Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Gustavo González
- The Catholic Church and Masons in Chile have clashed loudly over the issues of divorce, abortion and birth control in the run-up to the Dec 16 legislative elections.
On Tuesday, Jorge Carvajal, Grand Master of Chile’s Masons, lambasted as “domineering” the Catholic hierarchy’s response to a statement by the Grand Lodge published Sunday in the local press.
President Ricardo Lagos, who heads a centre-left coalition, has chosen to stay out of the fray. “This forms part of the democratic debate, and as long as it is conducted with respect, I believe it enriches the country,” said the socialist president.
In their published statement, the Masons complained that elements in the Catholic Church had engaged in “open interventionism” in the upcoming parliamentary elections which went “above and beyond the religious pressure on parliament that has always existed” in Chile.
The Masons were criticising a call issued by a member of the Church hierarchy “for Catholics not to vote in the coming elections for those candidates who are in favour of legalised abortion, a divorce law or the so-called ‘morning-after pill’.
“The call went far beyond the moral limits of any religious creed, since it aimed to impose specific values on the entire country,” added the declaration signed by Carvajal.
The 120 seats of the Chamber of Deputies will be up for grabs in the Dec 16 elections, as will 18 of the 38 popularly elected positions in the Senate, which is also made up of nine designated senators and two senators-for-life.
Polls indicate that the centre-left Coalition for Democracy that has governed this Southern Cone country since democracy was restored in 1990 will lose ground in the elections to the Alliance for Chile, the pact created by the two large right-wing opposition parties.
“Value-based issues” mark the greatest differences between the two blocs, whose social, economic and foreign policy platforms differ little and are based on the development model inherited from the dictatorship of General Augusto Pinochet (1973-90).
The figure of the former dictator, which hung over Chilean politics until the January 2000 presidential elections, has faded into the background since last July, when the courts declared the elderly retired general unfit to stand trial due to “mild senile dementia.”
Although the fate of around 1,000 victims of forced disappearance at the hands of the Pinochet regime remains unclear, human rights issues will play a lesser role in the coming legislative elections than in past polls.
However, the parliamentary elections are approaching just as Congress is debating a law that would make divorce legal in Chile, the only country in the western world, besides the small island state of Malta, where divorce is illegal.
Efforts by conservative anti-abortion groups lobbying for a ban on sales of the “morning-after pill” constitute another element of controversy that will affect the elections.
Cardinal Francisco Javier Errázuriz, archbishop of Santiago and the primate of Chile’s Catholic Church, backs the groups, which protest the contraceptive as an “abortion pill,” and are also opposed to the legalisation of divorce.
Errázuriz and other conservative bishops gave their implicit backing to Cardinal Jorge Medina, who is close to John Paul II in the Vatican, when he issued a call to voters in September urging them not to back candidates “who support divorce, abortion and the morning-after pill.”
The progressive sector of the Catholic Church hierarchy, weakened in the 1980s by a series of appointments of conservative bishops, did not make a unified response to Medina’s declarations, although several bishops discreetly indicated their disagreement.
In its statement, the Masonic Grand Lodge expressed itself in favour of the morning-after pill, pointing out that 150,000 illegal abortions a year were performed in Chile.
The Masons compared the Catholic Church hierarchy’s rejection of the pill with an order issued by Pope Leo XIII, pontiff from 1878 to 1903, that Catholics not be vaccinated against smallpox, which he called “a judgement of God,” likening vaccination to a challenge to heaven.
“With the same authority, modern-day traditionalists can thus say that divorce, regulated abortion and the use of the morning- after pill are ‘a challenge to heaven’,” stated the Masons’ declaration.
“I tend to fear those who label people who think differently as ‘fundamentalists’. It is better to opt for tolerance, if what we are seeking is the good of society,” commented Cardinal Errázuriz in his reply to the Masons.
He added that the declaration by the Grand Lodge “created a strain” in relations between the Catholic Church and Masonry.
Catholic priest Joaquin Alliende, an Episcopal Conference adviser, lamented the “low” treatment of the Catholic Church at the hands of the Masons.
Alliende underlined the spirituality of the Catholic Church, the service it offers “without distinction of religious or political convictions,” and its commitment to human rights, which “benefited numerous members of the Masons when other institutions did not protect them.
“While many of the Masons kept mum, Chile’s bishops were risking their lives,” said the priest, in an allusion to the repression waged by the dictatorship of General Pinochet.
Carvajal said Tuesday that the Catholic Church’s response to the Masons’ declaration was “domineering.” He pointed out that the Masons had stated their views a few weeks ago at a press conference, but that they were not made public by the local media.
Unlike the Catholic Church, the Masons have neither TV nor radio stations, which means they had to divulge their position by placing a paid advertisement in the press on Sunday, the Grand Master explained.
Next year will be the 140th anniversary of Masonry in Chile. Among the most famous members of the fraternity were independence heros Bernardo O’Higgins and José Miguel Carrera, and socialist President Salvador Allende, who was overthrown by Pinochet in 1973.
Chile has 108 Masonic lodges and around 45,000 active Masons.
On the other hand, 70 percent of Chile’s 15.5 million people are Catholics, according to the census, although only 35 to 40 percent of the population are practicing Catholics.
According to opinion polls, more than 70 percent of Catholics are in favour of the legalisation of divorce, and nearly 50 percent back the recent approval of sales of the morning-after pill.