Thursday, November 19, 2026
Deborah Horan
- In an open field at the entrance to this West Bank settlement, a solitary grave protrudes from neatly trimmed grass surrounded by typical Jewish religious symbols.
By it, on a sparse brown bookshelf, there are holy books written in Hebrew script, some tehillim, the black cord worn wrapped around the right hand and head by Jews during prayer, and memorial candles.
But this is no ordinary grave: in 1994, the small municipal plot became the makeshift resting place of Baruch Goldstein, the U.S.- born settler who gunned down 29 Palestinians at prayer in the city and who was then beaten to death by survivors.
Left-wing Israeli lawmakers say the grave has since become a shrine for extremist Israelis who consider Goldstein a hero, a charge most settlers in Kiryat Arba and Hebron deny. Nevertheless the legislators want it moved away from Kiryat Arba, the 6,000- strong Jewish settlement nestled in the Hebron hills where Goldstein made his home, to a cemetery in Jerusalem.
A bill to move Goldstein’s remains has passed to readings in Israel’s 120-member Knesset. If it passes a third, it becomes law. Lawmakers sponsoring the bill say that could be as early as next week.
Nearly four years after Goldstein’s attack the city is still not completely back to normal. The main thoroughfare passing a cluster of Jewish settlements in the city, closed following the massacre, has been only partially reopened. Hebron’s shrines, shared by both Muslims and Jews, are still divided according to religious affiliation and surrounded by checkpoints and metal detectors.
Sporadic violence still plagues the town of 120,000 Palestinians, probably because it is the only West Bank city that still has a visible presence of Israeli soldiers and settlers.
Since the Israeli army pulled out of 80 percent of the city in January of last year, both have been frequent targets of Palestinian frustration.
“We’ve had more fire bombs thrown in the last year than were thrown in the 10 years of the intifada,” said David Wilder, the settlers’ spokesman, referring to the Palestinian uprising that ended with a peace agreement in 1993 that eventually paved the way for Israel’s army to withdraw from most of Hebron.
After the partial withdrawal, some 450 settlers remained in the city guarded by hundreds of soldiers, a partition agreed to by Palestinian negotiators but never fully accepted by the Palestinian public.
Sporadic violence, they say, is limited to wherever the settlers are. “It’s only in that part of town that there are sometimes problems,” said Mohammed Tamimi, a Palestinian taxi driver. Israeli lawmakers hope that the potential for violence can be reduced further by moving Goldstein’s corpse.
“His grave is not just a grave,” said Guy Doron, spokesman for Ran Cohen, one of nine Knesset member representing the dovish Meretz party, who drafted the bill to transfer Goldstein’s grave. “It’s a kind of show. So the only thing to do is to move the body to Jerusalem.”
Ironically, his new resting place may be next to the grave of Rabbi Meir Kahane, the founder of the anti-Arab Kach movement to which Goldstein belonged. Former members of the Movement, outlawed as a terrorist organisation following the massacre, appealed to Israel’s High Court this week to reverse the banning order.
While moving Goldstein’s grave is not likely to induce fundamental changes in a city playing host to two groups who spend most of their time wishing the other side would simply disappear, Doron says it is a step in the right direction.
“The purpose of the law is to make sure that no one makes a monument to murders, said Doron, who said it would apply to both Israelis and Palestinians. Palestinians, he said, have erected monument in the West Bank to a suicide bomber who blew up a bus in Tel Aviv, killing almost two dozen people. “We shouldn’t show these people as heroes,” he said.
Some settlers said passing the first two readings may turn out to be easier than actually signing the bill into law. According to Jewish law, once burial has taken place, the remains should not be moved. But Doron said Goldstein’s case would be an exception because he was never buried in a proper Jewish cemetery in the first place.
Settlers also said there are questions as to whether law passed by the Knesset can be applied in the West Bank, territory captured by Israel in 1967 but never legally annexed; military law, not civilian law, still governs the land and the people there. Doron said the law stipulates that the minister of defence would issue the order to move the grave.
Though Cohen is sponsoring the bill, it is not just him who would like to see the grave moved. Goldstein’s parents, wife and four children, all of whom still live in the settlement of Kiryat Arba where he is buried, had wanted to bury him in Hebron’s Jewish cemetery, an idea refused at the time by the Israeli army for security reasons. Sources in Kiryat Arba say they still would like to seem him moved.
According to Tsuriel Popovich, the spokesman for Kiryat Arba, the municipality would prefer to see Goldstein transferred out of the settlement so that the park, built as a place for picnics or leisurely walks but empty since Goldstein’s burial there, can be used by residents as it was intended.
Popovich, like most residents here, insists that the grave has not become a shrine of the fanatical right. Most days, he says, no one is near the isolated site. But if it is moved to a more convenient location in Jerusalem, that may change.
“Today, very few people come because of the location,” he said. “If they move it to Jerusalem, more people will come to appreciate what he did. Many more will come.”