Development & Aid, Education, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean

CARIBBEAN-EDUCATION: Stress Begins Early For Region’s Students

Khadine Weekes

PORT OF SPAIN, Oct 11 1995 (IPS) - Each year thousands of hopeful 11 year olds all across the Caribbean stride into examination rooms with yellow pencils sharpened wickedly and apply themselves to sheaves of paper assessing their comprehension, writing and calculating abilities.

Welcome to the Common Entrance Examination, the test that almost always decides which child advances in society and which child does not.

The exam is so revered and reviled in the region that parents are known to severely punish their children should they not be awarded a place in a select high school as a result of their test performance and governments have determined to do away with it.

The examination, taken between January and March in most islands, has created a population of neurotic children and parents, psychiatrists say.

“Irritability, anxiety, depression, nightmares, psychotic behaviour, headaches, fever, vomiting, pains, rashes and unwillingness to attend school,” are some of the behaviour patterns which the 10 to 12 year olds display, before, during and after the examination, says Trinidadian psychiatrist Hari Maharaj.

According to Maharaj, there is an increase in child psychiatric cases about one month before the examination and two weeks before and after the results are published in the summer months, for the opening of the school year in September.

“The first time I took the exam I was very anxious. I felt butterflies in my stomach. One boy was sick in the room. He could not even do the exam,” says 12 year old Avonel Joseph who took the examination last year for the second time.

Young Joseph remembers when results were released the first time she took the exam and she had been placed in a Junior Secondary School, considered inferior in Trinidad.

“I cried all day. I kept wondering what my parents would say. They would not expect that of me,” she said.

Josette McDavid whose turn comes next year complained at the beginning of the school year of headaches. The doctor blamed her sinuses but the headaches mysteriously disappeared after her mother assured her that no matter what her exam result, she would still be loved.

Now a Trinidadian National Consultation Committee on Education believes it can ease the stress attached to this examination by not cramming it all in one morning as is the current custom. As an alternative the committee proposes that the government could grant each student two consecutive chances to write the examination when the student has reached the stage of readiness.

Then again, schools could do continuous assessment of primary schools students as a way of judging who should enter high school and who should not.

None of the proposals have found favour with the public.

“Stretching out the exam will not ease the pain … It is going to prolong the agony,” said Cedric Toussaint, a school principal.

Though many parents have welcomed the second proposal, Toussaint says it could create bottlenecks in schools with students who had been awarded places in schools deemed inferior, staying back at the primary level to try again for a more favourable school placing.

Of continuous assessment seconary school teacher Leonita McDavid says: “School based assessment was implemented by CXC (the secondary school’s Caribbean Examination Council) and it never worked.

“In fact, they are now trying to phase it out because many teachers would actually do the work for the children to ensure they passed. In many cases it was not a true assessment of the child’s performance.”

Though there are criticisms aplenty there are few alternative solutions to the problems posed by the exam. The government is on record as wanting to abandon the system but is unable to do so because there are not enough places in high schools for primary level students.

This year just under 30,000 students sat the test, but only 21, 992 were awarded places in high school.

In the northern Caribbean island of Jamaica the situation is similar. In January of this year, 55,073 students between the ages of 10 and 12 sat the exam and only 14, 925 places were available in high schools for these students.

Successive Jamaican governments have indicated that they will phase out the common entrance examination. The country has already begun with its ROSE project.

Begun in 1993, the project involves teacher training, devising a national curriculum for grades seven to nine and upgrading ten schools per year from secondary, all-age or junior secondary status to high school level.

“The major thrust of the project is to provide equity and access for all students to secondary level education. The overall idea in the future is that the common entrance would be phased out and children would go from grade six through to grade nine where they may then take some kind of test to move on,” said ROSE project administrator Jacinth Gordon.

The project is funded by the World Bank and ends in 1998. So far 30 schools have been upgraded.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags