Europe, Headlines | Analysis

POLITICS-RUSSIA: Threatened, Yeltsin Hits First

Analysis - Sergei Blagov

MOSCOW, May 12 1999 (IPS) - By sacking Prime Minister Yevgeny Primakov Wednesday, Russian president Boris Yeltsin is attempting to launch a preemptive strike against his foes in Parliament who have set an impeachment vote for May 13-15, analysts here say.

But Russian politicians and analysts agree that a new government shake-up could prove not just yet another blunder of the Kremlin boss but a fatal misjudgment, given Primakov’s growing popularity and Yeltsin’s own miserable approval ratings.

Russia’s political elite had been expecting Primakov’s departure from office, as Yeltsin has childishly demonstrated his disapproval of the premier in recent weeks, seemingly irritated by his popularity.

Primakov, who in fact ran the country during the winter while Yeltsin was ill, recently struck back at the President and defended his role in the country’s leadership after Yeltsin implied he was expendable.

In an unusual national television address, Primakov showed he did not appreciate being told that “today I’m useful, and tomorrow we’ll see” – nearly the same words used by Yeltsin.

Nonetheless, Primakov insisted that he was “categorically against” impeachment proceedings as it was a move “highly counterproductive” for domestic stability.

In what a Kremlin’s statement termed “not an easy decision, ” and in view of the country’s economic turmoil, Yeltsin fired Primakov Wednesday and appointed an ally, Interior minister and first deputy Prime Minister Sergei Stepashin, as acting head of government.

Stepashin was appointed deputy Prime Minister last week and has long been rumoured to be a “reserve Prime Minister.” Another alleged “reserve premier” is Nikolai Aksyonenko, the Railways minister, appointed First Deputy Prime Minister Wednesday.

Primakov took office as a compromise candidate, intended to make peace with Yeltsin’s left-wing foes in the immediate aftermath of Russia’s financial crisis in August 1998. His cabinet included prominent members of the Russian Communist party, which controls the State Duma (lower house of Parliament).

Primakov’s firing is probably Yeltsin’s gravest mistake, argued Gennady Seleznyov, chairman of the State Duma and a Communist party member, who thinks the impeachment procedure may now get overwhelming parliamentarian support .

“Now the chances for a successful impeachment vote look much better, but we also need to know who’s behind the decision to dismiss Primakov, ” he said.

Primakov has long been seen as a driving force behind a high- profile steady drive against high-level corruption, which has touched some of Yeltsin’s closest allies, including business tycoon Boris Berezovsky.

Berezovsky promptly left for France when an arrest warrant and a court order barring him from leaving Moscow pending an investigation were lifted last month.

Berezovsky, who has been charged with money laundering, fraud and other illegal activities, has actively campaigned against Primakov. Both the new acting Prime Minister and his first deputy are said to have close connections to Berezovsky.

Local analysts argue that Russia’s current dependency on foreign funds and its growing social inequality -trademarks of Yeltsin’s economic reforms – may have thrown most of the population into precarious living conditions, but are in the immediate interest of tycoons and corrupt officials.

Swiss federal Prosecutor Carla del Ponte has reportedly criticised a slackening of investigations into alleged high-level corruption, including Yeltsin’s daughter Tatyana Dyachenko.

But analysts agree that Primakov’s departure is likely to give a boost to impeachment hearings against Yeltsin – earlier on-again off- again process.

Earlier attempts to impeach Yeltsin, in March and September 1993 ended in a bloody showdown in downtown Moscow, when Yeltsin ordered artillery attacks against rebel deputies occupying the Parliament’s building, for which he was warmly congratulated by the United States.

The 1993 shelling is now one of the accusations waved to impeaching him. Others are his role in dismantling the Soviet Union in 1991, the 1992 war in Chechnya, the deplorable state of Russia’s armed forces and the “genocidal” economic policies.

In any case, the impeachment proceedings have little chance of success because even if the Duma votes them, the ousting of Yeltsin requires approval of the upper house of Parliament and the Supreme and Constitutional Courts, according to the current Constitution, approved in the wake of the 1993 showdown.

However, Yeltsin “cannot afford now to dissolve the Parliament by force as he did in 1993,” says Sergei Markov, director of the Institute of Political Studies, a Moscow-based think-tank. “It is just because Yeltsin will definitely lose, that he is unlikely to find one tank or a platoon of soldiers to support him,” he said.

Some politicians argued Yeltsin may even try and dissolve Parliament, but he cannot do that once impeachment proceedings have started.

Not surprisingly, Communist party leader Gennady Zyuganov has insisted that the impeachment debate, which had been postponed before, must be held as scheduled, on May 13-15.

“Every honest deputy must support the impeachment, Zyuganov said.

Former Prime Minister Sergei Kiriyenko argued that only the Communists needed impeachment proceedings for electoral objectives while business tycoon Vladimir Potanin said he was confident that the vote would not pass.

But liberal Yabloko party leader Grigory Yavlinsky – key to a vote – confirmed his support for the third of the impeachment five charges – launching the war in Chechnya. “We need to show the rulers of Russia that they could be held responsible for the death of civilians,” Yavlinsky said.

Russians are divided on whether the State Duma should go ahead with the impeachment proceedings. A recent survey conducted by the Public Opinion Fund found that 47 percent of Russians favour the idea of an impeachment debate, while 40 percent are opposed.

“I have recovered, I am in excellent form and ready for battle,” Yeltsin has said. “Battle” is widely perceived as a keyword, the single possible form of Yeltsin’s political action – and which many Russians feel to have fallen victim of.

Facing the threats Yeltsin is known to react on military terms: on the launching offensives. The Russian president has a history of unexpected dismissals – since 1991 he has sacked five Prime Ministers, some 40 deputy Prime Ministers and well over 100 government ministers.

But now Yeltsin is highly unlikely to find support among the populace, where there is a deep sense of frustration by the results of an economic reform that had promised them a western-style affluent market economy in the early 1990’s and has instead converted Russia into what US analyst Charles Krauthammer called “a beggar state.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags