Headlines

RIGHTS-IRAQ: US Says It Will Press for Saddam’s Indictment

Jim Lobe

WASHINGTON, Oct 28 1999 (IPS) - The United States is seeking the indictment before an international tribunal of Iraqi President Saddam Hussein and key figures in his regime for crimes against humanity, according to a senior US diplomat.

David Scheffer, US Ambassador-at-Large for War Crimes Issues, told the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace Wednesday that Washington had identified “nine major criminal episodes during Saddam Hussein’s rule in Iraq” which should be taken up by an international court.

His remarks appeared part of the increased US government campaign to win international approval for the creation of an international war crimes tribunal for Iraq.

Human rights activists said Scheffer’s speech was the most comprehensive given by a senior government official on the subject. But they expressed some scepticism that the administration was really prepared to follow through.

“They’ve been talking about this since (President Bill) Clinton came into office (in 1993),” said Joe Stork, a senior Mideast analyst at Human Rights Watch. “We haven’t seen the evidence yet that this will be a serious effort.”

Washington, according to Scheffer, is urging the UN Security Council to establish a commission of experts to gather and review evidence against the Iraqi regime and then report back to the Council on the merits of creating an ad hoc criminal tribunal similar to those set up for the former Yugoslavia and the genocide in Rwanda.

Scheffer said many governments he had consulted in recent months expected some Security Council members to block such an effort. “This will be an interesting test to see who will defend a regime that has committed both international and internal atrocities that are as horrendous as they are illegal,” he declared.

And “if an international criminal tribunal or even a commission of experts proves too difficult to achieve politically,” he went on, “there still may be opportunities in the national courts of certain jurisdictions to investigate and indict the leadership of the Iraqi regime.”

In that connection, Scheffer said Washington had urged the Austrian government to arrest on at least a provisional basis a top Iraqi official, Izzat Ibrahim al-Douri, when he travelled there for medical treatment last August.

An informal network of international rights activists – some of whom have received financial support from Washington – were preparing a war-crimes case in Austria against al-Douri. But the Iraqi, apparently tipped off by the government, suddenly left the country, before the case could be formally presented to an Austrian judge.

“The United States would have preferred that the Austrian government had not sought to facilitate al-Douri’s travel, especially when it seemed as though his sudden departure was made to thwart efforts by others to bring him to justice,” said Scheffer, who confirmed that Washington had asked Vienna to detain the Iraqi at least until a prosecutor could examine the evidence against him for possible action under Austrian law.

The timing of Scheffer’s remarks, particularly in the absence of a concrete new initiative at the United Nations itself, prompted some speculation about Washington’s motives.

Scheffer’s speech came in advance of a meeting this weekend in New York of Iraqi opposition leaders backed by Washington. It will be the first such meeting since Congress last year approved 97 million dollars for Iraqi groups seeking the overthrow of the Baghdad regime, and Washington may be hoping to highlight the opposition’s new-found unity.

His address also came amid a protracted impasse at the United Nations over Washington’s refusal, despite growing international pressure, to ease economic sanctions against Iraq. These have been in effect since August, 1990 – when Baghdad invaded Kuwait.

Earlier this week, UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan, in an interview with the ‘Washington Post’, accused Washington of undermining “our professed desire to help alleviate the suffering of the Iraqi people.” He was echoing similar charges made by French and Russian representatives.

A recent survey by the UN Children’s Fund found that death rates for children in Iraq’s central and southern regions – those under Saddam’s control – were twice what they were before the sanctions took effect.

Washington has strongly denied that its stand on sanctions is responsible for the ongoing health crisis in Iraq, arguing instead that the responsible party is the Baghdad regime and its refusal to co-operate with UN arms monitors.

At the same time, however, the administration has been sensitive to the charge that it is denying humanitarian aid to needy and innocent people. Scheffer reflected this Wednesday when he noted that even some in his audience might be thinking: “How can I go on about Saddam Hussein when we are being charged with crimes against the starving humanity of Iraq?”

“Easy,” he answered. “The fastest way to restore proper nutrition and medical treatment to the women and children of central and southern Iraq would be a regime change in Baghdad and the treatment of Saddam Hussein and his ilk for what they truly are”.

Scheffer said Washington had collected millions of pages of documents and photos detailing the Iraqi regime’s crimes against humanity. The nine major episodes, he said, included the Anfal campaign against the Iraqi Kurds, including the use of poison gas in Halabja in 1988, which killed an estimated 5,000 people in a single attack.

In addition, the regime should be prosecuted for crimes against humanity and war crimes for its use of poison gas, as well as other crimes, against Iran and its people during the Iran-Iraq War of the 1980s.

In addition, top government officials were liable for crimes against Kuwait during and after the 1990 invasion; for possible crimes against humanity for the experiments on the effects of banned weapons against human subjects; and for the elimination of suspected political opponents within Iraq.

Finally, Scheffer said a case could be made that government campaigns since 1991 – against Iraqi Kurds in northern Iraq and the peoples of the southern Iraqi marshes – warranted prosecution as genocide or crimes against humanity.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags