Europe, Headlines

CONFLICT-YUGOSLAVIA: Germany’s Political Metamorphosis

Ramesh Jaura

BONN, Apr 4 1999 (IPS) - Former social democratic chancellor Helmut Schmidt’s critical remarks on the NATO raids on Yugoslavia, with Bonn going the whole hog, have highlighted the political metamorphosis Germany has undergone in the past about two decades.

Schmidt was ousted in a parliamentary vote on Oct 1,1982 after the Social Democratic Party (SPD) refused to give its approval for NATO’s so-called two-track strategy against the now defunct Soviet-led Warsaw Pact.

It involved the stationing of U.S. Pershing II and Cruise missiles in Europe – most of these in Germany – as counterweight to Soviet arms build-up. Schmidt, as author of the NATO strategy, was convinced that the meanwhile non-existent Soviet Union aimed to create a military imbalance in Europe. This, he felt, would have unforeseen consequences for international security.

The deployment of Pershing II and Cruise missiles was approved by the German parliament a few days after the replacement of Schmidt by conservative CDU-CSU’s Helmut Kohl as chancellor who managed to rule for sixteen long years – until Gerhard Schroeder defeated him during the general election last year.

Chancellor Schroeder, defence minister Rudolf Scharping – both social democrats – and Foreign Minister Joschka Fischer, the Green Party’s stalwart, were all instrumental in preparing the ground for Schmidt’s ouster.

While Schroeder and Scharping could not reconcile themselves to the SPD favouring building up of a war machinery, Fischer and his Green Party mobilised a countrywide massive public campaign against the Kriegskanzler (war chancellor) Schmidt.

Schroeder, Fischer and Scharping now comprise what detractors call the German “war triumvirate” – against the backdrop of their unflinching support for the NATO bombardments of Yugoslavia and Germany’s military involvement for the first time in the past fifty-five years.

One would have thought that Schmidt – who continues to be highly respected in Germany and elsewhere in Europe – would support the historic decision of Germany’s first red-green coalition government had taken, breaking with all the post-war taboos.

Instead, Schmidt came up with an unmistakable criticism, though he couched it in a cautious language and expressed it an interview with a French language newspaper in Switzerland.

Schmidt was quoted saying: “Under the tutelage of the United States, we have disregarded the international law and the United Nations Charter.” German participation in the air raids would have been justified only in the interest of self-defence or defence of a NATO partner state, he added.

Asked for his reaction to Schmidt’s criticism, Schroeder said Saturday at a surprise press conference: “Also a significant statesman…can be wrong.”

He was flanked by Fischer and Scharping. The three are closely coordinating German military participation in NATO air raids on Yugoslavia, which for the first time since World War II are being carried out over Belgrade.

The Saturday press conference was the first addressed jointly by a German Chancellor, Foreign Minister and Defence Minister, exhibiting unity in face of growing criticism. It followed on the footsteps of a first-ever meeting of the three topmost government leaders at Germany’s ‘Pentagon’, the Hardthoehe.

Backed by both Fischer and Scharping, Schroeder said Germany would continue taking part in the NATO strikes – “and there should be no doubt about it whatsoever” – as long as President Slobodan Milosevic did not put an end to “forceful deportations of Yugoslav nationals after stripping them off their passports and belongings”.

“It is highly inappropriate to characterise as refugees (some 300,000) persons who have been forced – under threat of being killed – to leave their hearth and home. They are deportees, clubbed together in overcrowded trains or forced to flee,” said Fischer.

Repeated references during the press conference to the words “forceful deportations” and “deportees” were, according to observers, designed to take the wind out of the sails of the growing opposition within Germany’s Left – and France and Italy – during the Easter weekend to NATO bombardments of Yugoslavia.

Those words evoke horrifying reminiscences of the treatment meted out to Jews, Slavs, Gypsies and political opponents under the Nazi regime, headed by Adolf Hitler, before and during the World War II, triggered by Germany.

Millions died in gas chambers or were executed after being shorn off their belongings which – as revelations of late point out – were not only used to fund Nazi Germany’s war machine but also landed in the treasuries of the anti-Hitler Alliance.

At the Easter weekend marches which have a long tradition in Germany, the protesters carried placards stating “war does not prevent any humanitarian catastrophe, the war itself is a catastrophe”, “bombs do not fetch peace”, “halt the NATO war on the Balkans”, and “bread instead of weapons – peace policy in place of military deployments”.

The demonstrations were held across the country in more than a dozen cities in eastern and western Germany, as well as in several other European countries.

Observers noted that the German “triumvirate” was particularly anxious not only about the impact of remarks made by former social democratic Schmidt but also the growing opposition within the SPD.

In what appeared to be an attempt to underplay the significance of mounting opposition in the SPD – few days before Schroeder is to be elected as the SPD party chairman – the German Chancellor said: “A debate is to be expected when such a fundamental issue is involved that affects German foreign policy.”

Highlighting another aspect, deputy whip of the SPD parliamentary part, Michael Mueller, said in an interview with the Sunday newspaper ‘Welt am Sonntag’: “By bombing everything kaputt in Yugoslavia, we cannot create peace. One should also know where one is going to halt bombardments.”

Asked what if Milosevic did not accept the conditions for end to NATO attacks, Schroeder said he was “not going to join a public debate on hypothetical issues”, which might trigger uncalled for doubts about Germany’s “firmness and solidarity” vis a vis NATO.

But the hypothesis that NATO bombardments is not achieving its objectives has ignited speculations regarding the need for ground troops in Yugoslavia, which is a terrifying prospect, particularly for Germans, who sent 25 divisions to the Balkans during the Second World War and were defeated by Yugoslav guerrilas.

NATO spokesman Jamie Shea dismissed allegations that air raids were not effective. He said all NATO needs “is a couple of days of good weather,” to defeat Yugoslavia.

While the German Chancellor was unwilling to discuss a post- bombardment strategy in public, another eminent SPD member of parliament, Hermann Scheer, pleaded at the weekend in a newspaper interview for requesting U.N. secretary general Kofi Annan to act as an independent mediator with Yugoslavia.

Scheer said the draft Rambouillet treaty, which was rejected by Milosevic, mainly because it envisaged stationing of NATO troops in Kosovo, could no longer be the basis of a “political solution,” which Germany should try to work on within NATO.

Answering a reporter’s question, Foreign Minister Fischer said at the press conference Saturday that “political solution” would have no chance as long as the Yugoslav President continued his policy of “forceful deportations”.

Replying to another question, Fischer said “no emergency meeting” of G-8 -the seven largest industrial nations plus Russia – to discuss Kosovo was taking place, as desired by Russian president Boris Yeltsin.

Germany, which holds the six-monthly presidency of the European Union until end of June, is also host to the G-7/8 summit next June.

Italy and France had backed Russia’s proposal, reports said. Italy’s foreign minister Lamberto Dini said Saturday that he expected a meeting next week of the so-called Contact Group, including the U.S. and five European countries, on Kosovo.

He said the meeting would take place before a long-scheduled conference next Friday of foreign ministry political directors representing the G-7 and Russia.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags