Thursday, November 19, 2026
Abid Aslam
- The Palestinian economy continues to take a bashing more than three years after the start of the Oslo peace process with Israel, economists here say.
Palestinian unemployment has doubled, and individual incomes have fallen by one-fifth since the peace accords were signed in 1993, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) says in a new report.
Overall investment, which was 28 percent of gross domestic product (GDP) in 1992 — the year before the peace accords were signed — has fallen to 18 percent. Private investment has fallen from 25 percent to 10 percent.
This is despite Palestinian progress in establishing tax, budget, and banking operations in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, says Milan Zavadjil deputy director of the IMF’s Middle East department.
Analysts here attribute the economic malaise chiefly to Israeli border closings and restrictions on the use of Palestinian workers. Such measures have intensified following last year’s suicide bomb attacks inside Israel.
Palestinians have been barred from their former jobs in Israel while “workers are imported from as close as Lebanon and as far away as Thailand,” in violation of economic agreements, says University of Michigan economist Jennifer Olmstead.
This is in violation of the May 1994 ‘Protocol on Economic Relations’, Olmstead says in a report for the Washington-based Middle East Research and Information Project (MERIP), a non- governmental think tank.
The economic agreement states that “both sides will attempt to maintain the normality of movement of labour between them”.
Importing labour, ostensibly done for security reasons, “illustrates one way in which the Israeli government is destabilising an already fragile Palestinian economy,” Olmstead notes.
The IMF, which is advising the Palestinian Authority, appears to support this view, although its spokesmen are careful to avoid any appearance of political judgement. They simply note that 80 percent of the territories’ trade passes through Israel.
Although Israel has since eased some labour restrictions, the IMF says the average number of Palestinians working in Israel last year was still only 25,100, down from close to 120,000 workers in 1992, out of a total labour force of some 450,000.
Unemployment stands at around 35 percent, up sharply from 18 percent in 1993, the IMF says in its report, released here last week.
But these are official Palestinian figures. In reality, the rate is probably significantly higher, IMF officials and Olmstead agree. This is because the official estimates fail to account for the frequent border closures and for underemployment.
Most Palestinians who have jobs are underemployment, says Olmstead, meaning that their jobs do not permit them to work enough hours to earn a subsistence wage. And “as workers suffer increased levels of unemployment, wages are driven down and workers’ already fragile bargaining power is further eroded,” she explains.
Because Israel also controls the movement of goods across borders, Palestinian businesses have been forced to slow down production as their access to imported supplies and export markets is limited, she notes.
Such restrictions have wreaked havoc on the Palestinian economy. During the 1990 Gulf War alone, border closings cost the territories some 2.65 million dollars, or about a quarter of their daily national income, Olmstead says, citing World Bank reports.
While Palestinian exports have been blocked, however, restrictions on imports from Israel have been eased, contributing to a sustained trade deficit equivalent to about 38 percent of GDP, the IMF says.
All this may scare away potential foreign investors in the territories, but Palestinians retain “sincere hopes” of succeeding in international trade and investment, says Palestinian planning minister Nabil Sha’ath.
Their hopes are pinned on initiatives such as a special fund, to be administered by the World Bank’s Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency (MIGA), to provide investors with insurance against political risks including nationalisation, currency transfer restrictions, war and civil strife, and breach of contract.
However, that effort, to which the Palestinians and MIGA signed on last week, relies entirely on contributions from donor governments. The Palestinian Authority also is expected to pitch in, but will have to borrow from the World Bank first.
This worries Olmstead, who notes that “despite their need for capital, the (Palestinian Authority) must avoid becoming dependent on large loans”.
Although IMF officials publicly are more circumspect, Zavadjil notes that the Palestinian territories have “considerable potential” precisely because they have little or no public debt.
While foreign investment is likely to be slow in coming, investment by overseas Palestinians has been “disappointing”, Olmstead says.
However, the IMF sees the growth of the local banking sector as a sign of increased local confidence. Bank deposits, at around 1.6 billion dollars, are three times their level of three years ago. But there has been little growth in credit, the agency notes.
This suggests that, although Palestinians are confident enough in their future to take money out of hiding places at home and put it in banks, they are not confident enough to start borrowing and investing in the economy, analysts say.
The 1994 economic protocol itself may hurt more than it helps. Under its terms, each side must “do its best to avoid damage to the industry of the other side and will take into consideration the concerns of the other side in its industrial policy.”
Olmstead asks: “If Palestinian entrepreneurs decide to develop a computer industry drawing on the local computer and engineering talents, will they be told that such economic developments would compete with the existing Israeli industry and therefore cannot go forward?”
While such questions hang over the Palestinians, Israel’s economy continues to expand. Exports grew by 43 percent between 1992 and 1995, and nearly doubled in Asian markets that rescinded longstanding embargoes of Israeli goods once the peace accords had been signed.
Foreign investment in Israel has grown six-fold over the same period.