Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

POLITICS-UN: Annan’s Reforms Stymied by Member States

Thalif Deen

UNITED NATIONS, Oct 25 1999 (IPS) - A senior UN official Monday accused member states of thwarting Secretary-General Kofi Annan’s efforts to cut staff, eliminate waste and streamline the world body.

Under-Secretary-General Karl Paschke, the outgoing head of the Office of Internal Oversight Services (OIOS), said there was an “overly critical attitude of many member states towards the UN bureaucracy.”

This attitude, he pointed out, had resulted in numerous examples of “micromanagement” by the legislative organs and policy-making bodies of the United Nations.

Paschke, whose office was responsible for probing waste and mismanagement in the UN system, said that Annan himself was eager to bring about “meaningful reforms”.

“I find it deplorable that his efforts are being stymied by legislative bodies,” he told reporters, in one of his last press conferences before returning to Germany, his home country, next month after a five-year tour of duty .

Paschke accused the legislative organs – including the General Assembly and the UN’s Administrative and Budgetary Committee – of paying only lip service to the cause of reforming the world body.

He said that some of them had “interfered with the genuine authority of the Secretary-General” who had the legitimate right to bring about reforms in his capacity as the UN’s chief executive officer (CEO).

When Annan tried to impose staff cuts by eliminating obsolete posts and reducing the bureaucracy by about 1,000 posts, some of the legislative bodies opposed the move. “This was very unfortunate,” said Paschke, “because it prevented the Organisation from becoming more effective.”

As a pre-condition for the payment of some 1.6 billion dollars in outstanding dues owed to the world body, the United States has urged Annan to cut back on redundant staff and reduce overall spending.

Working toward this end, the Secretary-General made far reaching recommendations to convert the United Nations into a leaner and more efficient Organisation.

As a cost-cutting measure, Annan also pemitted the employment of “gratis personnel” mostly in peacekeeping operations and in war crimes tribunals. The salaries of these personnel were paid for, not by the United Nations, but by their home countries.

Developing nations, however, opposed the concept of gratis personnel because most of these workers came from rich industrial countries that could afford to pay high salaries.

As a result of the protest – which originated in the Administrative and Budgetary Committee – all gratis personnel, numbering more than 300, gradually were phased out.

Most of them were from the United States, Britain, France, the Netherlands, Canada, Switzerland, Austria, Norway, Sweden, Belgium and Denmark but a few came from developing nations such as Argentina, Namibia and Nigeria.

The 132-member Group of 77 developing countries said it was opposed to the concept for several reasons. Gratis personnel “diluted the traditional concept of the international civil servant” and “their loyalties were not to the United Nations but to their pay masters.”

One of the other reform proposals that ran into strong opposition was the introduction of time limits – or “sunset provisions” – on initiatives involving new organisational structures or major commitments of funds.

Under these provisions, if a UN mandate expired, all funding for the project was expected to cease, unless it is explicitly renewed.

Annan said there was an urgent need for sunset provisions because the cash-strapped world body was saddled with longstanding UN mandates and projects that continued to be funded every year- whether or not they produced results.

The practice of placing time-limits “would help end the built- in bias towards institutional inertia that has afflicted this Organisation for too long,” Annan said.

The United States went one step further and wanted time-limits, not only on new initiatives but also on existing General Assembly- mandated projects and operations some of which were two to three decades old and continue to be funded with the approval of the Assembly.

The proposal for sunset provisions has been held up because Third World nations feared that longstanding development-oriented projects also could be victimised by these provisions.

In July 1997, Annan introduced a package of reforms aimed at revitalizing the over-staffed and under-funded world body.

The package included proposals for the creation of a UN Development Group, a new Department of Disarmament Affairs, a new Office of Development Financing, a system of multi-year pledges for development cooperation, and a UN Revolving Fund to be financed by administrative savings.

With the exception of the first two, the proposals are still mostly in limbo.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags