Headlines, Human Rights, Middle East & North Africa

RIGHTS-ISRAEL: Botched Raid Throws Spotlight on Activities of Elite Army Unit

Ben Lynfield

JERUSALEM, Sep 5 2000 (IPS) - A botched raid in the West Bank that left three soldiers dead from friendly fire has touched off anguish in Israel and raised troubling questions about an elite army unit that specialises in undercover activities among the Palestinians.

The commander of forces in the West Bank, Brig. Gen. Shlomo Oren, and the leader of the unit, identified only as Lt. Col. Micky, resigned Thursday amid the uproar over the failed raid, carried out on Aug. 26. Its target, Islamic Resistance Movement (Hamas) leader Mahmoud Abu Hnoud, escaped from Asira al-Shamaliya village to the nearby city of Nablus which is controlled by the Palestinian Authority.

The unit, Duvdevan (cherry), is also under criticism on moral grounds. Dovish Israelis believe it may be endangering the lives of Palestinian civilians during its secretive night-time operations in the West Bank. A 73- year old Palestinian, Mahmoud Abdallah, was fatally shot on the roof of his house two weeks ago in Surda village, near Ramallah, by Duvdevan soldiers.

Apparently believing they were thieves, Abdallah had called on them to identify themselves and then opened fire into the darkness with a pistol, according to his son Hisham.

The army at first apologised for the shooting, but Chief of Staff Shaul Mofaz later termed the tragedy “a successful operation” by Duvdevan.

“Altogether when it comes to Duvdevan, we need an outside probe,” said Galia Golan, spokeswoman for the peace movement Peace Now. “The whole issue of human rights in the occupied territories has always been terrible. There has been killing of Palestinians in a wanton way for years,” Golan added.

Army spokesman Yarden Vatikai countered: “The lives of Palestinians are as valued as those of Israelis. There is not a single activity in which we don’t try to save lives. We give medical assistance and there are hundreds of cases in which we save people.”

Army officials add that Duvdevan’s activities foil terrorist actions against Israel. Israeli leaders are concerned that Hamas may be on the verge of staging an attack, hence the raid on Abu Hnoud who is wanted in connection with lethal bombing attacks against civilians. Security has also been tightened in public areas of Jerusalem.

Army officers have given differing accounts about what the troops were doing outside the Abdallah house in Surda, at first revealing they were looking for a fugitive terrorist and then saying that the army had never divulged the purpose of a mission and “will not do so now.”

Israeli journalist Arnon Regular, who investigated the episode for the Kol Ha’ir newspaper, said the soldiers outside the Abdallah house were “familiarising themselves with the terrain” in the event of hostilities stemming from a Palestinian declaration of independence, which is expected to be issued by the end of the year.

Mofaz, in remarks Sunday, spoke of the “built up terrain with much vegetation”in Surda in describing the army activity.

Israel has warned the Palestinians of dire consequences if they unilaterally, declare statehood and the army has reportedly been grappling with how to keep the upper hand in the environs of Ramallah.

Mofaz, in explaining why he thought the Surda activity was successful, told reporters “They arrested those they were supposed to arrest and they harmed whoever tried to harm them”.

In fact, there were no arrests in Surda, although Hisham Abdallah, a journalist for Agence France-Presse, was questioned twice by the Shin Bet intelligence service and then released.

In both incidents, standing orders for apprehending fugitives were followed. The areas were sealed off, and soldiers barred ambulances from approaching. Army officials say that in situations in which troops have been fired upon, they must close off the area and thoroughly comb it for gunmen before allowing anyone to enter.

Vatikai said army investigators “see no connection between the two” incidents.

Soon after the Aug. 26 raid in Assira al-Shamalliya, the army bulldozed the house of Nidal Darlas amid unproven charges that he had harboured Abu Hnoud. Darlas had been shot and wounded by troops earlier during the incident, and, according to press reports, bled for three hours before he was treated.

Amira Hass, Palestinian affairs reporter for the Ha’aretz newspaper, stressed in an opinion column last week that the questions surrounding the two incidents should not be left to army investigators.

“Only civilians can and must examine the reasons for the political failings that cause Palestinians to conclude that Israel, with the disregard it displays towards the sanctity of their lives, has not changed,” she wrote.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags