailed his victory as the start of a new age in the Islamic republic.

Khatame roundly trounced his conservative rival, parliament speaker Ali Akbar Nateq-Nouri, who took just 25 percent. But the vote appears to be a qualified protest at conservative objections to allow roles for all sectors of Iranian society — rather than active opposition to the core principles of Islamic rule.

“Islamic Iran has successfully passed another test and a new era has begun in the shining history of the Islamic Republic,’ said Khatame, who will take over in August when president Ali Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani steps down after eight years in office.

Khatame won by a landslide in Friday’s polls, capturing a massive 69 percent in a vote marked by a huge turnout — more than 29 million of Iran’s 33 million electorate. Celebrations were muted, with most Iranians still observing the annual mourning period for the seventh century Shi’ite martyr Imam Hussein.

Muhsin, a 38 year old Teheran shopkeeper, was as surprised as anyone. He had told his daughter, when quizzed, that he would vote for Khatame. “Many others had assured the same,” he said, “but I believed the (people in the) countryside would vote for Nateq- Nouri, and the mullahs would not tolerate anything else.”

At the first session of the 270-seat Majlis since it adjourned two weeks ago at the start of the election campaign, more than 200 deputies pledged their full support for Khatame. Previously the clear majority of parliamentarians had supported the conservative speaker, as had the religious leadership and the country’s influential trading community, the so-called ‘bazaar’.

Yet all were swept aside by Friday’s mass turnout by moderates of all shades, Islamist leftists, disaffected youth and women. It was arguably Iran’s biggest political upset since 1979, when fundamentalist Shi’ite Moslem clergy led by the late Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini toppled the former Shah of Iran.

Most voters cornered by state TV before the vote had held their tongue. “We all know who to vote for,” a phrase that came to be understood as ‘not for Nateq-Nouri’. Chief among them were the country’s many disaffected women.

“We women were sick and tired of everything,” snapped Mine, a 42 year old teacher. Most of Iran’s scores of women’s magazines had backed Khatame with a strong defence of the role of Iranian women in the revolution, in the past, present and future. Women voters were deeply concerned by the conservative dominated Majlis’ block on attempts bring more women into government and other public office.

“We Iranian women have suffered a lot and therefore we should overcome,” Khatame’s daughter Laila told Seventh Day women’s magazine. She said she believed oppression of women was part of Iranian culture and had nothing to do with Islam.

Though “some countries they (feminists) may have gone too far, we Iranian women have yet to gain our rights,” she said.

Nateq-Nouri did win the endorsement of some women’s groups, but most women voters were swayed by Khatame’s own stated support for the implementation of existing laws in favour of women and his line that private sector development would benefit women. “Islam,” he had said, “is not a whip.”

In a country where 15 year olds can vote and the population has nearly doubled to more than 60 million between the 1979 revolution and 1995, the youth vote was crucial as well.

One female economics student who had stuck Khatame posters on her car said she had pledged her vote for a small freedom — the right to watch satellite TV without fear of arrest.

Squads of religious guardians, operating separately from the police, randomly pick on women on the streets for often minor infractions of supposed Islamic dress codes. Yet others go more or less freely about their business as they like.

Iran is dogged by a divided system of public authority, multi- layered policy making bodies interpreting laws in contradictory ways, while parallel bodies — both new Islamic ones and pre- revolution civil agencies — put them into practice as they see fit.

It is the arbitrary or unfair application of Islamic law in Iran that upsets the general populace, rather than the laws themselves, and it is this that most voters want Khatame to address.

Thus the conservatives’ initial reaction to the result — that Iran’s Islamic identity would not be deeply affected by a vote for Khatame, an ayatollah’s son, appeared to have firm foundation.

Devout Shi’ites, especially in the rural areas, took note of his title of Seyyed and black turban, both signifying his descent from Islam’s Prophet Mohammed, and his known part in the 1979 revolution.

He also had to pass stringent vetting by the religious authorities in charge of clearing all candidates for public office, the Council of Guardians.

He was one of only four candidates to obtain the approval of from an initial 238 applicants. All the others were rejected as insufficiently attached to the revolutionary Islamic principles of Iran’s guiding Spiritual Leader (Vilyat-e-Faqih) Ayatollah Seyyed Ali Khamenei.

Likewise, all legislation passed in the Majlis — which despite its pledges of support, remains dominated by conservatives — must be approved by the Council of Guardians before it becomes law.

Disagreements between the Majlis and the Council of Guardians are frequent. In the mid-1980s so many laws were being rejected by the Council of Guardians that the late Ayatollah Khomeini established yet another body, the Expediency Council, to arbitrate between the two.

The Expediency Council has since become a law maker in its own right, charged with making political decisions that cannot be solved through the regular channels.

Some observers believe that its power is increasing and may supersede the authority of the presidency itself. The Expediency Council has 26 members who are appointed by Khamenei directly alongside the heads of the Majlis, judiciary and the president, the six clerical members of the Council of Guardians and ‘occasional members’ — ministers handling issues under discussion at the time.

There are other bodies among the many founded to act as checks and balances against any bid to dilute the revolution in Iran that Khatame may be considering. These include the 83 member Assembly of Experts, popularly elected every eight years and charged with interpreting the constitution and selecting the Spiritual Leader.

Yet in his own comment on the election, Khamenei made much of the event as a democratic triumph.

“Undoubtedly, without the presence of the varied ideas, tastes and approaches in the arena of the presidential candidacy,” he said in a re-read radio statement, “this tremendous wave of national turnout would not have been realised and this proud point would not have been recorded for the Iranian nation.”

He hailed it as a vindication of the democratic maturity of Iran: “The poisonous breath of the enemies, who for months kept referring in various tongues in their overseas broadcast propaganda to the superficiality of the election — in order to instill apathy in the people — failed to make the least impression.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags