Headlines, Human Rights, North America

RIGHTS-CANADA: Supreme Court Seals File in ‘Terror’ Law Challenge

Mark Bourrie*

OTTAWA, Aug 6 2003 (IPS) - The Supreme Court of Canada has sealed the file containing the legal arguments and details of the first challenge of the government’s anti-terrorism laws to reach the high court.

The case, simply titled ‘In the Matter of an Application Under s. 83.28 of the Criminal Code’, is a review of the constitutionality of a judicial order forcing a person to give evidence in an anti-terrorism case.

Media and their lawyers have objected to the secrecy surrounding the case, which grew out of an ongoing trial in Vancouver over the 1985 bombing of Air India Flight 182, in which 329 people were killed when an airliner exploded over the Irish Sea.

Hearings into the matter were conducted in Vancouver in June and July behind closed doors, despite representations from the Vancouver ‘Sun’ newspaper.

The Parliamentary Press Gallery, whose 450 members make up the bulk of the journalists who report on the Supreme Court, has also objected to how the case is being handled.

On Jul. 25, Press Gallery President Helene Buzetti wrote to Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin, saying the gallery is ”extremely concerned that any Supreme Court of Canada hearing(s) into a historic constitutional challenge to secret investigative hearings be held in open court”.


”We would oppose any ‘secret hearings’ in the High Court about the constitutionality of secret hearings," she added.

The gallery also wanted the Supreme Court to refuse the government’s request to seal the court record, ”or, if the Court holds that some secrecy is absolutely essential, that the minimum information possible be redacted”.

The day the letter was written, the Supreme Court quietly imposed a sweeping gag order on the case, but enough information was made available at the original hearing to give the case some perspective.

It relates to a "mystery witness" in the trial of Ripudaman Singh Malik and Ajaib Singh Bagri, the two men accused of the Air India bombing.

The witness was forced to testify in Vancouver at a secret "investigative hearing", a process created in Canada’s 2001 anti-terrorism legislation for people suspected of knowing something about a terrorist act that has happened or is about to happen.

The order compelling the mystery witness to talk was made by B.C. Superior Court Judge Heather Holmes Jul. 21 after a five-day hearing behind locked doors.

The interrogation then began in secret Jul. 22, but was adjourned when the witness’s lawyer, Howard Rubin, sought leave to appeal Holmes’ order to the Supreme Court.

That move means the witness, who is not a suspect in the Air India case, has put off testifying until at least next September.

The witness argues that being forced to testify at a hearing that is not a trial violates his rights to silence and against self-incrimination and that he is being subjected to a law passed after an event occurred.

But Holmes ruled that the order to testify was ”validly issued and constitutionally sound”.

The judge acknowledged the importance of freedom of expression in her ruling but said that sound reasons exist to keep the hearings in camera for now. "Certain judicial practices are inconsistent with public access," she said, citing the issuance of search warrants as an example.

Toronto refugee lawyer Lorne Waldman says the court refusing to release details of the matter is not so unusual. "I’ve been involved in cases where files were sealed," he said.

But a challenge to the laws passed after the 9/11 terrorist attacks in the United States was predicted from the beginning of that process, added Waldman. Forecasting the Court’s decision will be more difficult because "the constitutional issues involved are complex".

Judge Holmes listed six points in her judgement, he added.

The judge also said she intends to release more details from the secret hearing after the examination of the mystery witness is complete.

But some material may never become public, added Holmes, agreeing with Crown Prosecutor Robert Wright that the witness could be subjected to "advertent or inadvertent mischief in the community" if his identity was known before the testimony.

The Supreme Court has not set a date to hear the appeal.

*With reporting by Marty Logan in Montreal.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags