Thursday, November 19, 2026
Nadire Mater
- A Review Conference of the forthcoming summit of the Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) held here criticised Turkey for its slow implementation of newly-established human rights legislation.
The Norwegian ambassador to the OSCE, Kai Eide, said that the closed-doors gathering of official and non governmental representatives (NGO), held Nov 8-10, concentrated mainly on Chechnya, where a Russian military offensive has created a refugee crisis.
Nonetheless, “Turkey too has received sharp criticism. However, the Turkish government has adopted an open position in facing these criticisms- a positive sign for the future,” he said.
Turkey’s representative to the OSCE, Yalim Eralp, reacted sharply: “They have strangely cooperated in criticising Turkey. The European government delegations closed their eyes to each other’s situations to concentrate their criticism on Turkey. This is a scandal.”
The OSCE summit (Nov 18-19) is an important step for Turkey in its long-standing effort to become a European Union (EU) member, hampered by the human rights situation, in particularly legislation that ignores the country’s circa 12 million Kurds.
While welcoming improvements in Turkey’s human rights legislation, participants also criticised the sluggishness in the laws’ day-to-day enforcement at press briefings.
“We welcome the improvements in the human rights situation. However, it is time to turn to practice from theory, now,” Harold Koh, U.S. undersecretary of State for Human Rights, told journalists.
“Let aside the Kurds, even ethnic Turks are stripped of human rights in this country,” Diego Postigo Otero, of the Swiss-based International League for the Rights and Liberation of Peoples (LIDLIP) reportedly told the meeting.
Otero particularly underlined the ongoing torturing of children albeit Turkey has banned interrogation by the police of children younger than 15 years of age.
In the closed sessions, delegations from 54 countries and 170 NGOs from all around Europe, discussed the burning issues of “torture, children and armed conflict and good governance including the fight against corruption.”
“The Istanbul conference provided valuable opportunities both for the NGOs and the Turkish government,” says Akin Birdal former chair of Turkey’s Human Rights Association (IHD), who last year survived an assassination attempt.
“Yet what is more important is how Turkey would like to benefit from these opportunities,” Birdal told IPS. “The OSCE summit convenes in the eve of the EU’s Dec. 9-10 Helsinki summit where Turkey expects a final reply to its application for membership in the union.”
He said that Turkey would see its chances enhanced if it agrees to sign the ‘Istanbul Charter’ to be issued at the end of the summit and further adjust its domestic law to the EU’s criteria, which emphasise the rights of minorities.
The EU member countries, in spite of their past persistency in refusing Turkey’s application, have remarkably eased their positions in the last few months, raising Ankara’s expectations for being included in the EU “waiting list”.
Similarly, human rights activists and liberal politicians are also optimistic that Turkey’s amission as an EU-candidate may affect the human rights situation positively.
“The major question for Ankara is that it is yet to adjust the domestic law with the Helsinki Final Document signed in 1975,” when the OSCE was established, then in a Cold War context, Birdal said.
However, domestic and international media were unhappy by the Review Conference’s closed sessions.
Yilmaz Ensaroglu, the chairwoman of the pro-Islamist rights organisation Mazlum-Der was disappointed by the low profile representation of Turkish NGOs.
Esaroglu also denounced the Turkish government’s double standards. “The Foreign Ministry encourages NGOs but the Interior Ministry harasses participants,” she said.
“The Kurdish immigrants association Goc-Der was raided by the police while we were joining the conference,” Ensaroglu told IPS.
Although the Review Conference’s agenda was based on the political, social and economic dimension of rights, most domestic NGO’s focusing on such issues were absent while associations such as the Turkish Maritime Pilots’ Association, the Turkish State Theatre, Opera and Ballet Performers Foundation and the Lions Club were in.
“One of the major reasons for choosing Istanbul as the host to the Review Conference was the difficulties faced by the Turkish NGOs in participating in overseas conferences,” points Helmut Oberdiek, an advisor to the conference.
“Of course we have kept in mind the violations of human rights in this country (…) The Turkish government identifies NGOs with dissidence and thus takes measures to prevent participation,” he told IPS. “But when the number of participants seemed too low, then they started to encourage people.”
The Conference was “a chance to measure how each country meets its OSCE commitments,” said Holy Cartner, director of the Helsinki Division of the New-York based Human Rights Watch.
“Turkey is one of many states such as Uzbekistan, Azerbaijan and Russia where the torture is quite systematic. However even the U.S. and Britain are referred to in these terms,” Cartner told IPS.
“Turkey has introduced a good many measures in order to protect human rights. But the question is if Turkey is willing to punish the security force members’ violations. The amendments in legislation should be reflected in the actual government practices,” Cartner added.
Germany’s Interior minister Otto Schilly who visited Ankara, simultaneously with the OSCE meeting in Istanbul, warned Turkey that “only 30 days are left for Ankara” to adjust its domestic law to the EU’s criteria.
“Europe has made all the necessary preparations to adopt Turkey in the EU, in turn we are expecting two major steps to be taken by Ankara: abolish death penalty and improve the human rights situation. Then Turkey is hundred percent a candidate member,” he said.