Headlines, Human Rights, Middle East & North Africa

RIGHTS-LEBANON: Looking for 17,000 Forgotten Hostages

Kim Ghattas

BEIRUT, Nov 9 1999 (IPS) - After Terry Waite, Terry Anderson and other westerners taken hostage during Lebanon’s civil war (1975-90) were released with the help of their governments, the world just forgot about some 17,000 Lebanese who had shared their fate.

They are the Lebanese ‘disappeared’, most of whom are now presumed to have died in militia camps, or detention sites in Israel and Syria.

Last week, a campaign was launched by the “Committee of Families of the Kidnapped and Disappeared” (CFKD) to put the issue back on the national agenda.

Titled “It is our right to know”, the campaign aims at pressuring the Lebanese government into setting up a committee that will determine, within a year, the fate of all those kidnapped between 1975 and 1990.

Wives and mothers of men abducted by government and/or militia forces set up the CFKD in 1982. A “Friends Committee” has now also been established in order to mobilise the support of individuals and groups.

“Mothers, wives, sisters, they’ve been fighting their lonely battle for more than a decade, it was time we stood by them. We apologise to them for not doing so before,” said Albert Abi Azar, a priest, from the Friends Committee and coordinator of the campaign.

“It took us ten years to be able to face what had happened in our country, this is why it is only now that we take up this campaign,” he added.

Foreigners visiting Lebanon after the war were often surprised by the apparent amnesia that had struck people, concerning the ruthless years they had just been through. Ten years on, bits and pieces are coming up again in conversations and more Lebanese are realising their need to face and understand their past.

The campaign is also demanding that April 13, the day the civil war erupted in 1975, be marked as a commemoration day for all victims, “so that our children know what it was and that it never happens again,” said Abi Azar.

It often took a lot of convincing during the war to keep the children from kidnapped men to abduct someone “from the other side” for trading purposes.

Wadad Helwani, one of CFKD’s founders and whose husband was kidnapped in 1982, says she taught her two sons that revenge would not bring their father back.

“I asked here and there, trying to trace Adnane, but I don’t have the means to find him. But I’m a citizen of Lebanon, I abide by my duties. I know my rights, especially my right to know where my husband is,” she said.

“It’s up to the Government to look for him and all those who disappeared. We never turned to any militias for any favours in trying to find our men, we didn’t want to fall prey to them, we always resorted to the Government because we believe in the continuity of the State,” she added.

But until now the Government has showed little intention to pursue the matter. In 1995, it passed a law reducing the time period required to declare a missing person legally dead. This will enable families to claim inheritance or cash social security indemnities.

But “how can I go and declare my husband dead? Maybe he isn’t. How can I kill someone I love?” asked Helwani. “Only those who were desperately in need of money would go and even then very few went,” she added.

Some of the kidnapped may still be alive and while it is considered unlikely that they are held somewhere in Lebanon, many are believed to be in Israel and Syria.

Syria has identified 120 Lebanese citizens officially being held as prisoners, after 121 were released last year. But according to local rights activist Kamal el Battal, the number of prisoners is more “realistically a four-digit figure”, of whom nothing is known.

Local analysts deem it unlikely that the Lebanese government will challenge Damascus and request their release.

In 1991, an Amnesty law was passed, granting immunity to those who had been involved in the civil war. Several ministers and members of parliament were among the beneficiaries and human rights activists now doubt that they will show any willingness in unveiling an unpleasant past.

With the coming to power of president Emile Lahoud and his cabinet of ministers with no war history in 1998, hopes were high that issues such as this would be addressed. But relatives of the disappeared complain that they are being ignored by the authorities.

“The war hasn’t ended in our home. We haven’t been able to put it behind. We’re still waiting for it to give us back our father,” said Mona Hashoushi, whose father was kidnapped in 1982.

“We need to know what happened to my father, it’s very difficult to live like that, waiting, waiting, for ever. If we know he is dead, at least we can bury him, cry on his grave. But now we’re just waiting,” said Mona.

Some 30 militias appeared at Mona’s house on 15 July 1982, the day after Beshir Gemayel, leader of the Phalange (a Christian right-wing party and militia) had been killed. Southern Lebanon was then under Israeli control, supported by the Lebanese Forces, a coalition of Christian- Maronite groups.

Mona says she knows those who took her father – their own neighbours – and his family identified them before a Lebanese court, but the case is yet to be heard by the tribunal.

Wadad Helwani, one of the Committee’s leaders, is an impressive woman. Petite, with piercing blue-green eyes, she seems to have enough energy for the whole group. It’s the will that kept her going through the war, waiting and hoping for her husband to return.

Adnan Helwani was taken from his Beirut home, in 1982. Two armed civilians, apparently from the governments’ security services, came knocking at the door, asked Adnan to follow them, promising he would return in 15 minutes.

Adnan was a fighter in his own way, his wife says. The western (Muslim) part of Beirut where they lived was under siege by the Israelis and Adnan tried to keep life going in the neighbourhood by finding flour for bakeries, fuel for hospitals, assigning shelters to families.

“He was helping civilians, but for the Government (which was pro Israeli at the time) he was helping the wrong people,” said Wadad.

Although Israel usually identifies its prisoners -many labelled terrorists and held in detention camps without trial – one woman claimed she recognised her daughter in a picture brought back by a foreign reporter from an Israeli jail.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags