Headlines, Human Rights, Middle East & North Africa

RIGHTS: Some Positive Developments In The Arab World

Hossam Hassan

CAIRO, Aug 8 2000 (IPS) - Nearly three months after being granted legal status in Egypt, the Arab Organisation for Human Rights (AOHR), has issued a report on the human rights situation in the Arab world, with an ostensible emphasis on the positive.

According to AOHR’s Secretary-General, Mohamed Fayek, “the report does not focus on human rights violations only” but also deals with positive developments.

The first and “most important” in this respect, he stressed, was AOHR’s legal registration agreement with the Foreign Ministry, signed in May, 17 years after the organisation was established.

AOHR was founded on Dec 1, 1983 in Limassol, Cyprus. A recognised member of the Economic and Social Council of the United Nations, the organisation was founded to ensure the respect of human rights and fundamental freedoms of all citizens and residents of the Arab World.

It also works to defend any individual whose human rights are subjected to violation which are contrary to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights .

Other positive developments noted by the report included the liberation of the occupied zone in southern Lebanon, the lifting of the air embargo against Libya, the decline in violence in Egypt and its containment in Algeria.

In addition, the Jordanian government issued a new press law allowing for greater freedom of expression and, together with Egypt, Bahrain, Algeria, Tunisia, Saudi Arabia, Djibouti and Morocco, released thousands of prisoners of conscience.

Nevertheless, the “positives” were followed by a long list of violations monitored in 21 Arab countries in the 248-page report.

The extension of the state of emergency in Egypt, Algeria and Syria declared “unjustifiable”.

Executions without trial were carried out flagrantly over the past three years in Iraq as part of a “prisons clean-up” campaign.

On the other hand, the report objects to the steady rise in the death toll “by the thousands” in Iraq as a result of UN-imposed sanctions, which have been in force for 10 years.

The report monitored “gross” human right violations, “which are the worst of their kind,” in areas of conflict.

The most obvious case in point is “continually denying the Palestinian people their inalienable rights and the marathon-like competition by the Israeli occupation authorities to change the geographic and demographic features of Palestinian land through building (Jewish) settlements.”

This is in addition to the “oppressive” measures used against Palestinians in the occupied territories, the report added.

In Somalia, the “absence of a political will among the Somali leaders was an obstacle to stabilising the situation and establishing law and order.”

Civil war raged on, said the report, and more innocent civilians fell victim to the fighting. “The country was practically divided and the chance to establish peace was lost”.

“Similarly, in Sudan, a peace agreement was jeopardised” by the problem in the south, the assassination of the leader of one of the warring factions and the withdrawal of the most important factions in the negotiations. As the fighting continued, more people were killed and thousands fled their homes, the report noted.

The AOHR received complaints of torture in prisons in Sudan, Tunisia and Yemen. “Some prisoners died in these countries and no serious investigation was carried out to determine the causes of their deaths,” said Fayek.

He also called attention to the phenomenon of “involuntary disappearances,” which are estimated to be in the thousands, in Algeria, Iraq and Lebanon.

Tens of similar cases occurred in Egypt, Sudan and Libya, Fayek said. The report took issue with the ongoing clampdown on Egypt’s Islamist-oriented Labour Party, whose activities and mouthpiece, Al-Shaab, were frozen in May.

It criticised the restrictions imposed on the establishment of political parties in both Egypt and Algeria.

“Despite the guarantees made in the Political Parties Law in Algeria, the (Islamist-oriented) Wafa Party was prevented from being formed. And the existing restrictions in Egypt continued to turn down applications to establish new parties.”

The report voices concern over the Kuwaiti parliament’s rejection of a royal decree allowing for political participation by women.

Similarly, Morocco witnessed protests against granting women more rights.

The report also warns against recent practices by some Arab governments, that falsely accuse local opposition members of being terrorist groups, to cover human rights violations. The report cited Bahrain and Sudan as examples.

“Unfortunately, countries like Bahrain abused the sympathetic view shared by Arab and international public opinion against terrorism. It accused the opposition, which calls for developing the social and political system and enforcing the constitution, of being terrorists and spies for other countries,” noted the report.

The report describes the violence that took place in the southern Egyptian village of Al-Kosheh, which claimed the lives of 21 Christians, as of a “social nature.”

The incidents were described by some foreign press reports as sectarian strife, which angered the Egyptian government at the time.

Asked if the AOHR would participate in monitoring the November parliamentary elections in Egypt, Fayek responded vaguely that “some countries allow monitoring, which is internationally recognised, but others don’t.”

After 17 years of work, “can the AOHR offer a prize to the country that respected human rights the most and name the country that least respected them?” asked one reporter. “It’s our policy not to categorise countries,” replied a smiling Fayek.

Indeed, not only has the AOHR been careful not to provoke Arab governments, but observers believe that, following its agreement with the Egyptian Foreign Ministry, the organisation is expected to avoid causing Egypt any political embarrassment.

Commenting on the AOHR report, Gamal Fahmy, an activist from the Nasserite opposition party said, there was little reason to rejoice as basic human rights continued to be violated in almost every part of the Arab world”.

He noted that “problems such as the right to self-determination for the Palestinian people, liberation of Israeli-occupied territories, tight international economic sanctions against the Iraqi people, armed conflicts in Iraq’s Kurdistan province, southern Sudan and Somalia, not only failed to be resolved but, in some cases, worsened”.

Reactions gathered by IPS, however, indicated that the general public welcome the report for being more open in criticising other Arab countries, a matter which is rare in the region due to sensitivities between Arab neighbouring countries and the lack of freedom of expression especially when it comes to political issues.

“I am moved by what the report mentioned about the plight of the Iraqi people while criticising the UN Sanctions Committee, in charge of approving contracts to supply Iraq with its basic needs of food and medicine in return for selling a limited amount of its oil, for hindering the process and delaying aid,” said Waleed Atwa, a political science student at Cairo university.

“However, I am not convinced of accusing the UN committee of taking the hard-line position while the report ignores the atrocities of Iraqi President Saddam Hussein who is the one who should be blamed for destroying the chances of improving the living conditions of the Iraqi people,” added Atwa.

“One of the main points of the report is highlighting the deteriorating rights of the Palestinian people, which are treated like second-class citizens.

“We need such efforts made by independent organisations to highlight the increasingly repressive measures taken by the Israeli occupation authorities, the expansion of Jewish settlements, plans to Judaise Jerusalem and the manner in which Palestinian rights continue to be ignored,” said Salah-Eddin Hafez, a prominent journalist.

The AOHR report reiterates its strong stand against violence and terrorism.

However, it calls upon security forces in Arab countries fighting militants to battle armed groups within the limits of the law and to put an end to illegal measures such as torture, arbitrary arrests and holding of members of families of wanted suspects as hostages.

“Arab governments should respect the right of persons to have a fair trial and abide by court rulings once those who have been accused are proven innocent,” Salwa Bakr, a novelist, said.

She added that “thousands of political detainees have been arrested in the Arab region under the banner of violating national and international laws.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags