Friday, November 20, 2026
Thalif Deen
- Two international relief agencies have challenged the concept of “humanitarian war” widely used as a justification for Western military action against Kosovo last year.
The two agencies, International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) and Doctors Without Borders, say there is a dangerous confusion now between political action and humanitarian action in military conflicts.
James Orbinski of Doctors Without Borders points out that the so- called “humanitarian war” in Kosovo was an oxymoron. “One cannot use the tools of violence in the name of humanitarianism,” he told reporters.
Orbinski said that military action by the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO) in Kosovo had a clear and obvious political cause.
The “humanitarian” actions of NATO had put civilians at risk. The UN High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) had been effectively sidelined by the military might of NATO and by NATO’s aggressive public relations campaign for a humanitarian justification for its action, he added.
The role of relief agencies in protecting civilians in armed conflicts was the subject of a one-day debate at the UN Security Council Wednesday.
Addressing the Council, Jakob Kellenberger of the ICRC, said that his organisation was seriously concerned with “the weight of words” during NATO military action in the Balkans.
The term “humanitarian” has often been misused, he told delegates. “We have heard talk of a “humanitarian war” or even “coercive humanitarian countermeasures,” he said. These were expressions that “create dangerous confusion as to the respective roles and responsibilities of political actors and humanitarian organisations,” he added.
“The question here is not the validity of coercive action in extreme circumstances. Such action is often a last resort and necessary to protect the civilian population,” he added. Kellenberger argued that coercive action may be essential in situations where there are large scale and systematic violations of human rights and humanitarian law.
But such coercive measures, he said, should be envisaged only in extreme cases. The Security Council has numerous other means at its disposal for enhancing the security of populations – ranging from preventive deployment to the dispatch of peacekeeping and peace-consolidation forces.
In ICRC’s view, he said, the important thing is to distinguish between political and military action aimed at addressing the causes of conflict from humanitarian action aimed at addressing its effects.
The law governing the right to use force, must therefore remain clearly distinct from humanitarian law automatically applicable in the event of military operations. “The legitimacy of the cause being defended can, in no circumstance, exempt a military operation from the obligations laid down in international humanitarian law,” he added.
Orbinski of Doctors Without Borders said that the problem with the 1994 Rwanda genocide was that “no member of the Security Council was able to call a genocide a genocide.”
The US did not want to commit troops after it lost 17 of its servicemen in Mogadishu while serving as part of a humanitarian relief force in Somalia in 1993.
“There should have been an intervention by the Security Council under international law and within existing frameworks. That would not have been a humanitarian intervention, but a genocide intervention,” he said.
In a resolution adopted unanimously Wednesday, the Council indicated its willingness to consider the appropriateness and feasibility of creating temporary security zones and safe corridors for the protection of civilians in situations characterised by the threat of genocide, crimes against humanity and war crimes against civilian populations.
The resolution also underlined the importance of safe and unimpeded access of humanitarian personnel to civilians in armed conflicts.
Secretary General Kofi Annan told the Security Council that the United Nations has sought to strengthen the protection of internally displaced persons, mostly recently in February when a UN official undertook a mission to Burundi to urge the government there to dismantle the ‘regroupement’ camps.
Elsewhere in Africa, he said, the UNHCR is implementing programmes for prevention and response to sexual violence in Tanzania, Kenya, Guinea, Liberia and Sierra Leone. And the United Nations has also successfully negotiated “days of tranquillity” in Angola, East Timor, Sierra Leone and Sri Lanka in order to permit immunisation and vaccination campaigns for children.
Annan said one of his far reaching recommendations was a proposal to create a UN rapid deployment force that could move quickly to prevent the outbreak of conflict and violence.
Canadian Foreign Minister Lloyd Axworthy said that “the protection of civilians requires strengthening our disposition to intervene with force, if necessary.” For the most part, he said, “we know what is needed – faster, more resolute and more effective responses.”
But Ambassador Kishore Mahbubani of Singapore said that the key implication of this is often unmentionable in the Security Council: to save civilians you need effective military forces.
“The question is where will they come from, and who will pay for their costs?, he asked. In the case of East Timor, for example, every Australian taxpayer was asked to pay an additional 1,000 Australian dollars per person. How many taxpayers in democracies are prepared to do this? Mahbubani asked.