Europe, Headlines

RIGHTS-EUROPE: Ocalan’s Sentence Drives Turkey Away From EU

Niccolo' Sarno

BRUSSELS, Jun 30 1999 (IPS) - If confirmed by the Appeal court and Parliament, the death sentence issued against Kurdish leader Abdullah Ocalan this week may cost Turkey indefinite delays in its aspirations to join the European Union (EU).

“There is clear unanimity (in the European Union) on the issue,” said Anneli Puura-Markala, a deputy Director General at the Finnish Foreign Ministry. Finland will take over the EU’s rotating presidency on July 1.

European governments now also fear that the possible execution of Ocalan, leader of the Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK) may ignite a new wave of violence in Turkey and the rest of Europe, where hundreds of thousands of Kurds live.

Hans van den Broek, acting European Commissioner for relations with central and eastern Europe asked Turkey in statement to “take into consideration the EU’s opposition to death penalty.”

Several European politicians reportedly believe that the Ocalan trial and the situation of the Kurdish minority are evidence that Turkey, in spite of its economic potential and huge markets, is not yet ready to join the EU, which hosts at least 700,000 Kurds.

In 1997, the EU excluded Turkey from early membership negotiations, due to its poor human rights record.

According to Pauline Green, leader of the Socialist bloc at the European Parliament, enforcing the death penalty against Ocalan “would have serious implications on the relations between the EU and Turkey ” and would be a breach of Ankara’s international obligations.

Walter Veltroni, leader of the Democrats of the Left – the largest party of Italy’s ruling coalition – said the sentence was “absurd and very grave,” and that it compromised Turkey’s relations with the rest of Europe.

The German Interior minister, Otto Schily, said he hoped Turkish president Suleyman Demirel would review the court decision and appealed to Kurds to “put faith in the appeals process and the European Court for Human Rights”.

European pressures on Turkey’s government not to execute Ocalan are confronted with a strong internal political and media campaign to go ahead with the sentence. It is estimated in Brussels that it may take the Turkish court of Appeals and Parliament months to decide Ocalan’s fate.

If the judicial and parliamentary instances fail, Ocalan’s lawyers are likely to appeal to the Strasbourg-based European Court of Human Rights – a Council of Europe body which has already condemned Turkish policy on the Kurdish issue.

Ocalan was abducted in Kenya last February by Turkish agents, reportedly with assistance from the Kenyan police as well as U.S. and Israeli intelligence agencies.

Forcibly flown to Turkey, he was put in solitary confinement and has never been allowed to see his lawyers in private. At the trial, which started on May 31, he sat behind a glass cage from where he promised to serve the Turkish republic and achieve peace if his life was spared.

Ocalan has led since 1984 an armed struggle for the independence of Turkey’s 12 million Kurds, which has cost the country some 35,000 deaths.

In 1993, his party switched its objectives towards a political settlement seeking autonomy for the Kurdish minority within the Turkish republic’s borders.

Turkey’s constitution does not recognise the existence of the Kurdish identity and language. Separate education and public Kurdish cultural or political expressions are banned.

Turkey – a member of the Council of Europe and a party of the European Convention on human rights – was part of a 1997 pledge to abolish the death penalty or uphold existing moratoria on executions.

Although the death penalty has not been abolished, no execution has been carried out in Turkey since 1984.

In a cautious reaction to the Turkish court ruling, the Council of Europe said in a statement on June 29 that the moratorium “is an historic achievement which must be upheld.”

However, the Council had already threatened to suspend Turkey from its Parliamentary Assembly if an execution was carried out.

According to Human Rights Watch, a U.S.-based group, “the Turkish government made considerable efforts to convince the world that this would be a fair trial” but there were “serious problems with the independence of the judiciary.”

The United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, Mary Robinson, expressed concern that certain aspects of the legal proceedings deviated from international standards on the right to a fair trial before an independent and impartial tribunal.

Robinson said Ocalan’s lawyers were repeatedly subjected to threats and harassment and stated that it was “particularly disquieting” that the Court had sentenced him to death.

The London-based human rights organisation Amnesty International said that Ocalan’s right to a fair trial and his right to defend himself in person or through legal counsel had been violated.

In addition, Turkey failed to provide a full trial before a competent, independent and impartial tribunal, Amnesty said.

Ocalan was sentenced to death “at the conclusion of a trial that violated both national law and international standards for fair trials,” Amnesty said.

The rights group called for a full retrial of Ocalan, “before a competent, independent and impartial tribunal and under conditions which ensure the strictest compliance with fair trial guarantees enshrined in national and international law.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags