Headlines, Middle East & North Africa

RIGHTS-JERUSALEM: Arab-Israeli Integration Deemed Inevitable

Kim Ghattas

BEIRUT, Nov 14 1999 (IPS) - Two peoples for one land and one capital for two countries. Jerusalem’s ongoing challenges were last week the centre of an unprecedented international conference on the subject held by architects, urban planners and scholars last week in Beirut.

Inevitably sliding into the ages-long religious and political conflict in which the city – and the entire region – is deeply rooted, most experts agreed that in the long run there is little viability for separate national and religious entities.

Focusing on architecture and restoration methods, it became impossible for the meeting – titled Jerusalem Today -to avoid the political disputes.

Summarising part of the exchange, Palestinian scholar Nazmi el Ju’ba, director of the Riwaq Centre in Jerusalem, stated that “Israel’s future is to be a Jewish neighbourhood in an Arab Middle East.”

At the heart of the conference’s debates was the Israeli policy of settlements, designed to expand the Jewish presence beyond the borders established by the United Nations in 1948.

While the seminar was discussing the threat of expanding Israeli settlements on Palestinian land and its effect on Arab presence and identity, the Israeli police was evicting “illegal” Jewish settlers, with heavy media coverage.

Israeli prime minister Ehud Barak stood in the face of hundreds of angry settlers and went ahead with the dismantling of the Havat Maon settlement, the first of the 10 so called “illegal” settlements he has committed to remove.

Such action brought upon him the ire of the Jewish ultra orthodoxy, but did not provoke any particular sympathy or thankfulness from Palestinians.

The reason is that Arabs – and the United Nations – consider illegal all settlements built on occupied lands, not just the 42 raised lately without the specific approval from Israeli authorities.

Barak’s action does not seem to stem from his belief that Jewish settlements may be at the root of the regional conflict, but from the purpose of legitimising all other “legal” settlements, regional analysts say.

In fact, Barak’s government has just approved the construction of 2,600 new housing units in the West Bank, while seven hundred are also being built on the Golan Heights, taken from Syria in 1967.

And although Barak was seemingly taking a tough stand against settlers’ methods, he had coordinated his decision with the council of settlers prior to the police action.

Barak’s decision seems based on the necessity to expand settlements according to official Israeli planning. Evicted settlers were reportedly promised a review and the start of an authorisation process that would allow them to return.

“The settlements Barak plans to remove are not illegal, they are doubly illegal,” said Paul de Waart, a professor of international law at the Vrije Universiteit in Amsterdam who was participating in the Beirut conference.

Settlements and their expansion go against the application of international law and United Nations resolutions, as the 4th Geneva Convention forbids an occupying power from transferring its citizens into occupied lands, he said.

“Barak is just keeping his word (to settlers), and he will not remove settlements approved by former Israeli governments, unless there is great pressure from the United States,” he added.

In the Israeli daily Haaretz, reporter Ada Ushpiz even compares the whole dismantling episode to a session of musical chairs in which settlements were simply moved from one hilltop to another.

The issue of settlements is key in the road towards a peace, which Palestinians hope will finally bring about the sovereign state they have been fighting for since the partition of Palestine in 1948 . Such state was envisaged in the UN resolution allowing the foundation of Israel.

At present, some 200,000 Jews live in 160 settlements scattered among nearly 3 million Palestinians across the West Bank and Gaza, which Israel has occupied since the 1967 Arab-Israeli war. In addition, 180,000 Israelis live in East Jerusalem.

Israel claims Biblical rights over Jerusalem, the place where, according to the Old Testament, Abraham was greeted by Canaanite king Melchizedek in 1900 BC and which later became the capital of a united Israel by 1010 BC.

But the Jewish hegemony over the city faded after several invasions – Persian, Greek, Roman, Arab, European Crusaders, Mongols- which converted the city into a sacred place for Jews, Muslims and Christians.

For 730 years, between 1187 and 1917, when it was occupied by British troops, Jerusalem was predominantly a Muslim city. Until 1947 it was the capital of Palestine, but the 1947 UN resolution specified an independent city under UN administration.

After the 1948-49 Arab-Israeli war, the Israelis occupied south and west Jerusalem, while Jordan took the rest, until 1967, when Israel sized the entire city and declared it its capital.

“At this rate it will be increasingly difficult to keep two separate entities, Israeli and Palestinian, there is too much mixing,” said the director of Palestine Centre for Research and Studies, Khalil Shaqaqi, at Beirut’s conference.

“But if Israel is able to go on with its strategy of settlements it’s because there isn’t much reaction against it from Palestinians and Arabs,” he added.

Shaqaqi also criticised the lack of financial support for Palestinian housing, stressing that this was a necessary step to counter the Israeli expansion, which is based on who seizes land first.

Shaqaqi and de Waart both pointed out that Israel’s settlement policy will eventually undermine the Jewish identity of Israel.

“The greatest shock the Palestinians could inflict on the Israelis is to suddenly give up an independent state and become Israeli citizens, Israel would de facto become an Arab state,” said de Waart, half-jokingly.

For Canadian urban planner Anne Latendresse, who has worked extensively on Jerusalem, Israel still has the upper hand mainly thanks to international support, but she argues that in the long run, Palestinians will prevail due to demographic superiority.

Israeli columnist Ze’ev Sternhell says in Haaretz that if Israel’s best interests are to be defended the country should ‘provide economic and technological aid to the Palestinians, put a total freeze on settlements, limit as much as possible the area to be annexed and transfer settlements whose sole purpose is to be a bone in the Palestinians’ throats.’ ‘

“Because, after all,” he says ” everyone today understands the truth of the left’s argument over the past 20-odd years: the settlements serve only their own self-interests.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags