Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

//REPEAT//DEVELOPENT-MALAYSIA: Time to Plug Holes in Education System

Anil Netto

KUALA LUMPUR, Jan 24 2000 (IPS) - Malaysia’s overall literacy rate has climbed steadily since the 1970s thanks to its economic take-off, but the improved figures mask a persistent divide in the levels of achievement between urban and rural pupils.

A general census in 1980 showed that the country’s literacy rate was 72 percent, up from 58 per cent in 1970.

By 1991, the level of literacy — the ability to read a letter or newspaper and write a simple letter — had reached 85 percent among Malaysians over 10 years of age. Furthermore, a market research firm’s study showed that the level had risen to 93 percent in 1996 with no significant difference across gender in the ability to read.

The higher levels of literacy, obviously linked to the country’s breakneck economic growth in recent decades, are due to a series of major achievements.

For one, there are now more trained primary school teachers. In 1998, about 95 percent of primary teachers had been trained compared with less than 90 percent in 1990.

Higher enrolments in pre-schools have helped. On a national level some 88 percent of pupils have attended some form of early childhood education — while 96 percent of eligible children are attending primary school, official statistics say.

Easier accessibility to education has also boosted literacy rates. The number of primary schools rose from 6,828 in 1990 to 7,152 in 1999.

These impressive statistics were submitted by the Malaysian government to last week’s regional conference reviewing progress in education by the Asia-Pacific in the last decade. But they failed to highlight the urban-rural divide in Malaysian education.

Says Sahara Ahmad, coordinator of the assessment report of Malaysia’s progress on Education for All: “It’s very difficult to break down into urban and rural because we do not have the breakdown of the student populations in the various states.”

But she does concede that there is a disparity between urban and rural education and recognises the importance of statistics that would highlight the gap.

Experts say this is the next priority after last week’s conference that reviewed progress in the Education for All (EFA) initiative — to work to close this gap now that Malaysia has achieved good overall figures.

“We are hoping to do that in the future because we do see some gaps between rural and urban areas,” especially in the school achievements in national examinations, says Sahara. “That we can see clearly,” adds Sahara, who works in the Educational Planning and Research Division of the education ministry in Kuala Lumpur.

Most rural secondary schools in the country fairly large. Even the smallest school has about 700-800 students because these schools serve a large area with a few feeder primary schools.

In contrast, some rural primary schools have student populations as small as 40 to 50 students. Many of these schools were built to serve one or two ‘kampung’ or villagers, some of which are sparsely populated.

“On the whole, the facilities and resources in rural schools are not as good as urban schools, partly because the people running the urban schools are closer to the administrative centre,” says Dr Molly Lee, associate professor in the School of Educational Studies at the Science University of Malaysia in Penang.

Lee says that drop-out rates are not that serious because most parents realise the importance of education. This points to yet another priority for a country like Malaysia in coming years — reviewing the quality of learning.

“The important thing is whether they (the pupils) learned anything in schools or not,” she explains.

The most serious problem in rural secondary schools is the acute shortage of graduate teachers, most of who shun rural postings. “Even if they are posted to these schools they would ask for a transfer within a year or two,” observes Lee. “So the turnover of teachers is high, which doesn’t contribute to the well-being of the school.”

But Sahara feels the problem in rural schools is not one of high staff turnover. “It’s more about people not wanting to go there,” she says. “We still face a shortage of teachers but we are reducing it.”

Lee points out that some rural secondary schools do not even have proper principals, sometimes for as long as two years. During that time, the schools are run only by senior assistants.

What’s more, the standard of English is extremely bad in rural primary schools, Lee says, “because the English teachers themselves are incompetent in the language”. With such a poor foundation, the pupils invariably find it hard to catch up with their urban counterparts when they go to secondary schools, adds Lee.

The lack of trained teachers is especially serious in Sabah and Sarawak in north Borneo, because teachers from the peninsula are unwilling to be posted to these frontier states.

“I have seen some horrible schools in Sabah and Sarawak,” says Ganesh Rasagam, an activist with the Plantation Workers Support Committee. “The facilities are there. It’s just that the school system is loose. There is no sense of urgency.”

Another weak is the whole rural Tamil-language school system, mainly for Indian Malaysians. These schools are partially aided, which means the government pays the teachers’ salaries — and little else. Not surprisingly, these schools are always struggling for funds to buy equipment, says Ganesh.

“Many of them are in dilapidated condition and crammed,” he adds. “The whole environment in these schools is not conducive for any kind of learning; it’s a depressing atmosphere.”

Likewise, pupils in these schools do not have as much access to pre-school education, even though Malaysia was singled out at the Bangkok review conference as among the East Asian countries with quite huge total increases in early child development.

“Only about 60 percent of Tamil school primary students in Penang have had at least one year of pre-school education, compared with the state’s average of more than 90 per cent,” says Ganesh.

If at all they do attend pre-school, the medium of instruction in the government-run pre-schools is Malay. This often means that the young ethnic Indian pupils face problems switching over to Tamil when they begin their primary education in the Tamil schools.

Rural schools also lack proper remedial education opportunities for slow learners, who then lose motivation as they lag further and further behind their peers and often end up dropping out by the time they reach secondary school.

“Personally, I know children who can’t read or write after nine years in school,” says Ganesh. “There are no remedial classes in many schools and even if there are, the programmes are not creative enough to get the students interested to learn.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags