Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Analysis - Jim Lobe
- Republicans in the US Congress are growing increasingly impatient with President Bill Clinton’s failure to provide military support to exiled Iraqi opposition groups, as required by a law passed late last year.
While they applaud the administration’s more aggressive rules of engagement for US pilots patrolling the so-called “no-fly” zones over northern and southern Iraq, lawmakers say the administration lacks a comprehensive strategy to unseat Iraqi President Saddam Hussein.
“The entire US strategy seems to depend upon bombing and, while I support a vigorous and aggressive defence of the no-fly zones,” said Sen. Sam Brownback, chairman of the Senate’s Near Eastern Affairs Subcommittee, this week.
“I am concerned that I do not see more action on other fronts which could help bring us closer to the end of this bloody regime.”
Brownback’s complaint is echoed in other sectors.
In a scathing attack, entitled ‘Virtual Policy,’ published in the Washington Post earlier this week, columnist Jim Hoagland scolded Clinton for undermining his own five-month-old pledge to pursue “regime change” in Iraq.
“(That commitment) has bogged down and now comes across as an effort to triangulate policy on Iraq – to do just enough to defuse Republican and other criticism but not enough to risk fundamental change that would destroy tyranny in Iraq,” he wrote.
At the heart of the current fight is the Iraq Liberation Act (ILA), a law passed in late 1998 over administration objections which, among other provisions, earmarked some 97 million dollars in military aid for exiled opposition groups.
The act was based on a much-touted scenario brought to Washington last year by Ahmad Chalabi, the leader of the Iraqi National Congress (INC), a London-based coalition of opposition groups, including the two Kurdish militias in northern Iraq.
Chalabi and his backers – which include former high officials in the Ronald Reagan administration – have called for the establishment of opposition enclaves in northern and southern Iraq that would be protected from attack by US airpower.
US-supplied rebel forces would then use the enclaves as bases from which to conduct operations against the regime and recruit like-minded Iraqis.
While Clinton eventually signed the ILA and gave his rhetorical support to its goal of overthrowing Saddam, virtually no money has yet been provided to any of the groups.
The administration even waited until the very last minute to comply with the law’s January deadline for naming those groups which would be eligible for the aid.
Worse, so far as the Republicans are concerned, is the fact that two officials who are to play critical roles in designing and implementing Washington’s Iraq strategy have been openly contemptuous of the ILA and the INC, in particular.
Gen. Anthony Zinni, who commands US forces in the Gulf region, questions the “viability” of any opposition group in Iraq and its ability to overthrow Saddam, and he describes the task of carrying out the purposes of the ILA as “very difficult (and), if not done properly, very dangerous.”
“I’ve seen the effect of regime changes that didn’t quite come about the way we would have liked,” he says “And the last thing we need is another rogue state (or) a disintegrated, fragmented Iraq because the effects on the region would be far greater, in my mind, than a contained Saddam.”
Adding salt to the wound was a decision by National Security Adviser Sandy Berger to hire Kenneth Pollack as his chief deputy for Iraq policy. In January, Pollack co-authored with two other defence specialists a major critique of the ILA in the prestigious ‘Foreign Policy’ quarterly.
Pollack and his fellow writers called the notion of overthrowing Saddam through military support for the opposition a “fantasy” and could even lead to a “replay of the Bay of Pigs” debacle in Cuba in 1961.
Instead, Washington should provide continued limited support to existing opposition militias, such as the two rival Kurdish groups in the north, as well as to Shi’a groups in the south, and try to foster a more broad-based opposition movement, according to the article.
“Such a plan, to be sure, would be unlikely to overthrow Saddam but would help keep him off balance and boxed in even if (UN) sanctions and other current components of containment continue to erode,” Pollack wrote.
Much to the frustration of Republicans, Zinni and Pollack seem to be very much in the driver’s seat on Iraq policy.
The ongoing bombing campaign against radar sites and other air- defence and communications targets in and around the no-fly zones has become the longest-running air campaign since the 1991 Gulf War itself.
It appears aimed precisely at keeping Saddam off guard at the same time that they erode his ability to protect his forces.
“The message you’re sending both militarily and politically inside Iraq is this is someone dangerous to have as a leader,” says defence analyst Anthony Cordesmann.
In addition, Washington is expanding broadcasts from its new ‘Radio Free Iraq’ and doing as much as it can to disseminate opposition claims of army unrest, including executions of senior officers, inside Iraq. But Republicans and other anti-Saddam hawks are still not satisfied.
“The fact that the administration apparently has no immediate plans to equip or train Iraqi opposition forces does not lead me to believe that a genuine commitment to remove Saddam is present,” said Sen. John Ashcroft during a hearing this week.
“For his part, Saddam appears to be counting on the fact that an administration with only 22 months left in office will be mostly interested in running out the clock,” John Hillen, a military specialist at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, testified before Congress Wednesday.