Europe, Headlines, Human Rights

RIGHTS: Military Elite Experiments With Turkish Democracy

Nadire Mater

ISTANBUL, Jan 20 1998 (IPS) - Last week’s constitutional court ban on Turkey’s Islamist Welfare Party marks not the end but the beginning of a social experiment by the Turkish military elite that aims restore secular republican rule here.

On the same day the courts handed down its ban on the Islamists, the High Court of Appeals made an equally fatal ruling against Welfare’s former coalition partner, True Path Party leader and former premier, Tansu Ciller. Ciller must now face charges of illegally using secret state funds to finance her election campaign.

“If this is not a coincidence, one gets the feeling that a plan is evolving regarding redesigning of Turkish politics,” says professor Dogu Ergil of Ankara University’s faculty of Political Sciences Faculty.

He suggests that the latest developments are in line with a “supra-parliamentary replanning of Turkish politics,” first unveiled when the military laid down an 18 point ultimatum to the then ruling Welfare-True Path coalition, on Feb. 28 last year.

The ultimatum demanded changes to the Welfare-led government programme, including closure of religious secondary schools and tougher legislation to restrain Islamic fundamentalism. Under their pressure, backed by the Turkish media, the Welfare-True Path coalition was forced to step down.

Friday’s constitutional court ruling lend legal weight to the military’s original charges, that the Welfare planned to ‘overthrow’ the secular republic ‘and substitute it with Islamic rule’.

The court banned five Welfare Party leaders, including party leader Necmettin Erbakan, from politics for four years and lifted their parliamentary immunity from further prosecution. Erbakan reacted coolly, urging his supporters “to remain calm and refrain from angry reactions”.

“We will take the court decision before the European Court of Human Rights,” Erbakan said. “This decision represents a grave judicial error.” He is a fierce opponent of Turkey’s attempts to join the European Union.

Equally ironically Erbakan spent Monday visiting present ruling coalition partners Bulent Ecevit of the Democratic Left Party and Husametin Cindoruk of the Democratic Turkey Party, offering active support for new legislation that would “further steps towards broader democracy, freedom and human rights.”

“Finally the Welfare Party recognises the worth of human rights and democracy,” noted reputed Islamist intellectual Mehmet Metiner wryly, “something that during their days in power they had tended to neglect.”

Many took the view of international relations analyst Mehmet Ali Birand, that the Welfare Party should have been defeated at the elections, not in the courts. Those responsible had failed to avert the crisis.

“Up to this difficult moment the judiciary had neglected the developments so far,” he said, “political parties had not recognised the growth of Islamism and the Welfare itself did everything it could to provoke the secularist establishment with useless and unfounded gestures.”

Yet though the Welfare Party is banned, its deputies make up the largest party group in parliament and keep their party legislative powers until the court verdict is published in the country’s Official Gazette. Constitutional law analyst professor Yavuz Sabuncu from Ankara believes that this may happen faster than usual.

“Generally it takes between two or six months (for publication) but this time it might be finalised in a month,” he told IPS. “But apart from the five leaders found guilty by the court, the Welfare deputies will be able to retain their full parliamentary authority as independents.”

Rusen Cakir, a specialist on the Welfare Party, believes that a slow process of fragmentation and reordering is underway. “The Welfare Party has no other choice but moving towards the centre,” he believes.

“A new and relatively weaker party will be formed and it will be probably headed by one of Welfare Party’s moderate figures, most possibly by Recai Kutan, who is reputed for his friendly relations with the secularist establishment.

“Welfare Party leaders had been drifting away from their grassroots,” Cakir observes. “Those who had campaigned and voted for Welfare expected redistribution of wealth and job opportunities, not further strife, but the Welfare leadership’s challenges to the establishment brought them to the verge of civil strife.”

He thought Welfare’s political support will drift to right-wing parties with the senior coalition partner, the Motherland Party benefiting most.

“The military is staging a social engineering operation,” observed Ergil. “According to their schemes Turkish politics is going to be recreated around the army with a centre-right and centre-left political wing. All remaining tendencies will be marginalised to the point where they will be unable to regime for good or ill.”

Nevertheless this grand experiment in political reconstruction, even allowing for some sceptcism, appears to be broadly welcomed by most analysts.

“One thing is certain. The Islamists will be finally constrained within a weaker and more domesticated political organisation,” says Ergil. “The Welfare Party, along with all the rest of Turkish politics will be recreated, without the radical rhetoric and activists.”

Metiner agreed: “Ironically, thanks to the Army the Welfare Party has finally been forced to re-form as a Muslim Democratic Party.”

And most bizarrely of all, came support and an offer of help to the military from Abudullah Ocalan, leader of the insurgent Kurdish Workers’ Party (PKK), bitterest foe of the Turkish Army.

“The Welfare Party has always strived for liquidating the independent movement of Kurds,” he told Kurdish satellite Med-TV on Sunday. “The constitutional court, in closing down the Welfare, has closed down Erbakan’s mission as well.”

Ocalan’s PKK guerrillas have been locked in conflict with Turkish forces in the country’s disputed south-east since 1984. Some 30,000 people and an estimated three million displaced.

Yet without apparent irony he offered full support to the military’s plan for the “democratic restructuring of Turkey”. And he added, presumably helpfully: “If the Army will choose reconciliation with Kurds then the PKK guerrillas will be transformed into a peacekeeping force.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags