Headlines

RIGHTS-CHILE: Heavy TV Coverage Surrounds 30th Anniversary of Coup

Gustavo González

SANTIAGO, Sep 5 2003 (IPS) - As the 30th anniversary of the Sep. 11, 1973 coup d’etat in Chile approaches, TV coverage of the crimes against humanity committed by the 1973-1990 dictatorship is so heavy that some analysts warn against overload.
   Others, however, welcome the new media openness towards issues that remain highly divisive and controversial.

As the 30th anniversary of the Sep. 11, 1973 coup d’etat in Chile approaches, TV coverage of the crimes against humanity committed by the 1973-1990 dictatorship is so heavy that some analysts warn against overload.

Others, however, welcome the new media openness towards issues that remain highly divisive and controversial.

The new focus has even been taken up by TV stations that until recently shied away from reporting on and investigating questions surrounding the 3,000 political murders and forced disappearances committed by Gen. Augusto Pinochet’s de facto military regime.

Local stations have not only dusted off their footage of the bloody coup that overthrew democratically elected socialist president Salvador Allende (1971-1973), but are taking a new approach to human rights questions, no longer merely echoing the official version of events imposed by the dictatorship.

For example, the media have stopped using terms like the ”alleged detained-disappeared” or ”supposed torture victims,” and the right’s claim that the dictatorship’s human rights violations were an invention of ”international communism” has been laid to rest.

”Enough years have gone by to allow Chilean society to gain a more realistic view of this event (the coup) that was so far-reaching in Chilean history, and for that reason it is recalled or commemorated by the media,” Douglas Hubner, chairman of the Santiago Metropolitan Council of the Journalists’ Association, told IPS.

”I think this country is gradually achieving the media freedom that will allow the whole truth to come out,” he added.

The secretary-general of the government, Francisco Vidal, said the current ”boom” of TV programmes on human rights issues has come in response to high ratings.

Vidal told foreign reporters that the 21 in-depth reports on the issue broadcast in July and August were produced because the TV channels found that human rights programming draws viewers, which he decribed as a positive development.

TV, which has a much greater scope of influence than other media, is thus helping to uncover the truth about the full extent of the dictatorship’s repression, said the spokesman for Chile’s centre-left coalition government.

Some of the programmes on the 1973 coup and its consequences have scored ratings of 40 points as measured by the ”people meter” system, which meant 480,000 TV sets were tuned in to the broadcasts, said Vidal.

”Los zarpazos del Puma” by journalist Patricia Verdugo, the top-selling book in Chile on the dictatorship’s human rights abuses, has sold 150,000 copies at the most, including both legal and pirate editions, Vidal pointed out for the sake of comparison.

But experts say the heavy coverage could lead to overload.

”In Chile, the media tend to all cover the same news items at the same time, and that poses a serious danger of overkill, which is perhaps already occurring,” María Elena Gronemeyer, director of the School of Journalism at the Catholic University of Santiago, commented to IPS.

”The important thing in order to keep that from happening is for the media to take on the challenge of being creative, and to respond to the public’s need for news while weighing the dosage of information that the public is capable of handling, even about such a key event as the coup,” said Gronemeyer.

Santiago Pavlovic, a reporter with the Informe Especial programme produced by Chile’s state-run channel Televisión Nacional de Chile (TVN), agreed that ”coverage has been excessive,” but said ”that has provided the public, and especially the youngest generations, with more complete information.

”We have to remember that more than 60 percent of the population of Chile is under 30. That means they did not experience the coup, and perhaps this overkill is compensating for everything that was not talked about or explained during 17 years of military government, when only one voice was heard,” Pavlovic remarked to IPS.

”Although there has been some overload in terms of media coverage (of the coup), I think that due to historical reasons, and because of the time that has passed, it is important to look back,” said Claudio Mendoza, a journalist with the Contacto programme produced by the Catholic University channel.

”The issue isn’t just going to go away. It will keep cropping up for one reason or another, because someone was arrested, or because charges were brought against someone after new evidence emerged when someone else decided to talk (about the rights abuses). But probably on the 40th or 50th anniversary (of the coup), there won’t be another explosion of news like the one we’re seeing now,” Mendoza said in an interview.

In 1998, on the 25th anniversary of the coup in which Allende died, there was no media onslaught like today simply because ”Pinochetismo was still alive,” said Hubner.

”Five years ago there was no possibility for truth and justice (regarding the human rights abuses). Today, that is becoming a possibility in this country,” he added.

According to Gronemeyer, ”everyone now admits that the human rights abuses took place.

”Today, many members of the military are being prosecuted. Many opinion leaders with close ties to the left are even recognising their share of responsibility in the polarisation that occurred in the country 30 years ago and led to the coup,” she said.

In 1974, the dictatorship declared Sep. 11 a holiday, and it remained so until 1998, when it was eliminated by an accord sponsored by Pinochet himself in the Senate.

The former dictator became a life senator, a privilege granted to ex-presidents by the 1980 constitution, the day after he stepped down as army chief on Mar. 10, 1998, after holding that post since August 1973.

The elderly Pinochet celebrated the 25th anniversary of the coup in moderation, determined to cultivate a new image as a senator-for-life, as he prepared to travel to Europe to undergo surgery on a slipped disc and negotiate an arms deal on behalf of the army.

But on Oct. 16, 1998, as he recovered from his operation in a London clinic, he was arrested on the basis of a warrant issued by Spanish Judge Baltasar Garzón and held under house arrest until March 2000, when British Home Secretary Jack Straw released him on humanitarian grounds.

That was the beginning of the decline of the former dictator, who today, at age 88, watches while TV provides a continuous diet of information on the dictatorship’s deeds, which were still censored even during the first years of Chile’s transition to democracy.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Headlines, Human Rights, Latin America & the Caribbean

RIGHTS-CHILE: Heavy TV Coverage Surrounds 30th Anniversary of Coup

Gustavo González

SANTIAGO, Sep 5 2003 (IPS) - As the 30th anniversary of the Sep. 11, 1973 coup d’etat in Chile approaches, TV coverage of the crimes against humanity committed by the 1973-1990 dictatorship is so heavy that some analysts warn against overload.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |