Economy & Trade, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean

BRAZIL-MINING: Gov’t Claims Victory in Battle over Privatisation

Mario Osava

RIO DE JANEIRO, May 7 1997 (IPS) - The sale of the Vale do Rio Doce mining company (CVRD) is the greatest triumph yet of Brazil’s privatisation programme, due to the sum obtained and the obstacles overcome. But the battle has left both the government and the judiciary gasping for breath.

Overcoming the legal barriers put up by the broad-based opposition to the sale of the world’s largest exporter of iron was crucial to the privatisation programme that got underway in 1991, and which will now tackle the telecoms and electricity sectors, involving even higher sums – which could soar to tens of billions of dollars.

Because the next public assets to be sold off are in more strategic areas than mining, a repetition of the legal fight that successfully stalled and sought to block the privatisation of the CVRD can be expected.

But the street demonstrations in which several protesters were injured over the past week in clashes with security forces are not likely to recur, because there is scarce public support for the telephone companies due to the poor services offered.

The judiciary has been badly shaken by the privatisation of the CVRD, after acting as the main scenario for the fight between the government bodies involved in the privatisation and opponents to the sale.

The numerous and contradictory legal verdicts have given rise to the image of a chaotic legal system that acts according to political criteria and at a frenetic rhythm, to such a poinnt that a ruling temporarily suspended the auction 10 minutes after it got underway on Tuesday. And on Wednesday, another court decision suspended the sale, blocking the transfer of CVRD shares to the consortium that won the bidding.

Fresh legal challenges have been lodged by lawyers, politicians, unions and other groups in an attempt to annul the sale.

The sale of the CVRD has not been alone in facing legal action. Indeed, all 53 of the privatisations carried out in Brazil since 1991 have yet to be studied by the Supreme Court, which has not pronounced itself on the constitutionality of the privatisation programme.

“We have lost a battle, but not the war,” said jurist Fabio Comparato, one of the authors of the strongest legal challenge, which stalled the sale of the CVRD, initially set for Apr. 29, for an entire week.

Evaluation by the courts of all the charges questioning the legality of the privatisation of the CVRD would take three to five years, he added.

The incident has highlighted the urgent need for legal reforms, according to the president of the Supreme Court, Sepulveda Pertence, who is in favour of a constitutional amendment limiting court action.

But Comparato conceded that the government of Fernando Henrique Cardoso can well celebrate the sale, because of the improbability of the judiciary overturning a fait accompli.

According to Deputy Roberto Campos, a staunch defender of the neoliberal economic model, the government has eliminated “another nationalist myth” with the sale. Curiously, the Brazil Consortium, which acquired control over the mining company, is headed by another age-old nationalist symbol, the National Steelworks Company, privatised in 1993 in the wake of a similar battle played out in the courts and the streets.

The Cardoso administration not only obtained a political triumph, but a good price as well. The CVRD shares were sold for nearly 20 percent more than the mininum price set, considered excellent in a dispute between only two consortiums.

The 3.13 billion dollars will help reduce the fiscal deficit and the imbalance in the external accounts, because a large part of the money will come from abroad.

The opposition to the sale of the mining company was the toughest the privatisation programme has faced, with thousands of demonstrators taking to the streets of Rio de Janeiro in protest.

But the most outstanding aspect of the opposition to the sale was its breadth. The Catholic Church, the Party of the Brazilian Democratic Movement (PMDB, which has the largest parliamentary slate) and the Brazilian Bar Association all joined the traditional leftist critics of the sale of State assets.

The battle came on top of a number of other problems that indicate “the possibility of a weakening” of Cardoso’s chances for reelection in 1998, political scientist Bolivar Lamounier wrote in an article published Wednesday in the daily ‘Gazeta Mercantil’.

Economic difficulties like the swollen trade deficit and bail- outs of floundering banks, the newfound strength of the Landless Movement in the face of the government’s timid agrarian reform programme, and several parliamentary defeats have hurt the previously unquestioned popularity and credibility of the government, said Lamounier, who predicted continuing problems for the privatisation process.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags