Headlines

CULTURE: UNESCO Welcomes US, For a Few Dollars More

Julio Godoy

PARIS, Sep 30 2003 (IPS) - The return of the United States to UNESCO as a full member is both good and bad news, diplomats and commentators say – good for the organisation’s finances, bad for a proposed convention to protect cultural diversity.

The return of the United States to UNESCO as a full member is both good and bad news, diplomats and commentators say.

The U.S. return was led by Laura Bush, wife of President George Bush at the opening session of the 32nd general assembly of UNESCO (United Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organisation) Monday.

"From October 1 the United States will be again a full, active, enthusiast member of UNESCO, to promote peace and freedom, and cooperate with our colleagues to promote education, science and culture all over the world," Laura Bush said.

The U.S. government had announced in September last year that it will rejoin UNESCO. The U.S. quit the organisation in 1984 saying its resources were being mismanaged.

UNESCO general secretary Koïchiro Matsuura welcomed the U.S. decision to rejoin the organisation as good news for the organisation’s finances. "Every year our budget suffers a reduction of around five percent," he said. "Thanks to the U.S. return, our organisation can face the future with less austerity."


The UNESCO budget for 2004-2005 is 610 million dollars. The U.S. government will now pay 53 million dollars a year, and will pay an additional reintegration fee of 5.3 million dollars.

Officials at UNESCO say this is about the only good thing about the U.S. decision to rejoin the organisation. The U.S. returns on several conditions.. The first is an immediate place on the executive council, whose members are elected.

This U.S. demand forced four European countries – Luxembourg, Portugal, Greece, and Monaco – to withdraw their candidatures for the council, making sure that the U.S. ambassador to UNESCO gets elected.

The U.S. government has also declared that it will not accept a proposed convention to protect cultural diversity. This convention was supported unanimously at the UNESCO general assembly in 2001.

The convention sought to protect national cultural goods such as movies and music against rules of international trade set by the World Trade Organisation. The clear aim of the proposed convention was protection from the U.S. movie and music industry.

The convention is not central to the present meeting of the general assembly set to continue until October 18. But UNESCO was due to mandate Matsuura to begin negotiations on the issue. The process was expected to take two years, but its future is now uncertain.

"The U.S. government sees culture as just merchandise," a Latin American diplomat accredited with UNESCO told IPS. "For Washington, there cannot be a cultural policy." The French newspaper Le Monde quoted a UNESCO diplomat as saying: "It’s obvious that the U.S. wants to defend the interest of Hollywood’s powerful studios."

The vast majority of UNESCO member states support such a convention. These include the Group of 77, which represents 135 states from Africa, Asia, and Latin America, France, Canada, and the Organisation Internationale de la Francophonie – a group of some 50 states, which have French as an official or as a second language. Several European countries also back the convention.

The U.S. now faces isolation within UNESCO over this issue. A similar isolation within UNESCO led the government of Ronald Reagan to leave the organisation in 1984. The official explanation at the time was alleged mismanagement of resources, but UN experts say the main reason was issues of control arising from the Cold War.

"Reagan’s decision to leave UNESCO was based on the idea that it acted under communist influence," says John Washburn, a former U.S. diplomat, and director of the U.S. Association for the United Nations.

The main UNESCO debates at the time were focused on the New World Information Order and the New World Economic Order, two schemes proposed by Third World countries to counter the hegemony of the North in the dissemination of news and in world trade.

Reagan’s government fiercely opposed both programmes, and decided to leave the organisation. Washburn says the U.S. decision was counterproductive. "U.S. researchers were forced to create their own forums to discuss issues, whereas their colleagues from other countries benefited from the UNESCO structures."

Some commentators now see the presence of the U.S. President’s wife as special representative to the general assembly of the organisation as an affront in itself.

Laura Bush, a former teacher, has little experience of cultural, educational, or scientific policymaking, and contributes mostly to charity events. "This conveys a certain disdain for a conference in which over 3,000 experts take part, and which will receive five heads of government," Le Monde commented.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Europe, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

CULTURE: UNESCO Welcomes US, For a Few Dollars More

Julio Godoy

PARIS, Sep 30 2003 (IPS) - The return of the United States to UNESCO as a full member is both good and bad news, diplomats and commentators say.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags