Monday, November 16, 2026
Yojana Sharma
- An increasing number of laws and restrictions against foreigners, particularly asylum-seekers from Eastern Europe, the Balkans and the developing world, is fuelling racism within Germany, warn human rights groups and voluntary organisations here.
And, they add, at a deeper level Germany is becoming increasingly hostile to the outside world.
The Frankfurt-based refugee organisation Pro-Asyl said that the German authorities are using many methods to deprive people of their rights, including restrictive legislation.
On Feb. 9 the Bundesrat, the upper house of parliament, approved a bill that deprives asylum-seekers of state assistance if they cannot prove ‘well-founded fear of persecution’ and cannot show they are not able to return to their country of origin.
It amounts to “institutionalised racism from the highest authorities,” says Heiko Kauffman spokesperson for asylum seekers’ campaign group Pro-Asyl.
Pro-Asyl says such drastic state-sponsored measures against foreigners in Germany are giving right-wing extremists, often responsible for arson attacks on asylum-seeker hostels and on individual foreigners, the ammunition and the excuse to continue their attacks.
Refugee concern groups admit they were greatly surprised by the passage of the bill through the upper house. As a consequence they have only in the past few days launched a protest campaign to prevent it being passed into law in April by the lower house.
Some state governments are already preparing to put the new measures in practice by transferring the financial burden of many asylum-seekers to already over-stretched charities such as Caritas, a Catholic organisation, and the churches.
Local authorities say they spend between 600 and 700 dollars a month on each asylum-seeker. Others, such as the state of Brandenburg near Berlin, are seeking exemptions for specific groups such as Bosnians.
But rights groups argue that the bill, which will stop all welfare payments including rent and medical treatment if asylum- seekers are unable to show they cannot return to their own country, is just one of a whole swathe of measures designed to deter the influx of foreigners in general, not merely asylum- seekers.
The Bavarian-based Christian Socialist Union (CSU) party has said that controlling all types of non-EU migration to Germany is one of the main planks of its election manifesto for federal elections due in September.
The Bavaria state government is already proposing that the age- limit of children joining their foreign parents legally in Germany should be lowered from 16 to 10.
Relatives seeking reunion with their families are already subject to genetic testing at the German Embassy in Ankara, according to the newsletter Migration News. Even taxi drivers in some states such as Saxony are expected to check the identity of foreigners if they suspect they might be asylum-seekers or illegal immigrants.
Taxi drivers, like airlines, face fines if they are found to have transported them into the country, whether intentionally or not.
The CSU has been accused of using scare-tactics by raising the spectre of hundreds of thousands of asylum-seekers and immigrants flooding into Germany, unless dramatic measures are taken.
Since the arrival in Italy of thousands of Kurds from Turkey late last year, rights groups say that right-wing German politicians have been “in a state of panic”. They are convinced, according to the rights groups, that the vast majority wanted to come to Germany in order to live off the state.
Asylum-seekers come to Germany because, according to Guenther Beckstein, interior minister for the state of Bavaria, “the law is more liberal and the welfare payments are higher than in other countries.”
Politicians also insist the measures outlined in the welfare benefits bill are necessary to deter gangs which trade in smuggling humans and are responsible for bringing thousands of foreigners across Europe’s porous borders.
The bill, argue rights groups, was pushed through in an atmosphere of xenophobia and ignorance, just as record unemployment figures for Germany were announced.
The bill will have the effect, argue human rights organisations, of “starving asylum seekers into returning home”, in particular some 200,000 Bosnians on German soil.
There is also a general ban on asylum seekers looking for work — a sensitive subject at a time when Germany’s latest statistics of 4.8 million out of work are at a post-world war II high.
Asylum seekers who do come from countries where there is a recognised fear of persecution are sometimes subjected in Bavaria to speech and writing analyses. Their grammar, accent and lilts are tested to ensure they are from the country from which they claim to be.
The authorities insist this is to prevent people falsely claiming to be from war-torn countries, particularly as many asylum-seekers arrive without proper documentation.
Pro Asyl argues, however, that only highly trained ethno- linguists would be able to make any clear judgement on the basis of speech patterns. Such experts are few and far between in Europe.
In addition, Bernd Mesovic of Pro Asyl says, linguistic borders do not always follow land borders, making the rejection of asylum- seekers on linguistic grounds highly questionable.
Bavarian politicians also recently proposed a ban on asylum- seekers getting married while their cases are being processed, “to prevent them bypassing asylum procedures through marriages of convenience”.
Slammed by Pro Asyl as “the mind-set of an apartheid system,” Beckstein has since said he merely wanted to make the authorities aware of the possibilities of marriages of convenience. He has been forced to say in public there would be no ban on marriage — a move which would go against the U.N. Conventions on human rights.
Attempts, backed by Germany, have already been made to reduce the number of countries where there is a recognised fear of persecution. In particular, European Union interior ministers have refused to declare a ban on the deportation of Algerian asylum- seekers. Instead, Algerian asylum-seekers are treated on a case-by- case basis.
Last week a court in the city of Mainz rejected the asylum bid of an Algerian man. Court officials said that the unnamed man could always go and live in a part of the country “where no terrorist attacks from militant organisations are expected”.
Amke Dieter-Scheuer, the German Green Party spokesperson on asylum issues, recently criticised the government for its ‘moral bankruptcy’. “No-one can deny that in Algeria, open, indiscriminate terror reigns,” he said.
A report passed in the Strasbourg-based European Parliament last Tuesday states that “all migrants from third countries must be handled without discrimination” and “according to the social, economic and civic rights”. Human rights activists here claim that these rights are being flouted daily.
It is the loss of welfare benefits, however, that has mobilised the rights community into fighting what it calls the state’s ‘policy of pressure’.
Some Bonn politicians who opposed the bill fear that loss of welfare could led to some refugees having to resort to crime in order to support their basic needs. In Berlin alone, which has one of the highest refugee burdens in the country, some 40,000 could be on the streets within days, Caritas warned.
According to the Federal Interior Ministry, 104,000 were seeking asylum in Germany in 1997, 10 per cent less than the previous year’s total of 116,370.
Those given refugee status had fallen from 7.4 percent to less than six percent last year. Figures for January this year reported that 8,373 people sought asylum in Germany. They are mostly from the Former Yugoslavia, Turkey (including Turkish Kurds) and Iraq.