Active Citizens, Civil Society, Development & Aid, Headlines, Health

CHILDREN-UKRAINE: Chernobyl’s Cancerous Legacy ‘Needs More Study’

Andrei Ivanov

MOSCOW, Aug 28 1998 (IPS) - The lessons learnt from years of treating children exposed to radioactivity by the 1986 Chernobyl disaster may give clues to the treatment of youngsters suffering from thyroid and other cancers around the world — if there is the will to do so.

Keith Baverstock, a radiation scientist at the World Health Organisation’s European Centre for Environment and Health in Rome, believes that more funds should be made available to examine the links between cancers in children and the presence of radioactive isotopes in the atmosphere.

He says that studies in the Ukraine region have already have changed the way scientists assess the risks posed by iodine-131 (I- 131), a radioactive isotope released during the process of nuclear fission.

The studies could give clues to the levels of cancer among children in areas near nuclear power stations around the world.

It could also help treatment programmes in Norway, where there is concern about leaks from Russian Navy nuclear stores over the border, and in the United States, which still records higher than normal levels of atmospheric radiation that date back to early Cold War above-ground nuclear tests.

Until Chernobyl, studies had concentrated on adults and, as a result, scientists thought I-131 was only a weak carcinogen. Chernobyl has shown that children are at much greater risk than adults.

According to Ukrainian officials, there are more than 1,000 registered cases of thyroid cancer among children in the areas polluted by radiation. Belarusian Minister of Health Ihar Zelyankevich reported 574 cases of thyroid cancer among children in Belarus since 1986.

Baverstock believes the nuclear industry should fund an international foundation to study the long-term health effects from the disaster.

He is proposing an international effort to develop an organisation similar to the Radiation Effects Research Foundation (RERF), which has carried out research on survivors of nuclear explosions. RERF research has so far provided the main source of knowledge about the effects of radiation on human health.

However, other experts believe this would be hard to achieve. Steve Galson, a senior officer at the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s Office of Children’s Health Protection, believes that the political problems in establishing a joint research effort may be insurmountable.

Russia, Ukraine and Belarus would all have to be involved, yet they have fundamentally different approaches to radiation issues, he says.

But Baverstock believes U.S. officials may be unwilling to accept that I-131 poses a greater risk than previously thought because of the atmospheric nuclear weapons tests conducted in Nevada in 1950- 62.

These tests, he says, “appear to have left few parts of America unaffected by releases of I-131 three to four times greater than those from Chernobyl”.

The U.S. government’s own study of dangers to public health from nuclear testing in Nevada in the 1950s, found that the tests left ‘hot spots’ of radiation across the country that may have exposed up to 75,000 people to higher risks of thyroid cancer, especially children.

The growing youngsters were particularly susceptible to thyroid conditions, and drank large quantities of milk from local cows.

The study found that children in Nevada were exposed on average to two rads of radiation, about five times the amount emitted by a breast scanning machine. But in several ‘hot spot’ areas, children were exposed to up to seven times the average dose. Some youngsters who drank large amounts of milk, received as much as 300 rads.

The National Cancer Institute has been criticised for not warning the public sooner of the findings. If the health risks of nuclear tests and accidents have been understated, the U.S. government could theoretically face lawsuits from victims of the Nevada tests and the Three Mile Island nuclear accident in 1979.

In Ukraine a three-year, four million dollar project has just been launched, funded by the United States Agency for International Development (USAID). The aim is to provide Ukraine’s health care service with up-to-date methods of early detection of thyroid cancer as well as the necessary equipment to treat the disease.

The aid programme will concentrate mainly on rural areas, where the health care system is underdeveloped.

Baverstock argues that the Chernobyl accident presents a unique opportunity to increase understanding of I-131 and radiation generally, and in particular whether I-131 is associated with other cancers, including breast cancer.

Scientists might be able to develop so-called ‘markers’, molecular signals that would indicate whether radiation has caused a particular cancer. “Such markers would have obvious benefits in helping to determine eligibility for compensation for radiation- induced cancers.”

Baverstock notes that radiation released by Soviet weapons tests, for instance, might explain the increased incidence of thyroid cancer reported in Norway. Although organising an international research effort would be difficult, it is essential, he insists, “if the opportunities to learn from this disaster are not to be irretrievably lost.”

The Chernobyl Fund, which is paid for by an extra income tax, provides the 3.2 million people living in the four contaminated zones around the nuclear plant with free medicines, an allowance for food and vitamin supplements and an annual medical check-up. Schoolchildren are given free breakfasts and student receive larger grants than in other parts of the country.

According to the Emergencies Ministry, around seven percent of all Ukrainians receive some Chernobyl-related benefits. However, the benefits are often paid late and their value has been steadily eroded over the years because of the continuing economic crisis.

The tax used to fund the programme was originally set at 12 percent, but since an Ukrainian Finance Ministry investigation discovered widespread fraud, the rate has been cut to five percent.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags