Development & Aid, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Population

POLITICS: Military Aid Workers Threaten Relief Agencies

Thalif Deen

UNITED NATIONS, Jul 16 2003 (IPS) - The United Nations is expressing fears that armed troops – notably in strife-torn countries such as Afghanistan and Iraq – are increasingly doubling as humanitarian aid workers, threatening private relief operations.

"This involvement in what traditionally has been seen as ‘humanitarian space’ raises significant issues in respect of principles, as well as policy and operational questions," says U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan in a report released here.

Since the 1990s, he points out, military forces have been assuming growing responsibilities for vital civilian functions, including delivery of food and water, provision of electricity, and distribution of medicine and other relief supplies for victims of war.

The role of the military as aid workers has been enhanced in both Afghanistan and Iraq, thereby diluting the distinction between civilian relief workers and armed troops.

The rising opposition to the concept of military aid workers has also come from international non-governmental organisations (NGOs) and relief agencies working in war zones.

James Jennings, president of Conscience International, says that NGOs doing relief work in Baghdad have expressed frustration "at the continued involvement of U.S. military forces as principal purveyors of aid".


"The international humanitarian aid community is firmly against the idea of armies posing as humanitarians, with bread in one hand and a gun in the other. This discredits genuine humanitarian assistance and tends to put the lives of aid workers in jeopardy," he said.

"International NGOs fear that relief agencies funded by the United States will be perceived as extensions of the U.S. military occupation," Jennings told IPS.

"Unfortunately, many stateside agencies competing for U.S. funding have little understanding of the real security obstacles which might be attendant on accepting such a grant," he added.

Another major international aid agency, Oxfam America, has declined U.S. funds for its relief work in Iraq. "We remain committed to the principle that we would not accept money from belligerents on either side" of the conflict, says Oxfam president Raymond Offenheiser. "We will not be subject to taking direction from the U.S. military."

In the U.N. study, currently before a meeting of the Economic and Social Council in Geneva, Annan says that the issue of civil-military relations has been brought to the fore most recently in the context of the war in Iraq.

Annan sees the need for the U.S.-British "occupying power" in Iraq to "balance" the responsibilities of protecting civilians against the traditional role of the United Nations and other relief organisations providing humanitarian assistance to the needy.

After nearly three years of deliberations, the United Nations issued a set of guidelines last month that lays down basic ground rules for military participation in humanitarian activities.

Developed in collaboration with the international humanitarian aid community, the guidelines say that any use of military and civilian defence assets should be clearly limited in time and scale, and also present an exit strategy.

"Military personnel providing direct assistance should not be armed and should rely on the security measures of the supported humanitarian agency," it adds.

The guidelines also admit that many international military forces provide assistance to civilian population in their areas of responsibility.

"While motivation for this can be purely humanitarian and needs based, assistance can also be motivated by a desire to legitimise missions, gain intelligence, and/or enhance protection of forces."

Unilateral support of this nature can be inappropriate, lack longevity, and can disrupt assistance that forms part of a coherent immediate and long-term programme, the guidelines say.

"Humanitarian work should be performed by humanitarian organisations," it adds. But insofar as military organisations go, they should desist from providing direct assistance.

Jennings said Annan’s initiative in formulating the guidelines is very much welcomed by the international aid community.

"While no one disputes the very real need for military forces to briefly administer civilian areas which may fall under their control during or following hostilities – as in Germany and Japan following World War II – the humanitarian aid community has been emphatic in their condemnation of the use of armies of occupation as primary vehicles for the delivery of aid," he said.

This causes a pernicious confusion of roles, which at best is a cynical political game seeking to put a benign face on a very bloody business, Jennings added.

"At worst, it puts the lives of personnel from genuine humanitarian organisations at risk by identifying them too closely with the conquering forces," Jennings said.

"The unprecedented involvement of the Pentagon, from day one of the Iraqi invasion – of attempting to portray humanitarian aid as the real casus belli – is positively Orwellian," he said. "International humanitarian law does not countenance such bald-faced trickery."

One guideline very much needed, he said, is the rigourous exclusion of political considerations from humanitarian aid.

Officials of the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID), for example, have demanded that all grant recipients hew to the administration’s political line.

"And Pentagon contracts specifically require that press releases – even from humanitarian aid organisations – be approved by the Pentagon’s Office of Public Affairs," Jennings said.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags