Thursday, November 19, 2026
Gustavo Capdevila
- The European Union (EU) upheld its complaint over the US Helms-Burton law before the World Trade Organisation (WTO) Monday, despite President Bill Clinton’s decisions to partially suspend the effects of this.
The European Community mission to the WTO announced they would insist on going ahead with the action presented to the difference resolving body, in order to get a condemnation of the law passed by US Congress in order to pressurise Cuba.
“There is no reason why the complaint should be revoked yet as the suspension of the partial application does not signify modification of the law,” said the European mission in Geneva.
President of the European Commission, Jacques Santer, had initially welcomed Clinton’s decision, although he stressed the community opposition to the extraterritoriality of the controversial law.
A declaration by the French Foreign Ministry, last Saturday, also mentioned this nation’s concern over the questioned measures.
Last Friday, Clinton stated his decision to suspend Section III of the US Cuban Liberty and Democratic Solidarity Act, otherwise known as the Helms-Burton law after the two legislators who pushed it through Congress.
Section III gives US citizens the right to initiate legal procedings in their country against foreign people and companies to claim compensation for Cuban goods which were expropriated and “trafficked” after the 1959 revolution.
But the European Union, is also calling for the Helms-Burton and other measures to be declared “incompatible with dispositions on free trade from the WTO’s predecessor, the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT).
The EU also objected to the extraterritorial application of the US ban on trade with Cuba and the refusal to give tariffs on sugar, preventing European nations from exporting the processed product to the US market.
Another of the points questioned by the EU was the prohibition on entry to any US port for vessels transporting goods or passengers to or from Cuba.
The same ban covers loading and unloading of vessels which have passed through Cuban ports trading goods and services for up to 180 days after they leave the island.
The European group also rejected article 103 of the Liberty Law which prohibits funding from US citizens to any third person for transactions involving confiscated goods any US citizen has rights over.
Another EU objection is to the refusal of US visas to company executives from groups accused of “trafficking” with confiscated goods in Cuba. The visa ban also extends to their partners, dependent children and agents.
This exclusion has already been passed on executives of the Sherritt International Corp. mining company of Canada, and the Mexican Domus Group, who are negotiating telecom agreements with the island.
Former US ambassador to the EU, Stuart Eizenstat, designated by Clinton as special envoy for the promotion of democracy in Cuba, said this weekend that a dozen foreign companies had abandonned their business on the island.
Eizenstat added that a futher 12 companies were being investigated – an Israeli agricultural society, B.M. Group, was given a warning last week, he said.
Since his appointment last August, Eizenstat has based his strategy on the argument that the question presented by the European Union is a political issue – the democratisation of Cuba – far from a specific trade-related issue.
At the same time, in their reaction to the WTO, the US delegates have threatened to ask for article 21 of the GATT to be applied – a mechanism which allows for universal norms to be suspended to support “fundamental security interests.”
Cuba’s ambassador to the WTO, Eumelio Caballero, said Cuba had never presented a threat to the security of the United States and that, given the relative strength of the nations, it was his country which feels threatened.
Also, article 21 has never been applied. Trade officials estimate that if the United States sticks to this exception this could justify other nations copying it, endangering the globalisation of trade.
The EU complaint to the WTO problem-solving body is currently being studied by a panel which must come up with an answer within the next year.