Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Headlines | Analysis

ASIA: Ailing Tigers May be Better Off with Homegrown Cures

Analysis - Johanna Son

MANILA, Feb 10 1998 (IPS) - Like paramedics rushing to the disaster scene, officials of the International Monetary Fund and World Bank began the year criss-crossing East Asia in a bid to stabilise the region’s ailing casualties.

The IMF, which is leading bailouts of nearly 120 billion U.S. dollars, brought macroeconomic prescriptions, checked country statistics and in the case of Indonesia, forged a new austerity programme with tighter conditions.

WB President James Wolfensohn, whose six-nation trip to Asia ended this week, came with post-emergency treatment. He warned that greater attention must be paid to the poor who would bear most of the burden of austerity measures.

But even with the WB’s people-friendly pitch, the Bretton Woods institutions offered little by way of major proposals to treat the fundamental challenge posed by Asia’s ailment: how to manage the phenomenon of globalisation.

Mostly, IMF and World Bank officials dealt with the symptoms and reiterated the same advice — to slash public spending, pull up interest rates, tighten credit.

And if some Asian officials thought Wolfensohn would openly go against some of the Fund’s controversial advice, they were wrong. In Singapore, Wolfensohn said he believed the IMF was “doing a very good job” in Asia.

Seoul officials tried to get Wolfensohn’s support for easing high interest rates that were choking off credit and potential to stimulate some growth, but he said they were needed for now “to stabilise the financial market” and had in fact helped South Korea’s currency, the won, settle down so far.

Few doubt the utility of the IMF’s emergency funds or the need for belt-tightening. Analysts say such measures are unlikely to be enough, on their own, to reverse Asia’s illness or to even to prevent another one in the future.

So with the IMF and the Bank unlikely to go for a rethinking of old approaches, many Asian leaders have begun looking for homegrown solutions. “It’s better that we should discuss together and present a united front than for us to have each country making out his own case,” Malaysian Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad said in Manila this week.

Mahathir is lobbying South-east Asian countries to use regional currencies, most probably the Singapore dollar, for intra-regional trade. U.S. dollars would be used only to buy essential goods from outside the region.

And as the wild swings of Asian currencies calm somewhat and fears of a debt collapse are eased by rescheduling accords, the debate is turning to new ways for managing chunks of fast-moving capital, whose hasty retreat has battered Asia since July.

“Without a global arrangement, no concerted international action, this crisis will reappear,” said Thai deputy prime minister Supachai Panitchpakdi.

Signs of a growing consensus on this rethinking were rife in this month’s World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, where experts agreed that capital movements have clearly gone beyond the ability of governments or multilateral institutions like the IMF and the World Bank to regulate or monitor.

“As the number of players continues to rise and the nature of the game changes, the rules have to be reassessed,” said WEF founder and president Klaus Schwab and WEF managing director Claude Smadja in a published commentary recently.

“The need for a minimum consensus platform on the rules of the (globalisation) game is becoming more essential than ever,” they argued.

A mix of suggestions from bankers, economists and government officials have since been aired, ranging from a new kind of IMF, a board of overseers, or a global early warning device that would warn about overextended private, especially short-term, debt.

This debate is likely to simmer for years. Meantime, some of the earlier calls by Asian governments for curbs on speculation and currency trading remain largely unheeded. Since September, Mahathir has been seeking faster action on a study into the subject promised by the IMF and WB, including suggestions for a tax on foreign currency transactions.

Wolfensohn said in Singapore the Bank was studying means to moderate currency flows, but said these should not cut down the flow of resources. Currency speculation is not the cause of all of Asia’s problems, but “what we need to do is have some sort of balance”, he conceded.

With little movement on this front, Asian governments are realising that a large part of any long-term cure to financial instability may lie with action they take on their own.

Thai Prime Minister Chuan Leekpai says countries that want to reap the benefits of the global market, which has played a key role in Asia’s record growth in past decades, must also develop ways to “defend” themselves from the market as well.

Development experts point to some attempts, including by countries like Chile and Brazil, to beef up defenses, say by putting certain conditions on short-term portfolio investments and better control over foreign currency movements.

Speaking from experience with Mexico’s crash three years ago, President Ernesto Zedillo said that while global groups like the IMF were needed in emergencies, in the end financial flows have to pass through national borders and be subject to national policy that governments ought to draw up.

While the debate on globalisation rages, Asian governments, as part of efforts to draw up their own solutions to the crisis, are also trying to blunt the pain of IMF austerity measures.

“So the IMF and WB are supposed to be doing stabilisation. What next? That’s the question we should be asking ourselves,” said Nieves Confesor, a labour expert and former labour secretary of the Philippines who is now running for the post of director- general of the International Labour Organisation (ILO).

Just as the financial institutions run the macroeconomic programmes of ailing economies, there must also be “parallel programmes for ensuring that the rich-poor gap does not widen”, she said. And these should be given equal importance to what IMF and WB say, Confesor said.

During his Asian swing, Wolfensohn said some 9 billion of the 16 billion dollars it pledged to the IMF-led bailouts of Thailand, Indonesia and South Korea would go to job creation and to help ease unemployment.

The Bank said it was giving an extra 300 million dollar loan to create jobs in Thailand, releasing 100 million dollars for similar schemes in Indonesia and soon disbursing 7 billion dollars to South Korea. Critics say these cannot fully address the side effects of austerity and rising unemployment.

Asia’s political leaders are faced with restive citizens at a time when subsidies for basic items are being lifted, prices are rising and jobs are being shed.

This has prompted some countries to reach their own social accords, among them agreements by trade unions and employers in South Korea and the Philippines to work together to ease, if not stop, lay-offs in favour of cutting work hours or pay cuts.

Largely though, it is up to East Asian governments to pick out the least hazardous path through IMF austerity schemes.

But if there is one thing has that has been made clear by Asia’s illness, it is that the economic experts in suits can no longer separate financial decisions from their implications on societies they claim to be helping.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags