Headlines, Middle East & North Africa

POLITICS-MIDDLE EAST: Foreigners Marry Into Middle Eastern Divide

Virginia Quirke

RAMALLAH, WEST BANK, Dec 18 2000 (IPS) - If he had stayed in his native Ireland, his children would not need to be escorted to school everyday in a bullet-proof bus.

If she had stayed in her native Ireland, her children would not be growing up under the oppression of Israeli occupation.

Two Irish people, one married to an Jewish settler, the other to a Muslim Palestinian, can only wonder at how the other lives.

Menachem Copperman, 25, is welcoming in his small living room, lined wall-to-wall with Jewish study books. As he waits for the kettle to boil, the morning sun slowly creeps over the hills and unleashes its golden rays into the room. Copperman slowly begins to unfold his few memories of growing up in Ireland in the late seventies.

His claim to fame, he begins, is his picture which hangs in Dublin’s only Jewish museum. He was the first to be circumcised in his local synagogue.

The religiously observant family lived happily with their secular neighbours in Dublin. But when Copperman was still a child, his father decided to pack the family bags and head for the Promised Land.

Ann Daly, 39, lives only a 30-minute drive away from Irish Jew Menachem Copperman, but she lives in another world.

Having qualified as a nurse, she left Ireland in 1985 to offer her services as a volunteer in the Holy Land.

During her first week at St. Joseph’s hospital in East Jerusalem, she met the man who was to become her future husband.

Twenty-two years later, Menachem Copperman lives with his Jewish wife and two children in the fiercely idealistic Jewish settlement of Beit El, on the outskirts of the Palestinian- controlled West Bank town of Ramallah.

On the hilltop settlement, he is shielded from the surrounding Palestinian area by a military base and tight security at the entrance.

Fifteen years, and six children later, Ann Daly lives with her husband in the occupied East Jerusalem neighbourhood of Ras Al- Amud.

This village is exposed to extremist Jewish settler groups which enjoy wide public support in their effort to take over as much Palestinian property as possible.

While the last 12 weeks of violent clashes between Israelis and Palestinians have shown no signs of waning and the death toll spirals out of control, the relationship between Jews and Arabs living on the same piece of land has never been so strained.

“This on-going violence really makes life difficult,” Copperman says. “Not only do our children have to go to school in bullet- proof buses, I have to drive around with rock-proof shields on my car windows to protect passengers from angry Palestinian stone throwers.”

“It’s not fair the way we have to live now. I would like to be able to travel everywhere like before,” he says, pondering on the more subdued era when he and his wife would do their shopping in the nearby Palestinian town of Ramallah.

In 1987, all that changed. Palestinians who had lived for years under the frustrating conditions of Israel’s harsh occupation measures including the expropriation of land, arrests, imprisonment, torture and house demolitions, could take no more.

1987 saw the beginning of the first Intifada, the Palestinian uprising.

This second uprising, which began on 29 September, is another explosive reaction to the life Palestinians have been enduring since then.

Like Copperman, Daly lives in a constant situation of fear and anxiety – but her fear is directed towards the Israelis.

As she stands on the flat rooftop of her East Jerusalem Arabic house, she points towards the nearby Israeli settlement which is growing up around her. She dreads the day Israelis will occupy those apartments.

Daly too worries about the security of her husband and children.

Suspicion and anger, she says, is eating at the heart of many Jewish and Palestinian people during this Intifada. So much so that Daly is afraid to venture into Jewish areas, such as the popular Israeli shopping mall in West Jerusalem with her Palestinian husband.

“I am not comfortable there, not with my husband. If something happened like a bomb or somebody was killed, he could be immediately attacked by the Jews.”

According to Copperman, Arabs and Jews should be able to live side by side.

Furthermore, he denies that Palestinians suffer from any infringements of their rights to freedom of movement, despite the number of discriminatory methods that apply only to Palestinians.

“I don’t think we are occupying them,” he says of the Palestinians. “Our destiny is to live together. Anyway, five million Jews here are not going to leave.”

Daly treats Copperman’s notion that the Palestinian people enjoy freedom of movement, with disdain.

“Do you call that freedom of movement when a 20-year-old soldier makes my husband kneel or lie down on the street at the checkpoint while he checks his identity card?”

“Can Palestinians go and pray freely at the Mosque on Friday in Jerusalem without being stopped by Israeli soldiers?” she challenges in a disbelieving tone.

“No nation can tolerate being occupied by another nation,” she states, “and the Palestinians have every right to resist that occupation.”

“In the past, Jews were not welcomed anywhere. Being treated like we are here today is nothing new,” Copperman states, hugging his sleepy three-year-old daughter Ateret, close to his chest. “But this is our homeland. We belong here.”

Palestinian resistance has resulted in over 300 deaths to date, mostly Palestinian, and thousands of lost jobs due to Israel’s grip on the Palestinian economy.

As Israel tightens its blockade of Gaza and the scattered towns across the West Bank, most trade and traffic has been choked, preventing supplies, raw materials and workers from reaching their destinations. Daly cannot sit by and watch any more people suffer.

“Poverty only brings more riots and more problems,” says the mother of six who is volunteering her time for the Palestinian people once again by trying to rustle up support for needy Palestinians from her native homeland.

Furthermore, the Irish nurse has little time for Jewish settlers who complain about their present situation.

“The difference between the Israeli settlers and the Palestinians is that the Israelis have a choice. They can change the situation. The Palestinians cannot change being occupied.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Headlines, Middle East & North Africa

POLITICS-MIDDLE EAST: Foreigners Marry Into Middle Eastern Divide

Virginia Quirke

RAMALLAH, WEST BANK, Dec 18 2000 (IPS) - If he had stayed in his native Ireland, his children would not need to be escorted to school everyday in a bullet-proof bus.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags