Headlines, Human Rights, Latin America & the Caribbean, North America

RIGHTS-AMERICAS: Indigenous Committee To Lobby OAS

Gustavo Capdevila

GENEVA, Jan 5 1999 (IPS) - Indigenous groups from throughout the Americas plan to use their weight in the region to lobby the Organisation of American States (OAS) to approve a declaration on the rights of native peoples.

At a Feb. 10-12 session of the OAS permanent council in Washington, a regional indigenous committee will press for the approval of a declaration recognising the rights of indigenous peoples.

Efforts to hammer out a similar text, but with universal jurisdiction, have run aground in the United Nations for at least 17 years. Government and indigenous delegates to a working group set up by the UN Commission on Human Rights have failed to reach agreement on a draft UN Declaration on the Rights of the World’s Indigenous Peoples.

Faced with an unpromising scenario, indigenous groups are exploring new strategies, including bilateral discussions between local communities and governments and the possibility of a regional agreement in the Americas, which would give the UN negotiations a significant boost.

Indigenous organisations “are exercising international pressure on the region to launch a dialogue” between the committee of representatives of native communities and the OAS council, said Aucan Huilcaman Paillama, of the Council of All Mapuche Lands.

The relationship between the State and indigenous peoples stands out more clearly on the American continent than in any other region, said Huilcaman, an indigenous leader from Temuco, Chile.

Latin America alone is home to around 30 million indigenous people, who account for more than half of the population in countries like Bolivia, Guatemala and Peru.

A regional declaration adopted by the Americas would refer to more cohesive communities, because while the indigenous issue in Latin America “is somewhat differentiated, it is more integrated than in Africa or Asia,” said Rigoberto Juarez Mateo, with Guatemala’s Coordination of Organisations of the Mayan People.

On Feb. 10 “we will be in Washington, whether or not the OAS receives us,” said Huilcaman, who explained that the decision arose out of a December meeting of indigenous representatives from Central and South America, held in Bolivia.

The chances of the OAS adopting a declaration recognising indigenous rights are uncertain.

Unlike the United Nations, the OAS – which was created in 1948, at the start of the Cold War – still fails to recognise participation of civil society, the umbrella term covering private sector associations, unions, peasant and religious groups and non- governmental organisations.

Moreover, several governments sitting on the OAS council, such as those of Argentina, Brazil and the United States, have consistently stood in the way of approval of the draft declaration on indigenous rights in the United Nations.

The three countries, along with Japan and China, comprise “a block of strong states which are making every effort to keep us from being recognised as indigenous peoples,” said Huilcaman.

But he mentioned other countries like Bolivia, Chile, Ecuador, Guatemala and Peru as possible supporters of a text sponsored by indigenous groups.

The key differences between several states and indigenous groups concern concepts included in the UN draft declaration. The main bone of contention is article 3, which states that “indigenous peoples have the right to free determination. By virtue of that right, they freely determine their political condition, and freely pursue their economic, social and cultural development.”

The question of “free determination” triggers the sharpest objections from the governments that criticise the draft declaration as a risk to sovereignty and a threat of secession and the disintegration of countries.

Closely linked to that argument, the governments question the term “indigenous peoples” because the existence of a “people” and its respective culture constitutes the requisite for recognition as a nation.

Indigenous leaders, however, say free determination can take on a variety of forms. They argue that denial of free determination amounts to racism and discrimination, because the UN charter proclaims the right to self-determination for all people without distinctions.

With such unpromising precedents, “we are not confident that the United States, Brazil and Argentina will take a different position in the OAS,” said Huilcaman.

But “our main aim is to influence the OAS process,” and the chief effect of the initiative will be to get the inter-American community “to understand the need to recognise our rights,” Huilcaman added. A declaration that fails to reflect the main aspirations of indigenous peoples “would lack any legitimacy whatsoever,” he asserted.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags