Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Robin Pascoe
- Dutch businessmen who have failed to meet the deadline set by government for compliance with a law requiring them to employ a quota of ethnic minority staff, say the new legislation is a bureaucratic burden that will defeat its purpose.
And while minority representative organisations say the government initiative is a laudable one, they too say the law can be improved and fear that because it does not cover all minorities, it may pit one community against another.
The aim of the law is to stimulate employment opportunities for minorities. Once a company has assessed the make-up of its workforce, it must then draw up a programme to ensure the racial mix of its workforce matches the mix in the local population.
However, by June 1, the deadline date, only two per cent of companies had fulfilled their obligations and now the government has been forced to extend the deadline until September.
“The social affairs minister Ad Melkert has said he will meet employers again to talk about the problems,” says ministry spokesman Johan Huyzer, “… but companies which fail to comply can be fined up to 25,000 guilders (16,000 dollars).”
Employers organisations have been vociferous in their criticisms, arguing that the law is an unnecessary bureaucratic burden. Others criticise the whole definition of an ethnic minority and say it will do nothing to increase employment opportunities.
Under the law only people who were born, or have one parent who was born in Suriname, Aruba and the Antilles, Turkey, Morocco, Vietnam, former Yugoslavia, Somalia, Ethiopia, Iran and Iraq actually count.
These specific minorities have been selected because official statistics show they have the highest unemployment levels — some 36 per cent among people of Moroccan origin as opposed to 5.4 percent in the Dutch population — and the government has pledged to revise the list in a year’s time.
“It’s quite ridiculous,” says Luuc van der Raaij, manager of a student catering complex. “I am supposed to primarily employ students, and there are very few students from these categories. In addition, I am being forced to choose between say a Ghanaian (who is not on the government list) kitchen assistant or a Turkish one to bring up my quota.”
“In principle it is a good law,” says a spokesman from the national association of foreign workers organisations (LSOBA), which represents the interests of foreign workers.
“But it will set nationalities against each other. The bigger ethnic groups are recognised, but others are not. For example Palestinians or people from Cape Verdi have just as many problems as someone from Turkey in finding a job but this law will do nothing to help them.”
The social affairs ministry official admits that the law could end up creating a situation where minorities compete against each other for jobs, but in its favour, points out that it could also lead to a minority being chosen in preference to a “native” Dutch person.
“The aim is to stimulate employment among these groups. How the law works out in effect remains to be seen,” says Huyzer. “So far we only have anecdotal evidence.”
However the VNO-NCW employers organisation warns that because employees have the right to refuse to give details of their backgrounds, the register is likely to give a distorted view. The organisation claims that there have been numerous cases of Dutch- born people from a minority background who refuse to be categorised as such.
“Compliance depends on the goodwill of the employers,” says Muzeyyen Utlu, spokeswoman for the Dutch Centre for Foreigners (NCB). “All the criticism has focused on the registration aspects, but for us it is more about employment prospects.”
At the same time, Utlu says that the law as it now stands could lead to indirect discrimination. “We have to look at this law as a beginning,” she says. “There are a lot of things which can be improved, but the system of registration is only a means to an end. The government has to do more to help companies comply.”
Despite the extension of the deadline, employers are still reluctant to meet their obligations. The VNO-NCW is continuing its opposition to the law, saying it is placing an intolerable administrative burden on companies which are already being overloaded with paperwork.
“It is a bad law which politicians have just dumped on us,” said the group’s chairman Alexander Rinnoy-Kan in May. “It is a bureaucratic monstrosity which costs a lot and will deliver nothing.”
The VNO-NCW sees the answer to high unemployment among ethnic minorities as partly one of improving education and training among the worse affected groups. This must be done on a local not a national level, and involve employers, unions and government bodies.
“The law as it now stands puts all the onus on employers,” says a VNO spokesman. “The minister has promised to contact us to talk about the problems and our ideas, but we are waiting for his call.”
Utlu agrees that education is one of the keys, but warns of further stigmatisation. “There is a picture in The Netherlands that foreigners are low skilled and regrettably many are. But that does not mean there are no well educated minorities who are unemployed.
“Three years ago we set up a special employment agency for highly skilled minorities. We had 1,400 people on our books but had to abandon the project because no-one was interested in employing them,” Utlu says.
She adds: “Employers say, ‘we don’t have any low-skilled vacancies’, but not all minorities are low skilled. Employers should start recognising that fact.”
According to VNO-NCW research, 20 per cent of employers object to the law out of principle. The KBB company, which owns several chains of shops, announced when the law was first passed by parliament last year that it did not believe registration by origin was the best way to improve minority employment chances.
“We have 24,000 employees and many come from minority backgrounds. We also run schemes to promote equal opportunities. What has this law to do with us?,” said spokesman Alex Tailleur. “We support the principles behind the law but not the law itself.”