Development & Aid, Headlines, Human Rights, Latin America & the Caribbean, Population

RIGHTS/POPULATION-LATAM: Ethnic Minorities Seek ‘Visibility’ in Census

Yadira Ferrer and Tadeo Martínez

CARTAGENA, Colombia, Nov 11 2000 (IPS) - Census experts and representatives of indigenous and Afro-American communities of Latin America meeting in this Caribbean city called on the region’s governments Friday to ensure minorities are included in their countries’ demographic policies.

Some 100 delegates met for the conference “We All Count: Ethnic Groups in Censuses,” which began Wednesday and was organised by Colombia’s National Department of Statistics (DANE), with backing from the Inter- American Development Bank (IDB) and the World Bank.

They discussed ways to ensure that government policies take their various communities into account, and that they are included in any census process, from drafting the questions included in the surveys to interpreting the information gathered.

Several non-governmental representatives stressed that there has been a process of making ethnic groups of African or indigenous origin “invisible” through the failure to include more precise information about them in the census process.

Another concern shared at the meeting was that in conducting a census, the ethnic identity of an individual can be either self-identified or the census-taker subjectively decides the identity for him or her, often producing ambiguous results.

One participant in “We All Count”, who preferred to remain anonymous, said what is needed is a methodology that prevents a variable like ethnicity from being determined by the census-taker or the person being counted, especially in the Americas, where there is a broad range of ethnic and cultural diversity.

Yolanda Bodnar, director of census and demography at DANE, proposed the creation of a Network of Statistical and Socio-Demographic Information on American Ethnic Groups, which would allow sharing and consultation in the processes underway in each country.

Indigenous groups in the Americas have been involved in a cultural revitalisation process for nearly three decades, with an impact “at least legally, on policies and plans in the various national contexts,” Bodnar told IPS.

But the strengthening of the black communities and of other groups, such as gypsies in Colombia, is much more recent, meaning their inclusion in the region’s censuses is just getting started. Brazil and the United States are the exceptions because they have longer histories of counting their minority populations.

Karmen Vargas, a descendant of Africans and member of the Ethnic Community Organisation of Honduras (ODECO), told participants at the Cartagena meeting that there has been “a process of exclusion, discrimination and intolerance through the census processes.”

She said that better methods are needed in order to determine the population of African descendants in Latin America. There are an estimated 150 million African-Americans in the region, including the United States, representing about 30 percent of the total population.

Donald Allen, an African-American member of the Honduras delegation, pointed out that the three-day meeting was historically important because it was the first time civil society groups had met with officials from census institutions and multilateral organisations to study issue of ethnic representation in the region.

But Allen also said that “it is not just a matter of counting us, it is necessary to provide qualitative information about our needs as far as education, health and employment,” which could serve to improve planning and development policies.

Dalila Gómez, a Colombian who is part of the nation’s gypsy community of 8,000, said there are a great number of her people in the Americas, but that many would prefer to ignore them. “Gypsies are also part of American diversity, and if others do not know what we are like, it is unlikely they will respect us,” she said.

The importance of the meeting in Cartagena is that it allows the representatives to see the numerous viewpoints and the articulation “in the diversity of positions and of methodological approaches that exist in the region in the areas of demography and statistics,” DANE anthropologist Elsa Rodríguez told IPS.

In her opinion, ethnic groups “have been touched only tangentially” by Latin American conferences on population and housing, and this week’s meeting in Cartagena is the first to focus on those issues as they affect minority communities.

In the case of Colombia, DANE’s 1993 census recorded under “indigenous and black population” 1,105,499 people, of whom 574,282 were indigenous individuals belonging to the 81 ethnic groups found within Colombian territory, and 603,152 were Afro-Colombian.

The indigenous and black population would represent 0.32 percent of the Colombian population, of 36 million people, according to the 1993 census.

But Rodríguez pointed out that these numbers have varied with the changing situation of the country, as communities have practically disappeared from areas where the decades-long civil war has grown worse, or the government has simply ignored them.

One critical case involves the indigenous peoples of Colombia’s Amazon region, who “are dying from diseases such as malaria, tuberculosis and hepatitis,” said the anthropologist.

The Colombian Constitution of 1991 recognises the “multi-ethnic and pluri-cultural nature” of the nation, and indicates it is the duty of the State to acknowledge and protect that diversity.

Among the established rights is that these communities are to be consulted about development plans or other projects planned in their territories.

But researcher Alberto Yépez says the Constitution has not been enough, and nearly 10 years later the indigenous and Afro-Colombian communities still run up against “major obstacles to enjoying the same rights as the white and mestizo (mixed race) population.”

According to a study by Yépez, just 13.3 percent of indigenous children enter the educational system, whereas the national average for school attendance is 85 percent. Illiteracy among the indigenous population runs as high as 44 percent, while it is 13 percent for the entire Colombian population.

The western department of Chocó, where most of the nation’s black population lives, has the highest poverty rate in the country, as 82 percent of its residents lack access to basic necessities.

Among Colombia’s black population, of every 1,000 children born, 151 die before reaching their first birthday, compared to the national average of 39 deaths per 1,000, said Yépez.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags