Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Sarah O'Hara
- Nine months after both parties to the Northern Ireland conflict agreed on a ceasefire, paramilitary groups are continuing to mete out their own form of “summary justice”.
Families Against Intimidation and Terror (FAIT) — a group set up to campaign against punishment beatings and shootings — says there have been more than 124 beatings since last year’s ceasefires by both Republican and pro-British Loyalist paramilitaries.
The only apparent change since the ceasefires is the replacement of guns by baseball bats as the weapon of choice to carry out acts of retribution.
Youngsters engaged in “anti-social activities” — joyriding (speeding the streets in stolen cars), burglary and drug use — were previously punished with a shot through the knee, an act locally referred to as “kneecapping”.
Now offenders are having their knees beaten by baseball bats wielded by up to six men. And doctors say that today’s beatings do more damage than the previous acts of violence.
According to FAIT, the nationalist Irish Republican Army (IRA), which announced its ceasefire on Aug. 31, has carried out more beatings — 76 in all — than are attributed to the two loyalist groups.
The Ulster Volunteer Force (UVF) and the Ulster Defence Association (UDA), which halted their armed campaign on Oct. 13, are accused of 48 such acts.
“It’s about power and control,” says Henry Robinson of FAIT, the lone voice based in Northern Ireland calling attention to human rights abuses committed by paramilitary organisations.
The civil liberties group argues that the state itself has many institutions — the police, the courts, prison, the probation service — to deal with the illegal actions of paramilitaries, and categorically condemns the use of vigilante justice.
The political arms of the paramilitaries say they do not condone punishment beatings, but concede that paramilitary punishments are carried out at the request of their respective communities, often in working-class areas where interventions by police — the Royal Ulster Constabulary (RUC) — are not accepted.
“The community must cease asking the paramilitaries for justice,” insists David Ervine, leader of the UVF-affiliated Progressive Unionist Party (PUP), who is reluctant to assign total blame to the armed groups. “I don’t believe the paramilitaries trawl the streets looking for people to punishment beat.”
Fra McCann, a Sinn Fein councillor in West Belfast, is adamant the IRA is not responsible for most of the punishment beatings. “That is the biggest load of rubbish I’ve ever heard in my life,” he told IPS. “It’s very easy to come out and make statements like this. If they have evidence, they should come out and declare it.”
The IRA has carried out, at most, five beatings over the last nine months, he says, referring to a statement by the paramilitary group. “What you have increasingly is communities taking action themselves,” McCann argues.
According to Ervine, Loyalist punishments are most often instigated by local people seeking retribution for specific acts of wrongdoing, such as a woman who was robbed of a video and formally requested “justice”. Cases involving “internal discipline” — paramilitaries keeping their members in line — comprise the rest.
But FAIT says both Republican and Loyalist paramilitaries have carried out attacks driven by personal motives — for example when a man leaves prison and finds that his girlfriend has become involved with another man.
Neither the PUP or Sinn Fein, the political arm of the IRA, admit to knowing of such attacks.
Ervine, however, says that while he hasn’t heard of such cases, he wouldn’t summarily rule them out. “Two guys knock the pan out of each other on a Saturday night in the pub. The one who loses looks for justice,” he says.
But while statements issued by political parties may be viewed with a certain degree of scepticism, it must also be noted that FAIT’s cause has not been embraced by other politically active community groups. Asked why, Robinson replies, “You’ll have to ask them.”
What worries the West Belfast Parent Youth Support Group, an umbrella organisation for nine groups trying to help teenage offenders — those most at risk to incur punishment beatings — is not the paramilitaries, but the drugs threat.
Although Maria Osborne concedes that punishment beatings are still occurring, the manager of the centre on the strongly Republican Falls Road — where over 80 per cent of the locals are jobless — is more alarmed by drug-related violence.
“I don’t believe that they’re being done by the IRA, on this side (of the city) anyway. I know some young people who were beaten up because they owed money to drug dealers,” she adds.
Her group, which tries to provide structure for young people through social activities and training, is critical of FAIT. “FAIT are doing a lot of shouting but they are not doing anything about the children who are most likely to be punished,” she says.
Farther up Falls Road, at the offices of another umbrella group, the Falls Community Council, there is an equally low level of moral outrage about the problem of punishment beatings.
Information officer Ciaran Quinn observes: “Instead of taking the political high ground, we try and work with the kids and the problems they face. It’s not as black and white as FAIT presents it.”
For Quinn, the issue stems from the question of how kids get involved in “anti-social behaviour”, such as joy-riding, drug use and burglary, and how they can be helped. “It’s about tackling any sort of anti-social behaviour by intervening and giving kids opportunities,” he insists.
Even a Belfast lawyer is sanguine about punishment beatings. The lawyer, who did not wish to be named, linked the admittedly brutal acts to “the policing vacuum” caused by “the Troubles”.
“The police, to a large extent, were not accepted in Republican areas and Loyalist areas, and these groups decided to dish out their own punishments,” the lawyer explains.
“In the event that there is a political settlement and there is an acceptable police force, the whole raison d’etre of these punishment beatings will be undermined.”